• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

The USS Harvey Milk !!! (1 Viewer)

APACHERAT

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
15,633
Reaction score
6,159
Location
Behind the Orange Curtain
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Very Conservative
Obama may order the Secretary of the Navy to name a U.S. Navy warship after Harvey Milk !!!

>" there was grumbling from conservative commentators over Congressman Bob Filner’s petition to have a ship named after San Francisco activist Harvey Milk. Milk, who had served as an officer in the Navy, was assassinated soon after becoming one of the first openly gay men to be elected to public office in California. "<

Probably not as much of a controversary than when President Obama signed off on naming a Lewis and Clark-class cargo ship after Cesar Chavez who described his short service in the U.S. Navy “the two worst years of my life.”There's have been a number of controversary naming of U.S. Navy ships.

During the 1990's during the Clinton administration while drasticly cutting away at the fleet, social engineering was being forced upon the Navy allowing women to serve on warships and to propagate with the male sailors. This called for building a new class of ship, the Navy's maternity hospital ships to follow the Navy's Carrier Battle Groups around the oceans of the world. These new ships were to have been the USS Hillary Clinton class Maternity Hospital Ships. But Clintons downsizing of the fleet also axed these ships. ;- )

A couple of years ago it was suggested naming a Navy garbage scow after President Obama. Only problem was that the Navy doesn't assign names to scows but numbers. Sorry Barack.

Well here's a list of twenty six US Navy ship naming controversies in recent times and the history behind the naming of these ships. It comes from no better source than the U.S. Naval Institute.


Twenty Six US Navy Ship Naming Controversies

>" In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, the U.S. Navy had no formal procedure for naming ships. It wasn’t until 1819 that Congress passed an act stating “all of the ships, of the Navy of the United States, now building, or hereafter to be built, shall be named by the Secretary of the Navy.” The secretary has fulfilled this role ever since, even though the passage expressly assigning authority for designating ship names was omitted when the U.S. Code was revised in 1925.

In addition to recommendations from Congress and the president, the secretary traditionally has been guided by a rather loose set of naming conventions—cruisers were to be named for battles, attack submarines for U.S. cities, destroyers for Navy and Marine heroes, and so forth. Controversy has erupted whenever the choice of a name strayed too far from those conventions, was seemingly swayed by politics, or deemed inappropriate for various reasons.
Ship-name controversies date to the early days of the Republic, but have become more prevalent in the latter part of the 20th century and the early years of the 21st. "< The 26 ships. -> Twenty Six US Navy Ship Naming Controversies | USNI News
 
You can sink it with one of these:

300px-Hostess-Twinkies.jpg
 
Yes, but what foreign arsenal had the foresight to stock up on those before it was too late?

Haven't you heard? Twinkies are BACK baby!!! Yea!!!:mrgreen:
 
Hey, why not the USS Lenny Bruce as well?

Personally, I think my favorite ship naming of the last 20 years is the former USS Edenton, which is now the USCGC Alex Haley.
 
This link is kind of interesting. It states who and what the various classes of ships are often named after. Naming Ships - Navy Ships
 
This link is kind of interesting. It states who and what the various classes of ships are often named after. Naming Ships - Navy Ships

FAS is a reliable source, I use them often.

What they classify as "large cruisers" are actually classified by the U.S. Navy as "battle cruisers" or some European navies called "pocket battleships."

The United States only built two "battle Cruisers." They were launched during WW ll. They were of the Alaska class battle cruisers. (Alaska was a U.S. Territory back then.) The CB 1 USS Alaska and the CB 2 USS Guam.

Back when I served in the Marines we had a 900 ship navy and back then it was easy to identify a class of ship by it's name. Not today, the USS Alabama is not a battleship but a submarine today and today's USS Princeton is not an aircraft carrier but a cruiser. The original Essex class carrier USS Princeton was named after the battle of Princeton of 1777 not the city.

I went to the Navy's official website, today's CG-59 USS Princeton is named after the battle of Princeton.

The civilians Secretary of the Navy, POTUS and Congress need to keep politics out of naming Navy ships and stick to established naval traditions. Was Harvey Milk a naval war hero ? I don't think so. Neither was Cesar Chavez, he hated serving in the U.S. Navy. I'm sure Harvey Milk loved serving in the Navy with the tight living conditions aboard ship with no women being allowed to serve on ships back then. ;- )
 
Any particular reason ?

Salvage and Rescue Ship(ATS)

ATS-1 Edenton / WMEC-282' CLASS Alex Haley- Navy Ships

My favorite ship has to be the Iowa class BB USS New Jersey.

Notice, I said naming, not ship itself.

Alex Haley is quite an individual in my book, and he has always fascinated me.

Now most only know him as the author of Roots. However, he is also a WWII Veteran, spent 20 years in the Coast Guard, was a self-taught journalist, and the first black Chief Petty Officer in the Coast Guard. In fact, the Coast Guard thought so highly of him that he was the first "Chief Journalist" of the Coast Guard, a position created specifically for him.

His achievements as a Sailor alone to me merit such recognition.
 
Obama may order the Secretary of the Navy to name a U.S. Navy warship after Harvey Milk !!!

So when will the USS Harvey Milk be ready to take Seamen????
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom