• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

San Francisco weighs decriminalizing prostitution

Good for them, provide a safe haven for a service that is needed, how else will the closeted Republicans get their jollies off

At least democrats can finally file W-2's.
 
I've been saying that prostitution should be legal for the past 40 years.
Why must our nation be so backward ?
Fear ?
Look to Holland for guidance then, learn from their mistakes..
Have a President who can think, can originate an original idea..
 

It must be known that prostitution is WRONG; that does not mean that it should be illegal.. It should be taxed and controlled. Obviously Holland is not up to this task...I wonder if we are ?
As to cocaine, what are its overall effect on Holland ? In a society there will always be a certain percentage of worthless citizens; keep that number low enough and there should be minimal problems..
 
I think I read that SF decided not to pass this measure at this time.
more's the pity.
But at least they considered it, which is progress, and I'm sure it'll keep coming back to the table- much like gay marriage- until it does pass.
All societies must progress and evolve, or else wither.
 
I've been saying that prostitution should be legal for the past 40 years.
Why must our nation be so backward ?
Fear ?
Look to Holland for guidance then, learn from their mistakes..
Have a President who can think, can originate an original idea..
Xianity. :2wave:
 
Why is buying your wife a new fridge so that she'll be happy and keep blowing you, wrong?
 
Violence Against Women -- Sign In Page

Yes, legalize prostitution, it's such a good thing, a good thing for women.

The facts bare out how much better legal prositution is...

You guys should go read some of the studies on the horror that prostitution is, and you'll see there is more then "pushing morality" fighting against prostitution.

I care about people, legalizing evil isn't a good thing.
 
Last edited:

Regardless of what studies may indicate you can't legislate morality nor what someone will do to their own body. This has been proven as well.

Driving a car has been proven to be dangerous to all living things, yet we still drive cars, cigarettes have been proven to be dangerous, not only to the smoker but innocent bystanders as well, alcohol has been proven to be dangerous to the drinker as well as anyone they may come into contact with, mountain climbing and sky diving and gambling, motorcycle riding and swimming... if your point is that prostitution should remain illegal because it's harmful to women then you must also be against anything being legal that can cause harm to women (like giving birth) especially those things that cause more harm to women and men than prostitution. So where should your legislation begin and end?
 

Thats the thing though this isnt about whether or not prositution is particually pleasant vocation for those involved but how to reduce the unpleasantness. Citeing statistics for countrys like the UK where prostitution is legal is kinda missing the point.
 
Also the standard is to prove that legalized prostituion is worse then criminalized prostitution.

Even if legalized prostitution was no better for the prostitutes at all, it has various other benefits for broader society (being able to control where it goes on, taxing it, etc.)

You can't stop prostitution.
 
Legalize and regulate. Safer for everyone involved.
 
Someone very close to me has worked in the sex industry for just over a decade, and she has said on many occasions that the biggest hinderance to her life and the life of her co-workers is not potential abuses, but the law.

Where prostitution is illegal, it does a double whammy. Women who are abused and seek help with law enforcement instead have the law turn on them, or treat them badly because for many breaking the law is something immoral. The courts are less likely to feel sympathy for rape victims when they are prostitutes; those who abuse prostitutes tend to get off easier because their victim was seen as doing something "immoral" anyway.

Systemic bias against prostitutes prevents those who want to get out from doing so. Many become defacto slaves to their pimps because they cannot run to any official agency to beg for help. Those that run to the law if they are raped or held captive by anyone risk having the law turn on them. Immigrants who are willingly lured from overseas with the promise of lucrative opportunities in the sex industry (i.e. more money) can easily become indentured servants if they are not careful. If it were legalized, this would be a non-issue. It would take the power away from the creeps that routinely seek pleasure in holding people captive.

On the flipside, those that want to do this line of work lack the agency to do so because the law prevents them from forming working groups, registration databases (to track people who go missing), institutions where they can report bad clients to (right now this process is currently very underground), and regulate standard prices.

This industry is going to exist one way or another, and it is an industry that caters to all levels of society. Rich and poor people alike use prostitution services. The fact that it is not legal shows that our society, on a surface level, likes to pretend that certain needs don't exist, and that our collective morality is somehow "better than that". That is not the truth. The sex industry as a whole is number two only to the movie industry in North America in terms of profits, it's time we realize the reality of what is really going on.
 
Legalize and regulate. Safer for everyone involved.

And reality, facts and studies that say otherwise be damned!

You guys REALLY hate women don't you?
 
And reality, facts and studies that say otherwise be damned!

But have not done a comparative analysis of legalized vs. illegal prostitution and its effect on the people involved. For example what you quoted stated

Of 854 people in prostitution in nine countries (Canada,
Colombia, Germany, Mexico, South Africa, Thailand, Turkey,
United States, and Zambia), 71% experienced physical assaults in
prostitution,

This includes at least one country where prostitution is legal.

Now lets look at San Francisco where prostitution is illegal:

Violence
80% had been physically assaulted since entering prostitution
SF Task Force on Prostitution: Health Services/Needs Assessment

A 9% jump in violence.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…