• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

With cases soaring, Biden to announce COVID-19 task force

The thing is... testing out the wazoo should be happening regardless, and everything is relative.

...

Also the asymptomatic cases are a problem.. a big one. Here in Spain, before you can get a doctors appointment for some sort of treatment or scan, you need a covid test. Here tons of asymptomatic cases (a majority at one point) were discovered. There was no symptoms and hence no idea they had it.. but they were spreading it regardless.
Thanks for the quality comment.

I strongly agree with your first paragraph.

And the last paragraph is key. I just learned from a radio interview that there are two categories for those that test positive: infected versus diseased. A large percentage of positive-test people never get the disease- they are asymptomatic.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the quality comment.

I strongly agree with your first paragraph.

And the last paragraph is key. I just learned from a radio interview that there are two categories for those that test positive: infected versus diseased. A large percentage of positive-test people never get the disease- they are asymptomatic.

Testing isn't perfect and it doesn't appear to be a problem with the test systems but something with the virus itself. A positive is a positive and with minuscule false positive/contaminated specimen cases a positive result can be trusted.

The problem is with the negative results. There are some people who have the virus who continually test negative even though they are symptomatic. These patients went on to have a procedure called a BAL (Bronchoalveolar lavage) - testing those washings was the only way to get a positive test result from these people. We don't understand what it means that such an obviously positive patient is testing as negative and we also don't know the percentage of these false negative people. There is a huge variation of specimen collection techniques too. Some people are just swabbing the nares instead of doing a nasopharyngeal collection. Certainly we are not going to the other extreme and perform an invasive BAL to get specimens for testing though.
We test all patients being admitted into the hospital and do get a few surprise positives from asymptomatic patients who came into the ER with non-Covid related issues.
My point is - don't look to testing as a panacea. It's just a tool. A great tool but not a perfect one.
 
If he would have acted in February and put a task force together and included every state governor and all the experts it could have been controlled. Also Obama gave him a blueprint of what to do if faced with a pandemic and he ignored it. He had plenty of time to prepare.


Guess that's why big daddy government was voted in. Enough information was out there at the time people were fleeing the cities. They were already told to shelter in place and yet still dispersed nationwide - ironically to the South and red states that they proclaim to hate so much. I guess they had to be told not to - oh, wait, they already were told not to - at the local levels. So you're saying the city and state level wasn't good enough?

Sure is going to be interesting to see how any measures created some magic task force of Biden are going to be enforced. Also, I find it ironic how many of the "Not My President" people are now saying they would have followed the lead of President Trump. It's as if people want it both ways.


I just love how the story says they are going to their "beach and country homes". Not the majority - what percentage of people have those? RV sales were through the roof with people needed them as a place to live as they fled. The more common story is like my neighbors 5 brothers and their families that came down from NYC and moved in with my neighbor. There are now 6 families in a single family home.
 
Guess that's why big daddy government was voted in. Enough information was out there at the time people were fleeing the cities. They were already told to shelter in place and yet still dispersed nationwide - ironically to the South and red states that they proclaim to hate so much. I guess they had to be told not to - oh, wait, they already were told not to - at the local levels. So you're saying the city and state level wasn't good enough?

Sure is going to be interesting to see how any measures created some magic task force of Biden are going to be enforced. Also, I find it ironic how many of the "Not My President" people are now saying they would have followed the lead of President Trump. It's as if people want it both ways.


I just love how the story says they are going to their "beach and country homes". Not the majority - what percentage of people have those? RV sales were through the roof with people needed them as a place to live as they fled. The more common story is like my neighbors 5 brothers and their families that came down from NYC and moved in with my neighbor. There are now 6 families in a single family home.

You do realize that there has been a slowing trend in urbanization in the US for the past couple of decades, don't you?

You do realize that 1,000 New Yorkers does not constitute a "horde" (unless you live in Cabot Cove MA), don't you?
 
Unfortunately, in that aphorism, the word "proves" does NOT mean what you think it means.
Funny, I’ve looked everywhere and still can’t find the TU Curmudgeon Dictionary. Maybe it’s only available in Canada?
 
You do realize that there has been a slowing trend in urbanization in the US for the past couple of decades, don't you?

You do realize that 1,000 New Yorkers does not constitute a "horde" (unless you live in Cabot Cove MA), don't you?

So, you're saying only 1,000 people left NYC?
 
I just love the state of delusion the people are in when they scream "NOT MY PRESIDENT" on one side of their mouth and then tearfully say "If only he'd said something we would have listened." with the other. There was NOTHING President Trump could have said or done that wouldn't have been met with resistance. Nothing. It was the people fleeing locked down cities that spread the virus countrywide - not the president.

Explain to me how this country. the one with the most money. the most resources. the smartest doctors. the best epidemiologists. the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics, somehow has the 8th worst per capita death rate in the world regarding covid 19. Go.
 
Trump's middle finger given to the WHO. our CDC and other health care professionals leaves blood all over his hands. Negligent homicide is still homicide. Trump is really not much different than people like Idi Amin or Pol Pot. Genocide of your own people is genocide of your own people...no matter how you slice it.
 
You might be surprised to learn that some countries with HIGHER rates of testing have HIGHER Mortality Rates than the US does.

You might be surprised to learn that some countries with HIGHER rates of testing have LOWER Mortality Rates than the US does.

You might be surprised to learn that some countries with LOWER rates of testing have HIGHER Mortality Rates than the US does.

You might be surprised to learn that some countries with LOWER rates of testing have LOWER Mortality Rates than the US does.


The only number that is truly relevant...240,000 dead Americans. Truly horrendous and completely avoidable.
 
Funny, I’ve looked everywhere and still can’t find the TU Curmudgeon Dictionary. Maybe it’s only available in Canada?

To "prove" something, as the word is used in the saying, means to "test" and does not mean to "establish the truth of".


prove
verb

\ ˈprüv \

proved; proved or proven\ ˈprü-vən , British also ˈprō- \; proving\ ˈprü-viŋ \

Definition of prove


transitive verb
1a : to establish the existence, truth, or validity of (as by evidence or logic)

prove a theorem the charges were never proved in court​

b : to demonstrate as having a particular quality or worth
the vaccine has been proven effective after years of tests

proved herself a great actress​

2 : to show (oneself) to be worthy or capable

eager to prove myself in the new job​

3a : to test the truth, validity, or genuineness of

the exception proves the rule​


prove a will at probate​

(emphasis added)

Which you can get from the Merriam-Webster website <SARC>if it hasn't been blocked by President Biden and his commie cohorts.

I'm sorry that that dictionary is not available in the United States of America. However, you CAN order it on-line from Amazon.ca HERE. However, if Biden's Commie Border Police block you from doing that, contact me directly and I will put you in touch with the Patriotic Free Patritotic American Patriotic Patriots' Patriotic Underground so that you can finally learn what all of those Commie Left-wing Socialist so-called "Educators" have been keeping hidden from you for the past four years whilst Commie Biden has been the President of the United States of America and deliberately spreading COVID-19 whilst Donald John Trump was patrioticly leading the patriotic fight to patriotically save the lives of all Americans, even the Commie Socialist Left-wing traitors who go by the so deceptive name of "Democrats"<SARC>.

Remember what Mr. Trump has ALWAYS said

00-00-03 - Only Fools Wear Masks2.webp
Photo and caption certified as true and correct as of 30 FEB 20
** That NO official record of any contrary statement by Mr. Trump exists
also certified (as of 10 NOV 20) **
by
Winston Smith
Acting [by Presidential Decree] Director
The Federal Legal And Civil Knowledge Bureau
 
In other words...he would deal with the virus by doing the same thing Trump did...including a task force. How original and innovative. :rolleyes:

Trump's task force was okay with deaths in blue states.

Trump's task force was, as everything Trump touched, of negative value.
 
Explain to me how this country. the one with the most money. the most resources. the smartest doctors. the best epidemiologists. the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics, somehow has the 8th worst per capita death rate in the world regarding covid 19. Go.

Now that simply isn't true.

20-11-10 zW2 - Worldometer TOP Deaths per Million TABLE.webp
The US has the 10th worst record.
 
The only number that is truly relevant...240,000 dead Americans. Truly horrendous and completely avoidable.

I don't know about that. I mean, after all that's not even half the number of Americans who died fighting for freedom in WWII, isn't it?

On the other hand

20-11-10 B4 - Daily New Case Averages.webp

doesn't look all that peachy keen, does it?
 
To "prove" something, as the word is used in the saying, means to "test" and does not mean to "establish the truth of".
verb
\ ˈprüv \​
proved; proved or proven\ ˈprü-vən , British also ˈprō- \; proving\ ˈprü-viŋ \​
Definition of prove
1a : to establish the existence, truth, or validity of (as by evidence or logic)​
prove a theorem the charges were never proved in court​

b : to demonstrate as having a particular quality or worth​
the vaccine has been proven effective after years of tests​
proved herself a great actress​

2 : to show (oneself) to be worthy or capable​
eager to prove myself in the new job​

3a : to test the truth, validity, or genuineness of

the exception proves the rule


prove a will at probate​


(emphasis added)

Which you can get from the Merriam-Webster website <SARC>if it hasn't been blocked by President Biden and his commie cohorts.

I'm sorry that that dictionary is not available in the United States of America. However, you CAN order it on-line from Amazon.ca HERE. However, if Biden's Commie Border Police block you from doing that, contact me directly and I will put you in touch with the Patriotic Free Patritotic American Patriotic Patriots' Patriotic Underground so that you can finally learn what all of those Commie Left-wing Socialist so-called "Educators" have been keeping hidden from you for the past four years whilst Commie Biden has been the President of the United States of America and deliberately spreading COVID-19 whilst Donald John Trump was patrioticly leading the patriotic fight to patriotically save the lives of all Americans, even the Commie Socialist Left-wing traitors who go by the so deceptive name of "Democrats"<SARC>.

Remember what Mr. Trump has ALWAYS said

View attachment 67304128
Photo and caption certified as true and correct as of 30 FEB 20
** That NO official record of any contrary statement by Mr. Trump exists
also certified (as of 10 NOV 20) **
by
Winston Smith
Acting [by Presidential Decree] Director
The Federal Legal And Civil Knowledge Bureau
Wow! Desperate much?
 
Explain to me how this country. the one with the most money. the most resources. the smartest doctors. the best epidemiologists. the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics, somehow has the 8th worst per capita death rate in the world regarding covid 19. Go.

1. Obesity - we have an extremely high obesity rate - obesity and Covid do not mix.
2. Because we have the best doctors, the best epidemiologists, the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics we also have people living with - and living longer with - conditions that would otherwise be dead without the best doctors, the best epidemiologists, the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics. These people are more susceptible to worse case scenario Covid cases.
 
The difference is Biden will listen to his team and the experts unlike Trump who thought he was smarter than anyone. That’s the reason the epidemic got so bad here. He ego gets in the way of his common sense.
I look forward to narcoleptic joe making it all go away in-between his lids
 
1. Obesity - we have an extremely high obesity rate - obesity and Covid do not mix.
2. Because we have the best doctors, the best epidemiologists, the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics we also have people living with - and living longer with - conditions that would otherwise be dead without the best doctors, the best epidemiologists, the best hospitals, the very best therapeutics. These people are more susceptible to worse case scenario Covid cases.

I thought that you might be interested in a list of the "Top 50" countries in the world with respect to life expectancy. Unfortunately you do have to scroll down a bit to get to the US.

20-11-11 Average Life Expectancy.webp
 
I thought that you might be interested in a list of the "Top 50" countries in the world with respect to life expectancy. Unfortunately you do have to scroll down a bit to get to the US.


Yes? And I said "living with - and living longer with". In 1950 the life expectancy was just at 68 years. In 1960 the obesity rate was 14% - today it approaches 50% and yet our life expectancy still went up through those years. That falls into my "living longer with" category. It isn't that the patients magically became healthier - its that they were living longer in spite of themselves. Any healthcare system can only do so much when the patients are clearly working against it. In 1959 there were roughly 1 million people with type 2 diabetes - by 2016 that number increased to 24-ish million. Even the UK is no longer seeing rises in life expectancy and recently theirs fell by 6 months. It's so easy to criticize a statistic that only shows the end result and not the nuances. But then if you know anything of statistics you'll know of "There are lies, damn lies, and then there are statistics." There was another saying I recall - something like "There's a reason you don't see an elderly obese person. "
 
Back
Top Bottom