• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Someone Sold Two Of My Stocks In My Schwab Portfolio

rhinefire

DP Veteran
Joined
May 3, 2007
Messages
12,975
Reaction score
4,929
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Independent
Two of my stocks were illegally sold from my portfolio though no fault of my own. The money amount was recovered but Schwab put it into a money market account. I asked why they did not return it to the stocks. They said they cannot. One of the stocks went up 5 1/2 points in that two week period Schwab took to investigate. The cost me $600+ and now because I bought both this year I will have to tax on short term.
 
Two of my stocks were illegally sold from my portfolio though no fault of my own. The money amount was recovered but Schwab put it into a money market account. I asked why they did not return it to the stocks. They said they cannot. One of the stocks went up 5 1/2 points in that two week period Schwab took to investigate. The cost me $600+ and now because I bought both this year I will have to tax on short term.
Did you bring this up? What did they say?


Our security guarantee promises Schwab will cover losses in any of your Schwab accounts due to unauthorized activity. Learn more at schwab.com/guarantee
 
Really?! How did this happen? Someone got into your account? If it was me, I'd just be happy to get your money back. Sorry about the tax consequences though.
 
Two of my stocks were illegally sold from my portfolio though no fault of my own. The money amount was recovered but Schwab put it into a money market account. I asked why they did not return it to the stocks. They said they cannot. One of the stocks went up 5 1/2 points in that two week period Schwab took to investigate. The cost me $600+ and now because I bought both this year I will have to tax on short term.
That's insane. At least you didn't wake up and find a negative 49 billion dollar balance like that one lady.
 
You might want to dig into how your account security was compromised.

At least that's what I'm assuming when you said they were "sold illegally through no fault of your own."
 
Two of my stocks were illegally sold from my portfolio though no fault of my own. The money amount was recovered but Schwab put it into a money market account. I asked why they did not return it to the stocks. They said they cannot. One of the stocks went up 5 1/2 points in that two week period Schwab took to investigate. The cost me $600+ and now because I bought both this year I will have to tax on short term.

Damn, that is frightening. Did you have two-factor authentication enabled for your account's security? I make sure that I have that done on all our accounts, even though it is kind of a pain checking on them.
 
I assume you took this to upper level management?

What exactly occurred on the account? Do they know yet? Making you whole would seem to me to be one of their priorities....which in some ways they did, but in others....not. Did you bring this up with someone in upper management?

I had TD Ameritrade which was switched to Schwab when they merged....i havent had any issues with our two accounts....but both have two factor authorization....and i only log in from 2 places.

If you havent spoken to higher ups, that would be my move. Not sure of your account balance....but i have had zero issue getting assistance when needed including floor managers and above.
 
I assume you took this to upper level management?

What exactly occurred on the account? Do they know yet? Making you whole would seem to me to be one of their priorities....which in some ways they did, but in others....not. Did you bring this up with someone in upper management?

I had TD Ameritrade which was switched to Schwab when they merged....i havent had any issues with our two accounts....but both have two factor authorization....and i only log in from 2 places.

If you havent spoken to higher ups, that would be my move. Not sure of your account balance....but i have had zero issue getting assistance when needed including floor managers and above.


I will take a guess and say a schwab employee did it to cover a short position illegally
 
I will take a guess and say a schwab employee did it to cover a short position illegally
I assume you took this to upper level management?

What exactly occurred on the account? Do they know yet? Making you whole would seem to me to be one of their priorities....which in some ways they did, but in others....not. Did you bring this up with someone in upper management?

I had TD Ameritrade which was switched to Schwab when they merged....i havent had any issues with our two accounts....but both have two factor authorization....and i only log in from 2 places.

If you havent spoken to higher ups, that would be my move. Not sure of your account balance....but i have had zero issue getting assistance when needed including floor managers and above.
I had one of my retirement accounts at TD Ameritrade which were transferred there from Scottrade when it "merged." I wasn't happy at TD with their website and other things. When the next "merger" happened, I went to Fidelity as I wasn't, for many reasons, going to be sucked into Schwab. Just say I'm not surprised this happened to the OP and wish him well in getting ALL of his losses paid for.
 
That's insane. At least you didn't wake up and find a negative 49 billion dollar balance like that one lady.

Or the 20-year-old kid who was told by Robinhood he faced a $750,000 loss on stock options and had a $170,000 margin call. He then frantically emailed the broker’s customer service four times, got the brushoff, but then received the good news via automated email that it was all just a big misunderstanding—one day after he committed suicide:

Great news!" The email read, "We're reaching out to confirm that you've met your margin call and we've lifted your trade restrictions. If you have any questions about your margin call, please feel free to reach out. We're happy to help!"
 
Back
Top Bottom