• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Missing Malysian Airliner Continued to Fly on For Hours (Confirmed)


As a pilot I am going to say no. That is a stupid idea.

Transponders sometimes malfunction and give erroneous data, and need to be shut off so they don't screw with air traffic control radar and a critical piece of safety equipment called TCAS. (a system designed to prevent mid-air collisions) And when that transponder has an electrical problem and the wires start to smoke, I need to shut it off before it starts my avionics on fire.
 
Last edited:

OK, thanks for the heads up, I wasnt aware that they could be a fire hazard or give off bad info. You learn something new every day.
 
LOL a daily live press conference debunks it.. watch it tomorrow live if you want. You are spreading rumour, bull**** and out right lies... just like the Chinese satellite pictures supposedly showing wreckage... also bull****, and a waste of time.
The Malaysians are denying the WSJ article, they have not debunked it. Big difference there. And right now they arent saying anything since they dont know so anything is possible at this point.
 
OK, thanks for the heads up, I wasnt aware that they could be a fire hazard or give off bad info. You learn something new every day.

Well, any electrical device can be a fire hazard! It's why your house has circuit breakers.

Airliners have more than one transponder, so in this case it seems like the transponders were turned off deliberately. The other option being a major electrical failure causing both transponders to fail, or causing the pilots elect to keep them off.

A semi plausible scenario is that the plane had such an electrical failure and the pilots knew they wouldn't make it to their destination on emergency power, so attempted to return home to familiar territory because by then they might literally be navigating with their eyeballs. (yeesh, and I'd be shocked if they even had the charts on board that would help with that)

However, electrical systems on an airliner are highly redundant. I think that would be an unprecedented situation for a 777.
 
Same with the crummy Chinese satellite pics that were release days after the fact. One or several entities are hiding something.

The low-quality satellite picture showed possible objects in the water from Sunday. Such objects were not necessarily from the missing plane, but that did amount to a possible lead in the search for the plane.

Right now, there's very little solid information. The plane disappeared from the radar relatively early in its flight. Its transponder had stopped transmitting information. That's about all that is currently known.

Malaysia's contradictory reports don't necessarily mean that that country or others are "hiding" what happened. The convergence of pressures to respond to families who are pressing the authorities for information that could provide certainty/closure (which is largely absent) and lack of crisis communication experience probably may be a better explanation. I do believe Malaysia needs to be more careful about the information it is communicating--keep it limited and focused strictly on the facts that are known; don't provide content that has not been verified.

The media, however, is not under the same kind of pressure that those involved in the investigation are facing. The media is in a stronger position to refrain from disseminating speculative material. It should do so.
 
The media, however, is not under the same kind of pressure that those involved in the investigation are facing. The media is in a stronger position to refrain from disseminating speculative material. It should do so.

While we're at it, I'd like a unicorn.
 
maybe a mod could remove the "confirmed" from the thread title, substitute "debunked", or move the thread to "conspiracy theories"
 

It's a pretty credible story now.. US is moving ships into the Indian Ocean. So this isn't even close to debunked.

But I doubt Pete and others will admit they are wrong. I said from the start of this topic. We'll find it in the Indian Ocean. Malaysian military radar picked up the plane in Straits of Malacca. So it was heading West, not to China. So it can't be in the South China Sea.
 
It's fake. The engines stopped at 1.07. they didn't fact check even a little bit. Just the normal leel of disinformation to an uncritically accepting drone readership. Mushrooms: kept in the dark and fed a load of bull.....

Looks like its not fake:

Malaysia Airliner Communications Shut Down Separately, US Officials Say - ABC News
Missing plane sent signals to satellite for hours
Who's the drone now, eh? :lol:
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…