• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Uighurs Tell FNC: Better Human Rights at Guantanamo Than in China

Agent Ferris

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 22, 2009
Messages
4,324
Reaction score
915
Location
Past the edge of the universe, through the singula
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
They are now living in a big house with a pool on the beach. **** getting sent to Gitmo should be the best day in their life. Where would you rather live there or in West China?



Damn U.S. getting these guys a house and a pool on the Island paradise of Bermuda. They had a picture of it on the daily show it was pretty nice.
 
Yeah, well I think saying you have better human rights than China is a lot like saying a movie was better than Ultraviolet. I mean, sure it's true; but it doesn't really mean anything.
 
Yeah, well I think saying you have better human rights than China is a lot like saying a movie was better than Ultraviolet. I mean, sure it's true; but it doesn't really mean anything.

Wow. Gitmo is better than China? We've really exceeded expectations, haven't we?
 
Damn U.S. getting these guys a house and a pool on the Island paradise of Bermuda. They had a picture of it on the daily show it was pretty nice.

If they had a decent lawyer they could sue the US so bad they could live like Donald Trump.
 
Damn U.S. getting these guys a house and a pool on the Island paradise of Bermuda. They had a picture of it on the daily show it was pretty nice.

Maybe we shouldn't have catched them in the first place :mrgreen:
 
Wow. Gitmo is better than China? We've really exceeded expectations, haven't we?
Perversely enough, yes, we have.

After all, the lunatic left/Anti-Republican hypocrites have been bloviating ad nauseum about what a horrible place Gitmo is, how medieval it is, and how the poor defenseless baby bombers there are just suffering.

Now, out of the mouths of those same baby bombers, we are told that the reality is nothing of the sort.

Thus, all the lunatic left/Anti-Republican hypocrites have left is to be dismissive of the question.

I admit, it's kinda fun watching the lunatic left/Anti-Republican hypocrites flailing and bailing this way. Perhaps the experience will inspire them to attempt something novel....like coherent thought and a grasp of reality.
 
Maybe they shouldn't have been terrorists in the first place.

They aren't terrorists. They're Chinese Muslims and left China, afraid for their lives and were picked up in Afghanistan. The're horribly oppressed in China.

They were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Once picked up, no one knew what to do with them. To send them back to China meant certain death and no one else wanted them because of pressure from China.

We not only allowed the Chinese to come in and torture them, but US forces were told to "soften them up" for the interogations.

Because of Chinese money, trade, business, the US knuckled under over the past 8 years and pretended in many many instances to be blind to the extensive human rights abuses.

Being Muslim does not automatically equate to being a terrorist. I know you're beyond such claims.
 
Being Muslim does not automatically equate to being a terrorist.
No, but being at an al-Quaeda/Taliban terrorist training camp does automatically equate to being a terrorist.
 
No, but being at an al-Quaeda/Taliban terrorist training camp does automatically equate to being a terrorist.

Do you have a reputable link please? The only thing I've seen are Chinese claims, hardly reputable.
 
Life at Gitmo versus China?” The interpreter relayed, over the voices of all of the men talking: “Of course it's China. There's no guarantee for human rights there.”

Not really something to be happy about. China is clearly worse
 
No, but being at an al-Quaeda/Taliban terrorist training camp does automatically equate to being a terrorist.

Here is what I've found about this claim. It looks like our former fearless leader knuckled under to China again and agreed to designate where they were at as a "terrorist camp" AFTER they'd been detained.

The Washington Monthly
 
Here is what I've found about this claim. It looks like our former fearless leader knuckled under to China again and agreed to designate where they were at as a "terrorist camp" AFTER they'd been detained.
Thank you for proving the point.

They were learning small arms handling and tactics, and somehow I doubt it was for hunting anything except Chinese. And who in Afghanistan offers such training? Why, the Taliban and their baby bombing buddies al-Qaeda!

When you get trained by terrorists you get terrorist training. When you get caught getting terrorist training by the US military, you get thrown in Gitmo--a reasonable consequence for the action.

All China did was remind the US that they have terrorist issues too. Imputing immorality to their request or US accommodation of that request is neither a serious nor realistic position to take.
 
Bush and the FBI determined early in 2003 they weren't a threat, but at that point couldn't return them to China or they'd be killed.


Obsidian Wings: The Uighurs: 1

You can read the FBI pdf report from that link.
 
If they were terrorists, then they'd be in jail.

If they were just ordinary people minding their own business they wouldn't have been detained in the first place. Conspiracy is one of the hardest things to prove this in no way means these people are innocent. What the hell were they doing in Afghanistan under Taliban rule?
 
Yeah, well I think saying you have better human rights than China is a lot like saying a movie was better than Ultraviolet. I mean, sure it's true; but it doesn't really mean anything.

Yeah, the only thing missing at Gitmo which they have in China is some form of Capitalism.
Too bad Obama is hacking away at it here like he hacks at golf.

.
 

Ummm.... see post #17. The FBI report part.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…