What "well regulated" means in the 2nd Amendment

[danielpalos]

You brought it up Eminent Domain saying it applies to slavery. You don't know it but you've just expressed am appeal from ignorance.

Now explain was it is and give an example of how it might apply.


Give an example of an "appeal to/from ignorance"
Give an example of a "general" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense

Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

I gainsay your contention. How would eminent domain not apply as federal public policy regarding abolition?

 

[Rich2018]

...how would eminent domain not apply as federal public policy regarding abolition?

That's called an appeal from ignorance.

Because you can't think of a reason, does not make the opposite case true.


Still waiting for your examples of:
Eminent Domain
Appeal to/from ignorance
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

 

[danielpalos]

That's called an appeal from ignorance.

Because you can't think of a reason, does not make the opposite case true.

You appeal to ignorance by claiming eminent domain wouldn't apply. There is no appeal to ignorance of the law in this frivolous venue, unless you are just trolling.

 

[Rich2018]

You appeal to ignorance by claiming eminent domain wouldn't apply. There is no appeal to ignorance of the law in this frivolous venue, unless you are just trolling.

What is "an appeal from/to ignorance" ?

What does "Eminent domain" mean ?


Still waiting for your examples of:
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

 

[danielpalos]

What is "an appeal from/to ignorance" ?

What does "Eminent domain" mean ?


Still waiting for your examples of:
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

You are still appealing to ignorance of the whole and entire concept of eminent domain.

Eminent domain in the United States - Wikipedia

 

[Rich2018]

You are still appealing to ignorance of the whole and entire concept of eminent domain.

Eminent domain in the United States - Wikipedia

What is "an appeal from/to ignorance" ?
Give an example


That link on Eminent domain shows that it does not and cannot apply to slavery
Have you even read that link, let alone understood it ? Your link doesn't mention slavery once




Still waiting for your examples of:
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

 

[danielpalos]

What is "an appeal from/to ignorance" ?
Give an example


That link on Eminent domain shows that it does not and cannot apply to slavery
Have you even read that link, let alone understood it ? Your link doesn't mention slavery once




Still waiting for your examples of:
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

You got it wrong the first time and you are still wrong now since you deliberately appeal to ignorance of the law in this frivolous venue. Thank Goodness for our federal doctrine of separation of powers. Show us how our welfare clause General and the power of eminent domain doesn't apply to Any given contingency our Congress may need to respond to.

 

[Rich2018]

You got it wrong the first time and you are still wrong now since you deliberately appeal to ignorance of the law in this frivolous venue. Thank Goodness for our federal doctrine of separation of powers. Show us how our welfare clause General and the power of eminent domain doesn't apply to Any given contingency our Congress may need to respond to.

What is a definition of "an appeal from/to ignorance" ?
Give an example


What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?




Still waiting for your examples of:
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

 

[danielpalos]

What is a definition of "an appeal from/to ignorance" ?
Give an example


What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?




Still waiting for your examples of:
"General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.

There is no such Thing as a well regulated militia of Individuals in our Republic.

 

[Rich2018]

There is no such Thing as a well regulated militia of Individuals in our Republic.

Every state has a militia


The second amendment says such militias should be "well regulated"

And absolutely the people in the USA aren't some Borg collective, they're a nation of individuals.

Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.



Still waiting for:
Examples of "General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense
What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?
Definition and examples of an "appeal to/from ignorance"

 

[danielpalos]

Every state has a militia


The second amendment says such militias should be "well regulated"

And absolutely the people in the USA aren't some Borg collective, they're a nation of individuals.

Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.



Still waiting for:
Examples of "General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense
What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?
Definition and examples of an "appeal to/from ignorance"

Every State, not Individuals of the People. The State has clear jurisdiction over the militia of the State.

 

[Rich2018]

Every State, not Individuals of the People. The State has clear jurisdiction over the militia of the State.

The militia is made up of people or "invididuals"

The 2A says a militia should be "well regulated"


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.




Still waiting for:
Examples of "General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense
What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?
Definition and examples of an "appeal to/from ignorance"

 

[danielpalos]

The militia is made up of people or "invididuals"

The 2A says a militia should be "well regulated"


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.




Still waiting for:
Examples of "General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense
What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?
Definition and examples of an "appeal to/from ignorance"

You still appeal to ignorance of the law. And simply troll without clue and without Cause.

 

[Rich2018]

Just a side thought;
In today's world, with all that is happening, and could happen, would you feel safer owning a firearm or not. What is the priority, a false sense of security or the your, or your family's, security?
I want no replies, I just want you to Think.
Thanks .....

I would feel less safe owning a hand gun.

If you really feel you're under threat in your own home or that a post apocalyptic society is almost upon us, buy a shotgun.

 

[Casper]

I would feel less safe owning a hand gun.

If you really feel you're under threat in your own home or that a post apocalyptic society is almost upon us, buy a shotgun.

Nope the apocalypse is not here, yet.
Don't need to buy anything I already have my "arsenal" with spare parts, tools, and all the ammo I would ever need.
I do agree, you probably would not be safer with a handgun, plus the public would probably be less safe, so thanks for remaining unarmed.

 

[Rich2018]

...you probably would not be safer with a handgun, plus the public would probably be less safe, so thanks for remaining unarmed.

Nope and neither would anyone else be.

 

[Casper]

Nope and neither would anyone else be.

So you agree you should not own firearms, see we can see eye to eye.

 

[Rich2018]

So you agree you should not own firearms, see we can see eye to eye.

Yes and neither should anyone else.

 

[Casper]

Yes and neither should anyone else.

And I and Millions of other disagree, so here is a deal, you don't own them and I will own them, everyone gets their choice.

 

[Aberration]

Hawaii and Maryland have stiff gun controls, no reaction there


You seem to have forgotten what you were asked for evidence of though.

They do. So what? What’s that have to do your proposal to amend the Constitution so amendments take only a majority so you an get rid of the 2A?

I have not forgotten. The question seems irrational. What is it you’re petulantly demanding evidence of?

 

[Aberration]

What "well regulated" means in the 2nd Amendment

The militia is made up of people or "invididuals"

The 2A says a militia should be "well regulated"


Explain how an armed and mustered militia could eradicate crime and what actions they could take that current law enforcement isn't already doing.




Still waiting for:
Examples of "General" and a "common" policy/law with regard to welfare and defense
What is a definition of Eminent domain and an example of it ?
Definition and examples of an "appeal to/from ignorance"

The 2A does not say a militia should be well regulated. Even if it did, saying something should be does not grant power or authority. What it says is that a well regulated militia is necessary for the security of a free State. Which means your intended regulations are a threat to the security of our free State.

 

[Rich2018]

Re: What "well regulated" means in the 2nd Amendment

The 2A does not say a militia should be well regulated. Even if it did, saying something should be does not grant power or authority. What it says is that a well regulated militia is necessary for the security of a free State. Which means your intended regulations are a threat to the security of our free State.

“A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.” "


Bolded just so you can see it more easily.

 

[Rich2018]

And I and Millions of other disagree...

"A hasty generalization is a general statement without sufficient evidence to support it. A hasty generalization is made out of a rush to have a conclusion, leading the arguer to commit some sort of illicit assumption, stereotyping, unwarranted conclusion, overstatement, or exaggeration..."


15 Logical Fallacies You Should Know Before Getting Into a Debate | The Quad Magazine

 

[Rich2018]

They do. So what?

So there was no public reaction to them

I have not forgotten. The question seems irrational. What is it you’re petulantly demanding evidence of?

You have tried to

You seemed to claim there'd be some sort of public reaction to stricter gun control, but failed to provide any evidence

Indeed in the states I mentioned there was none.


So it looks like you're making wild claims unsupported by any evidence at all, that your quite unable to substantiate.

 

[RF667799]

"A hasty generalization is a general statement without sufficient evidence to support it. A hasty generalization is made out of a rush to have a conclusion, leading the arguer to commit some sort of illicit assumption, stereotyping, unwarranted conclusion, overstatement, or exaggeration..."


15 Logical Fallacies You Should Know Before Getting Into a Debate | The Quad Magazine

The authors didn't intend you use that as an instruction manual.