• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Russian Plane Carrying 92 Crashes in Black Sea; 10 Dead Seen

I heard there was no communication between the tower and the plane before it crashed

Thats indicative of a onboard explosion
 
No. No hard feelings towards Putin or his people. Just that it is war against us that they are waging at many levels and supporting a mass murderer and criminal against humanity that has had thousands tortured over day, weeks or months till dead so that he gets the population back for another go at it. So it is good news every time one of them is dead even ones building up the morale of the troops in the first line. This is not a question of emotions but one of ethics and security.

Most of his supposed mass murder was against rebels trying to overthrow them. It would be on par with claiming the union was mass murdering innocent civilians in the south by claiming all confederate troops were innocent civilians. The only death tolls being released are from groups constantly accused of counting armed rebels and isis/al nursa fronts as civilians.

He was definately a tyrant, but in the short chaos more damage was done by isis and al nursa and the rebels who sided with them, like kicking gay people off high buildings and beheading woman for not being conservative enough with their clothing.

The middle east needs dictators, without them every faction kills eachother, while the govts we overthrow tend to protect minorities. The middle east will remain said way until they can work out a system of democracy that works for them, not one the west imposes on them. The biggest cause of the entire crisis in syria is us meddling, libya already looks like somalia, and we only cared about human rights there until their leader was disposed of, then we left it high and dry, and now it is an isis stronghold. Syria will end up the same way.
 
A Russian plane carrying 92 people to an air base in Syria crashed Sunday into the Black Sea minutes after taking off from the city of Sochi, Russia's Defense Ministry said. Thousands of rescue workers were searching the undersea crash site but there appeared to be no survivors. Those on board included dozens of members of Russia's world-famous army choir.

The cause of the crash wasn't immediately known. At least one expert cited a terror attack as a possible reason — a scenario rejected by Russian officials.
The Russian military has repeatedly flown groups of Russian singers and artists to perform at Hemeimeem, which serves as the main hub for the Russian air campaign in Syria.

The passenger list for the Sochi plane released by the Defense Ministry included 64 members of the Alexandrov Ensemble, including its leader, Valery Khalilov. The ensemble, often referred to as the Red Army choir, is the official choir of the Russian military and also includes a band and a dance company. The choir sang "Get Lucky" at the opening of the 2014 Winter Olympic Games that Russia hosted in Sochi, becoming an instant online sensation.

http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2016/12/25/world/europe/ap-eu-russia-military-plane.html
Retaliation by ISIL members for Syria? For Aleppo?

Yeah, Kurds, Christians and other innocents were also affected by the Civil War in Syria but the main driver of the opposition of the Assad government and hence the Syrian Civil War came from ISIL. Assad's government is an offshoot of Shia Islam. ISIL is an offshoot of Sunni Islam. Sunni Islam and Shia Islam go together like oil and water.
 
Last edited:
Sidenote: Remember back, folks, to WWII. The US partnered with Joseph Stalin of the Soviet Union to destroy Nazi Germany. Now it's Russia, Putin, and ISIL.

Don't want US troops to be directly involved in fighting ISIL? Use the willing proxy militaries: Russia, or Iran, for examples.
 
Last edited:
A Russian plane carrying 92 people to an air base in Syria crashed Sunday into the Black Sea minutes after taking off from the city of Sochi, Russia's Defense Ministry said. Thousands of rescue workers were searching the undersea crash site but there appeared to be no survivors. Those on board included dozens of members of Russia's world-famous army choir.

The cause of the crash wasn't immediately known. At least one expert cited a terror attack as a possible reason — a scenario rejected by Russian officials.
The Russian military has repeatedly flown groups of Russian singers and artists to perform at Hemeimeem, which serves as the main hub for the Russian air campaign in Syria.

The passenger list for the Sochi plane released by the Defense Ministry included 64 members of the Alexandrov Ensemble, including its leader, Valery Khalilov. The ensemble, often referred to as the Red Army choir, is the official choir of the Russian military and also includes a band and a dance company. The choir sang "Get Lucky" at the opening of the 2014 Winter Olympic Games that Russia hosted in Sochi, becoming an instant online sensation.

http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2016/12/25/world/europe/ap-eu-russia-military-plane.html

A tragic loss of life. My condolences to the Russian people.
 
I don't know if that can be claimed to be too old and worn out, the c-130 has been in the us military since 1954, and is still used today.

Not the same planes. When I started flying, we had just transitioned from the C-130A's to the C-130B's. When I got out we were transitioning to the C-130H. The current model is the C-130J with all new airframe and engine technology, as well as state of the art avionics and electronics - a completely different plane than the ones I flew on.

Russia is flying the exact same old planes with the same old airframes and engines that were built decades ago. That's the difference.
 
Most of his supposed mass murder was against rebels trying to overthrow them. It would be on par with claiming the union was mass murdering innocent civilians in the south by claiming all confederate troops were innocent civilians. The only death tolls being released are from groups constantly accused of counting armed rebels and isis/al nursa fronts as civilians.

He was definately a tyrant, but in the short chaos more damage was done by isis and al nursa and the rebels who sided with them, like kicking gay people off high buildings and beheading woman for not being conservative enough with their clothing.

The middle east needs dictators, without them every faction kills eachother, while the govts we overthrow tend to protect minorities. The middle east will remain said way until they can work out a system of democracy that works for them, not one the west imposes on them. The biggest cause of the entire crisis in syria is us meddling, libya already looks like somalia, and we only cared about human rights there until their leader was disposed of, then we left it high and dry, and now it is an isis stronghold. Syria will end up the same way.

Nope. Do some reading.
 
Not the same planes. When I started flying, we had just transitioned from the C-130A's to the C-130B's. When I got out we were transitioning to the C-130H. The current model is the C-130J with all new airframe and engine technology, as well as state of the art avionics and electronics - a completely different plane than the ones I flew on.

Russia is flying the exact same old planes with the same old airframes and engines that were built decades ago. That's the difference.

Could be why, I know the new c-130s are new airframes, some previous models though were reconditioned frames, bad enough to a point they had issues with dioxin from agent orange in some of those c-130s from the vietnam war. The military in general rarely retires any frames, gun frames, truck frames, jet frames etc.

But we recondition them and certify them. If the russian jets of that age are suffering such issues, they have probably never stripped them down and fully inspected them periodically like america does with it's military aircraft.
 
Retaliation by ISIL members for Syria? For Aleppo?

Yeah, Kurds, Christians and other innocents were also affected by the Civil War in Syria but the main driver of the opposition of the Assad government and hence the Syrian Civil War came from ISIL. Assad's government is an offshoot of Shia Islam. ISIL is an offshoot of Sunni Islam. Sunni Islam and Shia Islam go together like oil and water.

Retaliation for something, by somebody, is my guess.

Most likely candidate IMO would be Israeli Mossad.
 
Nope. Do some reading.

What reading do I need? I am still trying to find proof of his mass murder, so far just propoganda pieces that say trust us it happened. They tried the same with qaddafi and accused him of planning mass genocide based off a statement he will crush the armed resistance. That country is more oppressive now than it has ever been, syria has between 180k through 600k deaths, which is a hard number to figure given most of the info on deaths came either directly from the regime, or from armed rebels.
 
They make good music,too bad for musicians

"'Then we heard the plane taking off, the engines were working normally.

'The only thing - I saw then with the corner of my eye a bright flash.'



'Then I saw splash - and it was very big,' she said.

'I had thought that actually it could be a plane that had fallen into the sea, but I tried to banish that thought.



"'But the fact is that during the seven minute flight, the plane managed to gain a decent height.

'From such a height the fragments found in different places is too much.

'This suggests that it began to break up in air.

'No technical failure can lead to the destruction of the aircraft in the air....

'The plane's destruction began in the sky, it means that already something extraordinary had happened.

'This was not a flock of birds, as hit the plane which downed in the Hudson River after getting into trouble by hitting a flock of birds.

'This was a more serious total and immediate failure of the plane.'


Read more: Kremlin blame pilot error or technical fault for Russian air disaster | Daily Mail Online
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook




Read more: Kremlin blame pilot error or technical fault for Russian air disaster | Daily Mail Online
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

Kremlin blame pilot error or technical fault for Russian air disaster | Daily Mail Online
 
Last edited:
Retaliation for something, by somebody, is my guess.

Most likely candidate IMO would be Israeli Mossad.

Uh....why?

Mossad is much more interested in Iran and Hezbollah then Russia.
 
Back
Top Bottom