• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Israel’s attack on hospital in Gaza may constitute a war crime on many fronts

Allan

DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 30, 2019
Messages
54,980
Reaction score
83,746
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Liberal
This horrendous crime is intended to carry out two of Israel’s goals: shutter remaining Gaza medical facilities and kill journalists that are reporting on the genocide.

Israel claiming the killing of civilians was in error is a laughable lie. They targeted a functioning hospital, twice.

Israel’s twin strike on the Nasser hospital in Gaza, which killed five journalists including staff working for the Associated Press, Reuters, and Al Jazeera, is a potential violation of international law writ large.

While the Israel Defense Forces, which have killed about 200 journalists already in the Gaza war, immediately attempted to suggest the killing of civilians had been in error, the reality is that it appears to be policy and not a mistake.

What is striking about this incident is that each individual element – the targeting of a working hospital, of journalists and rescue workers, of civilian injured already under treatment – would be expected to draw accusations of a war crime in its own right.

Taken together it points to something far darker, a “horrific” incident in the words of the British foreign secretary, David Lammy.

A joint investigation in July by the Israeli +972 Magazine and Local Call reported that the IDF now routinely carried out additional attacks in the area of an initial bombing, sometimes intentionally killing paramedics and others involved in rescue efforts.

“If there’s a strike on a senior commander, another one will be carried out afterward to ensure rescue efforts don’t take place,” said one of +972’s sources who it said was present in an Israeli attack planning cell. “First responders, rescue teams – they kill them. They strike again, on top of them.”

 
This horrendous crime is intended to carry out two of Israel’s goals: shutter remaining Gaza medical facilities and kill journalists that are reporting on the genocide.

Israel claiming the killing of civilians was in error is a laughable lie. They targeted a functioning hospital, twice.







There should be Nuremberg style trials for Israeli government people and the IDF.
 
There should be Nuremberg style trials for Israeli government people and the IDF.

Yeah, it turns out that Norm Finkelstein really was right all along. Israel is a nation of murderers.

A nation of ethno-supremacist colonizers will always devolve into mad self-victimizing butchery.
 
This horrendous crime is intended to carry out two of Israel’s goals: shutter remaining Gaza medical facilities and kill journalists that are reporting on the genocide.

Israel claiming the killing of civilians was in error is a laughable lie. They targeted a functioning hospital, twice.








Double tapping a hospital, Russian style. Only Israel is far more inhumane and cruel to the people they lord over.
 
@Allan

Don't worry. Israeli authorities are going to investigate what happened and that will make it alt. right, just as the State of Israel has investigated and severely dealt with all other allegations of war crimes. The jails of Israel are bursting with war crime prisoners. Who knew so many Palestinians were willing to commit war crimes on behalf of the State of Israel against their own people? Those Pali's are an inscrutable lot, eh wot?

Kill about twenty human beings to take out a security camera? Perfectly sensible and utterly legal. Those five to six reporters sheltering on the other side of that wall were clearly terrorists spreading terror with their cameras and words. /sarcasm.

Be well and be safe.
Evilroddy.
 
Yup. The tank commander that was "just following orders", some members of the government cabinet and Netanyahu himself should all be tried. Unfortunately victors don't face war crimes trials.
Allan:

So make the present-day government of the State of Israel the losers by boycotts, sanctions, asset seizures and denial of trade and then prosecute those government officials, after Israeli voters throw them out by the ballot box.

Be well and be safe.
Evilroddy.
 
Yeah, it turns out that Norm Finkelstein really was right all along. Israel is a nation of murderers.

A nation of ethno-supremacist colonizers will always devolve into mad self-victimizing butchery.

That's why Norman is a pariah and had his career as a professor destroyed. He told/tells the truth in such a meticulous way they can't refute it so the other option is to destroy and demonize.
 
Double tapping a hospital, Russian style. Only Israel is far more inhumane and cruel to the people they lord over.


I think most supremacist based regimes are happy to control the other but in Israels case control isn't enough, the aim is to ethnically cleanse and so control , although necessary to inflict mass human rights violations and keep the resistance down, it offers little or nothing to the real goal.

I've not read it myself yet but there is a book available that was written by two Israelis in around 2004/5 iirc called Lords of the Land which outlines how the settlements have been used for exactly that.

 
Allan:

So make the present-day government of the State of Israel the losers by boycotts, sanctions, asset seizures and denial of trade and then prosecute those government officials, after Israeli voters throw them out by the ballot box.

Be well and be safe.
Evilroddy.


BDS has always been my preferred approach too
 
Double tapping a hospital, Russian style. Only Israel is far more inhumane and cruel to the people they lord over.
….the modern variant of double tap strikes were pioneered by American drone pilots in Afghanistan and Pakistan during the Obama administration.

“Few if any militaries admit to using double-tap strikes as an overt tactic, and Israel is not the only country alleged to have done so. In 2012, the Bureau for Investigative Journalism foundthat from 2009 to 2012, CIA drone strikes in Pakistan killed at least 50 civilians “in follow-up strikes when they had gone to help victims.”

 
There will be no sanctions so long as the US has Israels back imo

While it does not help the innocent Palestinians at the moment, it is clear that Israel's years of unlimited aid and shielding from the United States are numbered. Thankfully, the younger generations despise Israel. The right-wing hates Israel for isolationist reasons and many for antisemitic reasons. The left-wing hates them mainly for humanitarian/social justice reasons. When the Boomers are mostly gone over the next decade, support for Israel will end.
 
Republicans, not Democrats, are supported by Israel, IDF, ESPECIALLY Bibi, Smotrich, Ben-Gvir, now Neville Gantz and Likud.

Republicans are responsible for the daily crimes against humanity committed by Israel, etc since the barbaric acts of the Hamas terrorists.

Where did Hamas terrorists get their billions to build their tunnel systems and get WoWs?
 
it is clear that Israel's years of unlimited aid and shielding from the United States are numbered.

Not before the US blocks Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and his delegation from attending a UN meeting by revoking their visas.

And for the MAGA out there, Abbas is not from Gaza and is not part of Hamas.
 
While it does not help the innocent Palestinians at the moment, it is clear that Israel's years of unlimited aid and shielding from the United States are numbered.

I sincerely hope that's true, Felis Leo
Thankfully, the younger generations despise Israel.

I think they've seen behind the mask more than any previous generation
The right-wing hates Israel for isolationist reasons and many for antisemitic reasons.

For sure the US right contains many genuine anti semites. In the UK, in contrast, still sees much support for Israel on the right due to its shift from Jew hate to Muslim hate.
The left-wing hates them mainly for humanitarian/social justice reasons.

Agreed.
When the Boomers are mostly gone over the next decade, support for Israel will end.

Let's hope so and there's not another card that Zionists can play to maintain their position of impunity.
 
Back
Top Bottom