• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Why isn’t the GOP stopping Trump from hurting US farmers while helping those in Argentina?

WisconIndependent

DP Veteran
Joined
Nov 3, 2023
Messages
2,498
Reaction score
3,244
Gender
Male
Beyond Trump’s tariffs giving the China grain markets to Argentina farmers and giving up to 40 billion to their government while letting our children go hungry, now he is going to allow Argentina’s cattlemen to dump beef on our markets. Once again Trump cars little about our farmers in a stupid attempt to curry favor with lower beef prices. I,know he knows nothing about farming, but if left alone, cattlemen in this country will quickly increase the amount of beef on the market and prices will come down. If Trump allows Argentina beef, then many of our farms will just go under. America first, not so much.
 
Beyond Trump’s tariffs giving the China grain markets to Argentina farmers and giving up to 40 billion to their government while letting our children go hungry, now he is going to allow Argentina’s cattlemen to dump beef on our markets. Once again Trump cars little about our farmers in a stupid attempt to curry favor with lower beef prices. I,know he knows nothing about farming, but if left alone, cattlemen in this country will quickly increase the amount of beef on the market and prices will come down. If Trump allows Argentina beef, then many of our farms will just go under. America first, not so much.
Can we drop this "children go hungry" nonsense? The poor in America are already over-represented in obesity.
 

Why isn’t the GOP stopping Trump from hurting US farmers while helping those in Argentina?​

Because Trump isn't hurting US ranchers. He's giving them...and American beef consumer...some breathing space so that US ranchers can rebuild their herds.
 

Why isn’t the GOP stopping Trump from hurting US farmers while helping those in Argentina?​

Because Trump isn't hurting US ranchers. He's giving them...and American beef consumer...some breathing space so that US ranchers can rebuild their herds.
Hmm…the ranchers don’t seem to see it that way.
 

Why isn’t the GOP stopping Trump from hurting US farmers while helping those in Argentina?​

Because Trump isn't hurting US ranchers. He's giving them...and American beef consumer...some breathing space so that US ranchers can rebuild their herds.
Did you make that up all on your own or is that the latest MAGA hive mind talking point?
 
Beyond Trump’s tariffs giving the China grain markets to Argentina farmers and giving up to 40 billion to their government while letting our children go hungry, now he is going to allow Argentina’s cattlemen to dump beef on our markets. Once again Trump cars little about our farmers in a stupid attempt to curry favor with lower beef prices. I,know he knows nothing about farming, but if left alone, cattlemen in this country will quickly increase the amount of beef on the market and prices will come down. If Trump allows Argentina beef, then many of our farms will just go under. America first, not so much.
Im all for lower beef prices.
 
Kids are obese, they don’t need food. - MAGA

I think you should put that on a bumper sticker.
But then why is Trump trying to lower the cost of food by importing from other nations at the expense of American ranchers?

Oops I forgot this is Trump, trying to do two mutually exclusive things at once is the norm for him
 
Here is an article that actually tries to explain WHY beef prices are high right now instead of just quoting ranchers who are pissed off that Trump is taking steps to bring those prices down.

And no, the price increases aren't due to tariffs. As the Associated Press reported, one of the issues is America's shrinking cattle supply, which has been decreasing for the past twenty years. It noted that as of the start of 2025, the U.S. had 86.7 million cattle and calves, the lowest number since 1951.

And that's not all. As Food & Wine reported in late 2024, a flesh-eating parasite called the New World screwworm (NWS) was found in cattle in Mexico and is spreading north. This led the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) to restrict the "importation of animal commodities originating from or transiting Mexico, effective immediately and pending further information from Mexican veterinary authorities on the size and scope of the infestation." And, as we predicted, this resulted in a significant drop in cattle imported into the United States, which already has far fewer cattle than in years past.

“It happened overnight, and in an environment where we already have tight supplies, we’re going to end up in a spot where we’re going to have tighter supplies," Charley Martinez from the University of Tennessee shared with Brownfield Ag News at the time. “You have feed lot operators that are needing cattle now, and they no longer have a supplier, and they’re going to have to go out to the sale barns and go look for cattle … Well, that’s actually going to cause a short-run demand increase, and as demand increases, prices increase.”

Then, there's climate change. The AP noted that a three-year drought, which started in 2020, dried out many pastures, leading to higher feed prices and forcing cattle ranchers to slaughter more female cattle to meet beef demand, which in turn reduced their herd sizes in subsequent years.

“For them, the balance is, ‘Do I sell that animal now and take this record high check?’ Or do I keep her to realize her returns over her productive life when she’s having calves?” David Anderson, a livestock economist at Texas A&M, told the AP. “And so it’s this balancing act, and so far the side that’s been winning is to sell her and get the check.”


Now...I sympathize with US ranchers, but the fact is they have NOT been the ones meeting the US demand for beef for years. Other countries have been doing that. US ranchers have been cashing in with the higher prices and the US consumers have been paying for it.
 
Here is an article that actually tries to explain WHY beef prices are high right now instead of just quoting ranchers who are pissed off that Trump is taking steps to bring those prices down.

And no, the price increases aren't due to tariffs. As the Associated Press reported, one of the issues is America's shrinking cattle supply, which has been decreasing for the past twenty years. It noted that as of the start of 2025, the U.S. had 86.7 million cattle and calves, the lowest number since 1951.​
And that's not all. As Food & Wine reported in late 2024, a flesh-eating parasite called the New World screwworm (NWS) was found in cattle in Mexico and is spreading north. This led the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) to restrict the "importation of animal commodities originating from or transiting Mexico, effective immediately and pending further information from Mexican veterinary authorities on the size and scope of the infestation." And, as we predicted, this resulted in a significant drop in cattle imported into the United States, which already has far fewer cattle than in years past.​
“It happened overnight, and in an environment where we already have tight supplies, we’re going to end up in a spot where we’re going to have tighter supplies," Charley Martinez from the University of Tennessee shared with Brownfield Ag News at the time. “You have feed lot operators that are needing cattle now, and they no longer have a supplier, and they’re going to have to go out to the sale barns and go look for cattle … Well, that’s actually going to cause a short-run demand increase, and as demand increases, prices increase.”​
Then, there's climate change. The AP noted that a three-year drought, which started in 2020, dried out many pastures, leading to higher feed prices and forcing cattle ranchers to slaughter more female cattle to meet beef demand, which in turn reduced their herd sizes in subsequent years.​
“For them, the balance is, ‘Do I sell that animal now and take this record high check?’ Or do I keep her to realize her returns over her productive life when she’s having calves?” David Anderson, a livestock economist at Texas A&M, told the AP. “And so it’s this balancing act, and so far the side that’s been winning is to sell her and get the check.”​

Now...I sympathize with US ranchers, but the fact is they have NOT been the ones meeting the US demand for beef for years. Other countries have been doing that. US ranchers have been cashing in with the higher prices and the US consumers have been paying for it.
The entire Agricultural industry has been largely bought up by mega corporations and conglomerates.

The small farmers can’t compete.

And tariffs on equipment they need, etc don’t help the equation.

All by design.

JD Vance’s early investment in AcreTrader brings in profit when the small guys go under.

🤷‍♀️

Prices in the grocery store will continue to climb. The rich will continue to profit. And Trump gives money to Argentina while Americans can’t even get food stamps.

MAGA ‘Merica.
 
Can we drop this "children go hungry" nonsense? The poor in America are already over-represented in obesity.
Are you that uneducated as to the reason, it is because they have to eat the kinds of food that can make you fat as that is what they can afford.
 
Beyond Trump’s tariffs giving the China grain markets to Argentina farmers and giving up to 40 billion to their government while letting our children go hungry, now he is going to allow Argentina’s cattlemen to dump beef on our markets. Once again Trump cars little about our farmers in a stupid attempt to curry favor with lower beef prices. I,know he knows nothing about farming, but if left alone, cattlemen in this country will quickly increase the amount of beef on the market and prices will come down. If Trump allows Argentina beef, then many of our farms will just go under. America first, not so much.
Why should Trump help U.S. farmers when he can get a cut from Argentina?
 
Are you that uneducated as to the reason, it is because they have to eat the kinds of food that can make you fat as that is what they can afford.
What special food is it that they absolutely "have to" eat that makes them fat? Go on, tell us uneducated folks.
 
Nope.

Shows your character though.

F*ck them kids is a real good look.
I'm simply informed and understand that shoveling more food into obese children's mouths won't make things better for them in the long term. You, on the other hand, prefer virtue signaling.
 
Back
Top Bottom