• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Washington high school coach placed on leave for praying on field


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abington_School_District_v._Schempp
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Fe_Independent_School_District_v._Doe
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engel_v._Vitale
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lee_v._Weisman

In short, the courts have ruled this way: There is no issue with students having their own prayers, etc. It's a different matter when a school official does it in their capacity as a school official. The collection of cases in similar matters have established this as a fact. If he was offered accommodations to pray in, and he refused, he has even less ground to stand on.
 
Public universities receiving public funds:





It happens every Saturday.
 
d0gbreath said:
Why does he have to walk out to mid-field? The sideline prayers cannot be heard by Jesus?
Click to expand...

Best post among a pile of repetitive chanting postings.

It isn't that Jesus can't hear him on the sidelines, it is so he can draw everyone's attention to himself.

Prayer isn't prohibited in school. Everytime there is a math test you know there are some silent prayers being made.
 
Can't say, "Merry Christmas "because it might offend someone. Pretty soon we won't be able to sing the national anthem at sporting events. I thought this was supposed to be a nation of tolerance. We're supposed to be tolerant of gays and numerous religions but gays don't have to be tolerant of someone's religious beliefs and different religions don't have to be tolerant of us saying "Merry Christmas" or praying at schools and football games. I guess tolerance is just a one way street.
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065196140 said:
I have an advanced degree in leadership. I know how to utilize people's strength's to advance a common cause and overcome narrow mindedness and pettiness.

It appears you have much to learn.
Click to expand...

Really? I'm sure Dick Cheney would probably have the same opinion about himself...but that wouldn't make him a good leader.

I've known quite a few senior Navy officers in my time (one who went on to work directly for Cheney, strangely enough) - and from day one, officers are taught how to lead. Thing is, one can learn reams about leadership, yet still be clueless about how to be a good leader. It's a lot like painting - you can learn all there is to know about painting, but that doesn't mean you should be allowed anywhere near a canvas, that you still could only be trusted with painting a house. Leadership's the same way - no matter how well you know the mechanics and principles, if you aren't able to apply them as a true artist applies that paint brush to a canvas, then you'll never be a good leader.

Personally, I don't enjoy being the leader...but I do know what it feels like to be directly responsible for the careers and the lives of my subordinates. I know the joy of guiding them to advance and to succeed...but I also know what it feels like to be the one ending their careers - two of whom were my friends, one of whom was my neighbor. More than once I've laid my career on the line to help someone else - not because I didn't care about my career, but because it was the right thing to do...and it took me a long time to realize that it was precisely that idealism that kept me from being more successful as a leader. But you know what? To me, remaining true to myself is far more important than power over others...

...and I've seen too many "leaders" for whom power was an end that justified any means.

So...please don't try to intimidate me with your "advanced degree" in leadership. You may well have precisely that and good on you, I'm honestly happy for you...but don't try to tell me that what you were taught makes you a good leader. It doesn't.
 

I must have missed something, but who said you can't say "Merry Christmas?" Can we still say "Happy New Year," or did that one change too when I wasn't paying attention. Gotta know these things with the season coming up and all.
 

I know he's been doing this for years, and people have joined, or not, as they chose. If you have any evidence of any coercion or pressure, please provide it. Otherwise, just be happy you live in a place that still enjoys such freedoms, though it sounds like if you get your way, freedoms like this will be a thing of the past.
 
CMPancake said:
There's nothing wrong with praying. I never said that was the case.
Click to expand...

None of us have.

He can "pray" all he wants.

He should not do it in the center of a football field where the players he coaches can be intimidated into having to join him.

I don't think some of these people get that.
 
Glen Contrarian said:
The coach did not overtly or explicitly pressure anyone...but his actions IMPLICITLY pressured the students to join in. If you don't get this, then you've a lot to learn about leading people.
Click to expand...

Exactly!
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065196140 said:
I have an advanced degree in leadership. I know how to utilize people's strength's to advance a common cause and overcome narrow mindedness and pettiness.

It appears you have much to learn.
Click to expand...

Think about what you just wrote!

The coach apparently knows how to utilize people to advance a cause.

That is what some of us are objecting to.

Perhaps it is you who has much to learn.
 

You just do not get the nature of subtle coercion, Moon.

Under any circumstances...he was asked to stop the public display; he didn't; a penalty was exacted.

Justice on all sides.
 
Frank Apisa said:
None of us have.
Click to expand...

This was in response to American who was most likely under the assumption I had in issue with prayer after sports games.

Frank Apisa said:
He can "pray" all he wants.
Click to expand...

I agree.

Frank Apisa said:
He should not do it in the center of a football field where the players he coaches can be intimidated into having to join him.
Click to expand...

It's been stressed throughout the article that the coach doesn't force or coerce his players to join him in prayer. Do you have anything that can actually support your claim that the players felt pressured to join the coach in prayer

Frank Apisa said:
I don't think some of these people get that.
Click to expand...

Sadly if there's anyone out of the loop, it is the people who suggest a coach should lose his job for whispering sweet nothings to his sky daddy.
 
CMPancake said:
It's been stressed throughout the article that the coach doesn't force or coerce his players to join him in prayer.
Click to expand...

The fact that he goes out to the center of the football field in full view of the attendees and "prays"...IS coercive on young people.

Young people are often "coerced" subtly by peers, CM...what on Earth would make you think they would not be uber coerced by a coach who has authority over them...who assigns playing time...who chooses starting assignments...and by the reaction of the people in the stands to anyone not willing to join in the hoping going on in the center of the field.

The amount of coercion here is enormous!



Do you have anything that can actually support your claim that the players felt pressured to join the coach in prayer.
Click to expand...

Do you mean besides the common sense nature gave me...and the fact that I can think?



Sadly if there's anyone out of the loop, it is the people who suggest a coach should lose his job for whispering sweet nothings to his sky daddy.
Click to expand...

He was not penalized for "praying"...he was penalized for not following the schools rules.
 
Frank Apisa said:
The fact that he goes out to the center of the football field in full view of the attendees and "prays"...IS coercive on young people.
Click to expand...

That's your opinion.

Frank Apisa said:
Young people are often "coerced" subtly by peers, CM...
Click to expand...

Sure, but as stated in the article the students joined on their own accord. They even interviewed players and confirmed this. Your continued speculation that the students were somehow forced into these prayer circles is unfounded nonsense.

Frank Apisa said:
what on Earth would make you think they would not be uber coerced by a coach who has authority over them...
Click to expand...

I have my reasons to believe that the students didn't pray against their will because several students have claimed they do so willingly.

Frank Apisa said:
who assigns playing time...who chooses starting assignments...
Click to expand...

If you're suggesting the coach provides incentive for players to join him in prayer we will need to see something to validate these suspicions.


Frank Apisa said:
and by the reaction of the people in the stands to anyone not willing to join in the hoping going on in the center of the field.
Click to expand...

What?

Frank Apisa said:
The amount of coercion here is enormous!
Click to expand...

Odd, I watched this video of the coach praying at the 50 yard line and I didn't feel the need to pray. The same can be said for when I was in high school when they had prayer circles before games.

Frank Apisa said:
Do you mean besides the common sense nature gave me...and the fact that I can think?
Click to expand...

You have plenty of assumptions about the personal dynamic between the players and coaches at a Washington high school but until you can at least provide testimony that a player felt he was forced to join in on a huddle to thank god for watching over them instead of the starving children in Africa.

Frank Apisa said:
He was not penalized for "praying"...he was penalized for not following the schools rules.
Click to expand...

A school rule that specifically stated he wasn't allowed to pray in public on public school grounds. The argument isn't whether or not the Coach violated school policy but rather is the coach allowed to pray on school grounds after football games?
 

The school has policy; he was warned he was violating that policy; he continued to violate it; he was suspended.

You have a problem with that...take it up with the school.

I do not think they suspended him for praying...I think they suspended him for violating a policy they established for their employees.

If you have a problem with that...

...tough.
 
Crovax said:
So you think school policy can override the 1st amendment?
Click to expand...

All of our liberties have restrictions upon them. I don't believe you can exercise your second amendment right at school either. Btw, just because I pointed out that this action was legal because it was consistent with school policy, does not necessarily mean that I like the policy. The far right is always keen to pointing out that the law is the law and as such you must follow it. If you don't like it, then work to change it. That's usually your argument when you like the law though. Have the decency to acknowledge that the coaches dismissal is not the issue here being it was consistent with school policy, and that it's the schools policy you have issue with and then see what you can do to effect that.
 
Moon said:
There is no requirement that someone be comfortable when someone else is exercising a right. If that were the standard, then there could be no public discourse at all for fear of making some feel uncomfortable.
Click to expand...

We are given freedom OF religion (or lack thereof). Not freedom FROM religion.
 

Yep, this is what I said yesterday and got a lecture on the First Amendment. We'll see what happens here. I think some people just want to be upset about prayer, and not the specific situation.
 

It's interesting how terrified atheists are of prayer.
 

The dismissal is 100% the issue. Telling someone they can't pray because they are an employee is 100% unconstitutional and far beyond ANY restriction that could be placed on freedom of religion. In fact...i would argue it is the state respecting the lack of religion. Period.

Whoever dismissed the coach should be fired and the district sued.
 

A policy that is unconstitutional. A policy that respects a lack of religion. A government entity cannot make a policy that bans someone from praying. Firing him or dismissing him based on that policy is wrong and unconstitutional. Period. The policy is unconstitutional. Period.
 
Being punished for praying. There is "no war on Christians" but plenty of support for banning them from practicing their faith in view of others. Fire them for praying. This is despicable.
 
Paleocon said:
It's interesting how terrified atheists are of prayer.
Click to expand...

I doubt any atheist is "terrified" of prayer.

I'm not an atheist.

But here is how I feel about prayer:

Every priest, minister, rabbi, imam, monk, nun on this planet is constantly "praying" for peace...and it is a commodity in very short supply.

Why do you think that is?



I know people say prayer can move mountains.

So...I say we have a contest...the agnostic way. All the priests, ministers, rabbis, imams, monks, nuns, and religious people you can gather pray that a small hill on the golf course where I work move...and I will furnish a girl scout with a teaspoon.

We'll see whether the prayer or the girl scout moves more of the "mountain."

How do you think that would work out?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…