Correct, 20th century Fascism emerged from socialism.
AI: Which contributed to the rise of fascism more: Capitalism or Socialism?
...
Fascism Causes: Socialism vs Capitalism
Fascism arose primarily as a response to the crises and contradictions of capitalism, particularly during periods of severe economic instability, rather than as a consequence of socialism’s successes. While fascist movements often used anti-socialist rhetoric and violently suppressed socialist and communist movements, the ideological and structural origins of fascism are deeply rooted in the failures of liberal capitalism, including economic inequality, overproduction, unemployment, and the perceived inability of democratic institutions to manage capitalist crises. Socialism, by contrast, is presented in the sources not as a contributor to fascism but as its antithesis—a revolutionary alternative that fascism was specifically designed to prevent.
Fascism as a Product of Capitalist Crisis
Fascism is widely interpreted in the provided sources as an extreme, authoritarian response to the systemic failures of capitalism. J.T. Murphy, writing in 1935, explicitly states that
"Fascism is not an alternative to Capitalism. It is Capitalism in its most desperate, violent form". This perspective frames fascism not as a break from capitalism but as its most reactionary defense mechanism during periods of collapse. When capitalism faces deep structural crises—such as overproduction, falling profits, and mass unemployment—the ruling capitalist class may turn to fascist movements to preserve the existing economic order by crushing working-class resistance and dismantling democratic institutions that might enable socialist transformation.
The economic model under fascism maintained private ownership of the means of production, but subjected it to strict state control in the name of the "national interest". This arrangement allowed capitalists to retain ownership while the state intervened to ensure profitability, suppress labor unions, and eliminate socialist threats. For example, in Nazi Germany, industrialists collaborated closely with the Nazi Party, supporting its rise in power to prevent a potential socialist revolution. This collaboration underscores the idea that fascism functions as a tool for big business to maintain control during times of social and economic upheaval.
The Role of Socialism in the Rise of Fascism
While socialism did not cause fascism, it played a significant role as a
political target and
ideological foil. Fascist movements consistently defined themselves in opposition to socialism, communism, and class struggle, portraying them as existential threats to the nation. The violent suppression of socialist and communist movements—such as the murder of Spartacist revolutionaries by the Freikorps, precursors to the Nazi Party—was central to fascism’s consolidation of power.
However, this opposition does not imply that socialism contributed to fascism in a causal or structural sense. Rather, the fear of socialism among the capitalist class acted as a catalyst for supporting fascist movements. As one source notes,
"Fascism ultimately serves as a reactionary movement to hinder the tide of history"—specifically, the historical movement toward socialism and workers’ emancipation. In this view, fascism is not a response to socialism’s strength, but to capitalism’s weakness and the ruling class’s fear of losing control.
