• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Would you buy an electric car?

Would you buy an electric car?

  • yes

    Votes: 25 48.1%
  • no

    Votes: 8 15.4%
  • depends

    Votes: 19 36.5%

  • Total voters
    52

he VW has, as I recall 52 romping stomping Diesel horsepower..The 50 MPG is not magic.
 

My screwball idea is a Diesel/electric powered car.. This works well for the railroads, why not automobiles ?
Forget the greater costs..
Money grows on trees.:rofl
 
I would think die hard greenies would just off themselves seeing how in their mind humans are the problem or at least sterilize themselves.

You just don't understand greenies.. they want to reduce the population by 80%, but they want you to step up to the plate, not themselves.
 

And what does it cost every 3 years for new batteries? What does it cost per mile to recharge? How will it stand up to a collision with an 18 wheeler? Will any of those electric cars pull a 5,000 lb. boat? Do they come in 4 wheel drive?

Until they get those 18 wheel + trucks on their own roads away from me, I'll stick with my 22 MPG extended cab, long bed, 4x4 power stroke.
 
Mark my words most people wont be driving petrol driven cars in 10 years time maybe less.
 

You are aware that our government subsidizes ethanol by about a dollar per gallon, right?... and ethanol gives about 15% less energy per gallon, right?

You do know that transmission losses for electricity is about 8%? Any idea of what the efficiency is for converting fossil fuel into electricity?

What do those batteries cost in that dinky little car, and how often do you have to replace them?
 
You just don't understand greenies.. they want to reduce the population by 80%, but they want you to step up to the plate, not themselves.

Yes, I heard they encouraged suicide...:roll:

Mark my words most people wont be driving petrol driven cars in 10 years time maybe less.

Due to the economic implications of alternative energy for cars I doubt it. Probably longer. Just being skeptical.
 
Yes, I heard they encouraged suicide...:roll:



Due to the economic implications of alternative energy for cars I doubt it. Probably longer. Just being skeptical.

Fair enough time will tell.
 
for those people who only need 20 miles there is something know as A BUS.

I actually think the bus is far more convenient on a cross-country trip than it is on a 20-mile commute. The problems with short bus trips like a work commute is the waiting for the bus and generally longer travel times of the bus due to it making frequent stops and the annoyance of bus transfers.

On a cross country trip waiting an hour at the bus station for the bus isn't such a big deal, they don't make frequent stops like a city bus, and they can drive more hours per day than I can (with multiple bus drivers).
 

In a lot of places trucks aren't allowed on highways or roads.
 

8 percent transmission loss is nothin compared to efficiency of gas motor which loses about 90 percent.

Lost energy is inevitably heat. For gas engine to be efficient it would need to have exhaust at room temperature. You can roughly figure from that how badly gas engines actually suck.
 

That is true... now think about the efficiency of turning oil or coal into electricity.... same rational holds true.

Now store it in a battery. (note the heat given off by a battery charger)

Now turn that electricity into motive power. (ever notice the cooling fins on powerful electric motors?)

Do you still think electric cars are efficient?
 

well what kind of idiot would use oil to produce electricity ?

electricity should be produced from renewable energy sources like wind and solar.
 
well what kind of idiot would use oil to produce electricity ?

electricity should be produced from renewable energy sources like wind and solar.

But that leads to a whole new discussion concerning an electric car during a point where most electricity is produced through renewable energy sources...something that's not currently true.

So until that becomes true, the thing that poster is saying is a legitimate concern in regards to the situation CURRENTLY
 
well what kind of idiot would use oil to produce electricity ?

electricity should be produced from renewable energy sources like wind and solar.

Sounds good..... on paper.


James Schlesinger and Robert L. Hirsch - Getting Real on Wind and Solar - washingtonpost.com

But everyone knows that.
 
Most studies I've seen have shown that the act of charging these vehicles is inefficient and actually will cause more polution than a conventional contemporary engine. If the grid was being mostly fed by nukes then maybe I'd buy one but it would have to sound like a Pontiac GXPR.
 

Until we have almost all of our power supplied by Hydro or Nukes the electric car is just a Greenie delusion... kinda like those spiral florecent light bulbs that, in California, if you break one, by law you have to have a HasMat team come in and clean up the Mercury. :shrug:
 
Sources please?
 
I just saw a SmithsonianHD channel (I think) documentary on ethanol from sugar cane. Apparently Brazil has gone from 80% dependency on foreign oil to <10% dependency by using flexfueled cars and mandating the availabilty of ethanol at the pump. They also showed a sugar cane operation in Hawaii where they take the depleted cane and process it as fuel for their generators which provide electric to the mill and 7% of Maui's total electricity production.

If sugar is bad for you, and we already have a large portion of agricultural resources dedicated to its production, using it this way seems like it could make a significant contribution to the solution of our oil dependence problem without depleting the worlds food supply.

Just please keep the fraud algore away from it!
 


I'd consider trading my left leg for this electric car
 
I trid to answer you but the ervr won't all me to give you the information.
 
It would be easy to make an all wheel drive electric just install four electric motors 1 for each wheel it has been found that most hybrid gas/electric car batteries make over 200,000 miles. As for 5000 pound pulls I don't see a problem there either if the car is designead for it I have worked with electric fork lifts, electric riding pallet jacks etc. A electric pallet jack will run for 0 hours on a single charge lifting pallets that weight up to 3000 pounds same with an electric fork lift, and that is with simple lead acid batteries. I will be satisfied with an electric commuter car that gets me to work and home every day and when I want to haul heavy stuff I will rely on a gas vehicle. Later, when electrics are developed, they Will be able to pull 5000 lb trailers and go 1000 miles on a single charge. They are being suppressed and the car companies know they are superior and what their potential is. The oil mafia is a force that is very powerful I won't say any more on that subject. I value my life. Just consider the fact that GM got a multi billion dollar "bailout" and still was able to go chapter 11 and no one did anything about that. That is my opinion.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…