• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Trump determined to created more illegal immigrants

j brown's body

"A Soros-backed animal"
DP Veteran
Joined
Jun 18, 2018
Messages
78,749
Reaction score
83,081
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Progressive
"President Donald Trump’s administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to allow it to end humanitarian parole for hundreds of thousands of immigrants from four countries, setting them up for potential deportation. The emergency appeal asks the justices to halt a lower-court order keeping in place temporary legal status for more than 500,000 people from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela.

The Republican administration argues that the decision wrongly intrudes on the Department of Homeland Security’s authority. “The district court has nullified one of the administration’s most consequential immigration policy decisions,” Solicitor General John Sauer wrote.

...Trump promised on the campaign trail to deport millions of people who are in the country illegally. His administration has also sought to dismantle policies from President Joe Biden’s Democratic administration that created new ways for people to live legally in the U.S., generally for two years with work authorization."



These people are not here illegally. If he is able to end their legal status, many will probably try to stay illegally. Then get can send ICE out to round them up.

The absurdity of it, the waste of time and resources, the fox hunting aspect if it, boggles the mind.
 
I keep saying that illegal immigration is a manufactured issue, the regime keeps SAYING OUT LOUD that it is a manufactured issue, has signal led its intent to CREATE MORE "ILLEGAL" immigrants, and still right wingers are like "nuh uh! Crime! Gangs! Murder! Terking er jerbs!"

Absolute snowflake mentality.
 
I keep saying that illegal immigration is a manufactured issue, the regime keeps SAYING OUT LOUD that it is a manufactured issue, has signal led its intent to CREATE MORE "ILLEGAL" immigrants, and still right wingers are like "nuh uh! Crime! Gangs! Murder! Terking er jerbs!"

Absolute snowflake mentality.

It is indeed. They'd have us believe gangs of illegals are swarming the nation, but they go after these poor people.
 
These people are not here illegally.
But they are also not here  permanently. The administration has decided their temporary status is no longer warranted and has moved to terminate it, as they are entitled to do. That some may refuse to leave as they are obligated to is not Trump's fault, nor is it a reason to perpetually renew a program that, by its very nature, is supposed to be of limited duration.
 
But they are also not here  permanently. The administration has decided their temporary status is no longer warranted and has moved to terminate it, as they are entitled to do. That some may refuse to leave as they are obligated to is not Trump's fault, nor is it a reason to perpetually renew a program that, by its very nature, is supposed to be of limited duration.
Who is throwing them out, and why is that person doing it?
 
"President Donald Trump’s administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to allow it to end humanitarian parole for hundreds of thousands of immigrants from four countries, setting them up for potential deportation. The emergency appeal asks the justices to halt a lower-court order keeping in place temporary legal status for more than 500,000 people from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela.

The Republican administration argues that the decision wrongly intrudes on the Department of Homeland Security’s authority. “The district court has nullified one of the administration’s most consequential immigration policy decisions,” Solicitor General John Sauer wrote.


...Trump promised on the campaign trail to deport millions of people who are in the country illegally. His administration has also sought to dismantle policies from President Joe Biden’s Democratic administration that created new ways for people to live legally in the U.S., generally for two years with work authorization."



These people are not here illegally. If he is able to end their legal status, many will probably try to stay illegally. Then get can send ICE out to round them up.

The absurdity of it, the waste of time and resources, the fox hunting aspect if it, boggles the mind.
There is no statuatory or economic reason to do this, so it's entirely unforced. Nothing but motive.

And the motive is to trash the lives of brown people for the adoration of the unwashed trailer park masses.
 
But they are also not here  permanently. The administration has decided their temporary status is no longer warranted and has moved to terminate it, as they are entitled to do. That some may refuse to leave as they are obligated to is not Trump's fault, nor is it a reason to perpetually renew a program that, by its very nature, is supposed to be of limited duration.

The court says they are not entitled to do it, but even if they are, what's the point? Because Trump feels like it because he gets off on being cruel?

The point is the absurdity. He will be hunting down people he made into illegal immigrants when he could be going after those who are already illegal immigrants!
 
There is no statuatory or economic reason to do this, so it's entirely unforced. Nothing but motive.

And the motive is to trash the lives of brown people for the adoration of the unwashed trailer park masses.

The cruelty's the point.
 
"President Donald Trump’s administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to allow it to end humanitarian parole for hundreds of thousands of immigrants from four countries, setting them up for potential deportation. The emergency appeal asks the justices to halt a lower-court order keeping in place temporary legal status for more than 500,000 people from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela.

The Republican administration argues that the decision wrongly intrudes on the Department of Homeland Security’s authority. “The district court has nullified one of the administration’s most consequential immigration policy decisions,” Solicitor General John Sauer wrote.


...Trump promised on the campaign trail to deport millions of people who are in the country illegally. His administration has also sought to dismantle policies from President Joe Biden’s Democratic administration that created new ways for people to live legally in the U.S., generally for two years with work authorization."



These people are not here illegally. If he is able to end their legal status, many will probably try to stay illegally. Then get can send ICE out to round them up.

The absurdity of it, the waste of time and resources, the fox hunting aspect if it, boggles the mind.
Interesting that Trump can not actually find people to deport...... It seems our "illegal immigrant" problem was grossly overstated.

OTH, it would be much easier to find illegal immigrants if they focused on the employers of illegal immigrants including meat packing, agriculture, construction and Trump hotels....
 
Last edited:
Interesting that Trump can not actually find people to deport...... It seems our "illegal immigrant" problem was grossly overstated.

Yeah, the gang thing is over the top.
 
"President Donald Trump’s administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to allow it to end humanitarian parole for hundreds of thousands of immigrants from four countries, setting them up for potential deportation. The emergency appeal asks the justices to halt a lower-court order keeping in place temporary legal status for more than 500,000 people from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela.

The Republican administration argues that the decision wrongly intrudes on the Department of Homeland Security’s authority. “The district court has nullified one of the administration’s most consequential immigration policy decisions,” Solicitor General John Sauer wrote.


...Trump promised on the campaign trail to deport millions of people who are in the country illegally. His administration has also sought to dismantle policies from President Joe Biden’s Democratic administration that created new ways for people to live legally in the U.S., generally for two years with work authorization."



These people are not here illegally. If he is able to end their legal status, many will probably try to stay illegally. Then get can send ICE out to round them up.

The absurdity of it, the waste of time and resources, the fox hunting aspect if it, boggles the mind.
They have no right to be here.
 
The court says they are not entitled to do it,
Statutory text at 8 USC 1254a(b)(3)(B) explicitly says they are entitled to do it. I've said before they are in violation of the part that requires a minimum 60-day notice prior to the termination taking effect, but beyond that they are 100% entitled, by statute, to terminate TPS.

but even if they are, what's the point?
It has to end sometime.

Because Trump feels like it because he gets off on being cruel?
I'm sure that's the reason you wrap yourself up in every night to keep warm.

people he made into illegal immigrants
People who are present beyond their authorized period of stay make themselves illegal immigrants.
 
How much does it cost to deport one person? multiply that by however many of the 500k don't leave and that is how much this decision will cost taxpayers.

People forget deportations cost money. These people are paying taxes currently, why not change that to making the citizens? It would be a heck of a lot better money wise.
 
Statutory text at 8 USC 1254a(b)(3)(B) explicitly says they are entitled to do it. I've said before they are in violation of the part that requires a minimum 60-day notice prior to the termination taking effect, but beyond that they are 100% entitled, by statute, to terminate TPS.


It has to end sometime.


I'm sure that's the reason you wrap yourself up in every night to keep warm.


People who are present beyond their authorized period of stay make themselves illegal immigrants.

Can you give a logical reason why Trump would do this?
 
Gonna hurt the economy.
 
There is no statuatory or economic reason to do this, so it's entirely unforced. Nothing but motive.

And the motive is to trash the lives of brown people for the adoration of the unwashed trailer park masses.
Surprised he doesn't required that all velvet Elvises in trailer parks be replaced with velvet Donalds.
 
But they are also not here  permanently. The administration has decided their temporary status is no longer warranted....
No, they decided they didn't want a bunch of brown-skinned people in the US, and are trying to revoke their status.

Most of TPS recipients are from Venezuela, Haiti and El Salvador. Conditions in all of those countries did not magically change in the last 3 months. What changed is the US presidency.

The only nation I see on the list where it makes sense to end TPS is Syria, which has a whopping 3,800 approved individuals.

That some may refuse to leave as they are obligated to is not Trump's fault
Right, because nothing is ever Dear Leader's fault. :LOL:

nor is it a reason to perpetually renew a program that, by its very nature, is supposed to be of limited duration.
That would be a much better argument if Dear Leader was motivated by something other than xenophobia and racism.
 
I'm sure you have your answers to these questions already made up and entrenched. Why bother asking me?
Perhaps there's something I haven't noticed.

If you don't want to answer the question, that's fine.
 
No, they decided they didn't want a bunch of brown-skinned people in the US, and are trying to revoke their status.
I'm sure that's the story you're going to stick to, come hell or high water.

Most of TPS recipients are from Venezuela, Haiti and El Salvador. Conditions in all of those countries did not magically change in the last 3 months. What changed is the US presidency.

The only nation I see on the list where it makes sense to end TPS is Syria, which has a whopping 3,800 approved individuals.
Then be sure to send your thoughts on the matter to the appropriate individuals. I am sure they will welcome your expert input on the topic.

Right, because nothing is ever Dear Leader's fault. :LOL:
It's pretty weird to assign blame for one person's unlawful behavior to someone else entirely.

That would be a much better argument if Dear Leader was motivated by something other than xenophobia and racism.
Sure, sure. You keep banging that drum.
 
Why would I need to do that?

Because the logic of this action is missing.

Do you approve of this out of mindless support for Trump?

Otherwise, what's the point?
 
Back
Top Bottom