• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Los Angeles Raises Minimum Wage to $15 an Hour


You'd be surprised in how the two cities are alike. Both are major ports. Both are politically rather progressive. Both have very ethnically-diverse populations. And Los Angeles is not that bad when it comes to level of educational attainment.
 
Speaking of facts not fitting someone's narrative, are you aware that the States that have the weakest unionization tend to have the strongest employment and least inequality?

Are you aware that the states that have the weakest unionization also have the lowest average income, the lowest educational attainment rates, the highest teenage pregnancy rates, the highest divorce rates, and the highest violent crime rates? Google them - it's true. Red states are generally worse than blue states in all those categories.

And when it comes to your attempt to correlate unionization with inequality in cities, I was not aware that cities in Florida, North Carolina, Louisiana, and Texas were so strongly unionized:

 

We'll see in the years to come, won't we?

how about this you open a business and pay no skill low skill labor 15 an hour.

I am a small business owner. We've got a small store where we do airline ticketing (at rates that are almost always lower than anything you find online), package shipping, and money remittance. We also have another small business where we provide home care to an elderly lady with dementia, and another one where we provide home care to a young man (who was our Foster child since he was four) who has fetal drug syndrome - he has a trach, a g-tube, rods in his back, seizure disorders, cleft palate, and is also developmentally-disabled.

So yes, we DO own three small businesses and we DO have employees. Are you doing as much? Perhaps you are - I don't want to make the same mistake you just made by assuming that I don't know anything about running a business.
 
Has anybody seen any data on the effects on unemployment rates of teenagers in cities where the MW has been raised a significant amount?
 
Sam's Club does half the business, and carries fewer SKU's.

I don't think you're hitting the target you're aiming for.

Sam's Club = Wallmart.
 
David Neumark, in his book Minimum Wages, summarizes the important studies on minimum wage effects. Here are the effects according to the preponderance of evidence:

Minimum wages reduce the employment of low-skilled workers, especially for those directly affected.

There is no compelling evidence that it helps low income families; there is some evidence that it actually harms them and increases their poverty.

The clear conclusion is that there is no beneficial distributional effects.

Minimum wages create either no effect or a negative effect on employee skills and training. There is no positive effect.

Schooling - there is an unambiguous negative effect on future schooling (as measured in case studies).

There is a long-term negative effect on the young, lowering their wages and earnings in their late twenties.

Increase prices in those industries directly affected, but not in general economy.


It's just that simple, folks. The only question needing discussed is why each of these effects occur - which, for those familiar with economics, should be somewhat obvious.
 

One thing is for sure, you seem oblivious to the thread of prior claims. I questioned your laudatory claims about strong unions being correlated with robust economies in other countries; so I asked you if you were aware that in this country, State employment rates and inequality is correlated to strong unionization.

Bizarrely, you take off carping over scatter-shot irrelevancies about how bad their non-economic demographics were - aka, dodging. Then you offered a red herring list of ten Cities (not States), some cities in red states, who have the worst inequality and poverty (ignoring that most or all of those cities, even in red states, are blue).

The correct answer was "Max, I confess that I was unaware that States with stronger unions correlate with higher unemployment and greater inequality".
 
Last edited:
They come be a use they can find the jobs. Start jailing employers and that all goes away.

then why is your plan then...... jail employers.

instead of granting work visas.

the only reason the u.s. ever created them in the first place was for skills which could not be found in the u.s. not to just give them to people who wanted to work in america
 

LOL of course you do everyone is everything on the internet.
you don't pay 15 bucks an hour either on every position you have.

you pay the market rate for the job the person is doing.
 
A pay raise for minimum wage losers is a pay cut for everyone else.
 
How about the business owners successfully operated a couple of stores, and now remaining in business is questionable? Obviously, never thought about that.

It happens every day. You're paying way too much for lease rates.
 

Trust me, California doesn't care. For every one that leaves, 10 more start up.
 
I just showed that it did and you were proven wrong and I am sure that there were more that were not reported.

businesses cannot justify paying low skill no skill workers 15 dollars

Look, your little article has zero effect, that's what I've been telling you. Your opinion is useless against the markets and public demand. If you can't sell your cup cakes here - then leave.
 

All that sounds fine however L.A. is L.A. and just like up here, businesses will come and go a dime a dozen. The ones that make it will be able to afford $15 an hour. If the others can;t hack, then asta la byebye.
 
Look, your little article has zero effect, that's what I've been telling you. Your opinion is useless against the markets and public demand. If you can't sell your cup cakes here - then leave.

businesses are leaving or closing down. that is why CA has some of the highest poverty rates in the country and more people on government assistance.
it has been going on for years.

yep if I owned a cupcake shop in CA I would shut it down and move to NV where I can operate efficiently.
it isn't a matter of selling cupcakes.

it is the matter of making enough money off of them to continue operating.
I mean if you will buy 10 dollar cupcakes then please do I will stay in business.
 
All that sounds fine however L.A. is L.A. and just like up here, businesses will come and go a dime a dozen. The ones that make it will be able to afford $15 an hour. If the others can;t hack, then asta la byebye.

and the ones that make it won't be hiring no skill low skill workers either.
 
and the ones that make it won't be hiring no skill low skill workers either.

Then, what happens to the more than 25% of Los Angeles residents who lack high school diplomas? The disappearance of job opportunities for them almost certainly would lock them in poverty, especially as no large-scale education initiatives are on the horizon for the City.
 

it is a liberal dream land isn't? tons of people dependent on the government for survival?
beholden to their government overlords to provide for them while the rest of the people move to avoid the increased taxes.

CA is going the way of Detroit but as the entire state as a whole.
 
Wow, LA by proclamation has suspended a law of economics! Amazing. I can't wait till they issue another proclamation that sellers must sell below cost because they can always make it up in volume. Venezuelan economic decrees in America, can't wait!
The minimum wage is 80 years old and yet America continues to have a resilient and robust economy.

The problem is that the myths that conservatives convince themselves are real, like increasing the minimum wage will cause people to lose their jobs and it will drive out small businesses, are not real.
Minimum Wage Mythbusters - U.S. Department of Labor
 

what if there is no demand for cupcakes in NV ?
 
Wow, LA by proclamation has suspended a law of economics! Amazing. I can't wait till they issue another proclamation that sellers must sell below cost because they can always make it up in volume. Venezuelan economic decrees in America, can't wait!

Economics has laws? I've always thought of them as opinions.
 
A pay raise for minimum wage losers is a pay cut for everyone else.
Thank you for reading your bumper sticker. That doesn't make it so and insulting hard-working Americans by calling them "losers" doesn't help your case. The reality is low earning workers are constrained at what they can purchase. If they earned more, they could consume more. Remember, their earnings are your income. If they have more income, you get more sales, which means you earn more.

Moreover, when minimum wage workers get raises, their pay bumps up against supervisory workers, who then demand higher wages.

Contrarily, a pay raise for minimum wage Americans is a pay raise for everyone else.
 
What you believe is (once again) wrong. There are studies that conclude otherwise: Studies look at what happened when cities raised minimum wage | The Seattle Times



 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…