• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Is Calling Someone A Typical Black Person Racist?

Is it racist to use the phrase "a typical black person"?

  • Total voters
    18

Caine

DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
23,483
Reaction score
7,284
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
http://campaignspot.nationalreview.com/post/?q=MDg1MTk0YjQ2YjI1ZDBhNDYzMTA4Y2NhMDA4ZWRlOWU=

So, Obama has been quoted as saying that...

............to a Philadelphia Radio Host 2 days after his "great speech" that was made.

To reference his speech

So, with that said, the question begs to be asked.

Do you think it is racist is someone makes a comment that someone else was a "typical black person"??

For example, is it racist for me to say that Shanikqua is an unemployed single mother of three living in Section 8 (free) housing , receiving a welfare check, her children are on free meals at the local school due to their lack of income, yet mom has a very nice car from one of her drug dealer boyfriends, and she doesn't go a day without some liquor. You know, a typical black woman.

Is this type of stereotyping acceptable?
 
Is the statement one that intends to demean, insult, or indicate inferiority among people of the race?
 
If the 'typical' white person was racist, blacks would have 0 rights.




If the 'typical' white was as loving and understanding as Jeremiah Wright,...
 
Iriemon said:
Is the statement one that intends to demean, insult, or indicate inferiority among people of the race?
Click to expand...

Generalizing people as "typical (insert race here) person" is bad. Period.

Regardless of what your INTENT is, there is someone who is offended by your representation of what a typical "insert race here" person is.

I am insulted by Obama's suggestion that a typical white woman is in fear of a black person she witnesses while walking along the streets. Because this generalization is that of a "typical white woman" being a racist woman who fears blacks on the basis of the color of their skin.
 
Caine said:
Generalizing people as "typical (insert race here) person" is bad. Period.
Click to expand...

Why? Typical doesn't mean absolute. As well, stereotyping isn't racism.


The "typical white woman" that he referred to was his grandmother. Given that, she must have lived in the time of the the antebellum south, and probably through the Jim Crow era. Most likely, Obama is correct about this "typical white woman" stereotype. It may not be true today, but you must consider his context.
 
Lightdemon said:
Why? Typical doesn't mean absolute. As well, stereotyping isn't racism.
Click to expand...
Funny.
Because if I stereotype that blacks eat Fried Chicken and Watermelon, that makes me racist.

There is nothing hateful about this stereotype. However, Its WHO im Stereotyping that makes it racist. :roll:





He didn't give it the context of age or era.

He said, "SHE IS A TYPICAL WHITE WOMAN."
 
Caine said:
Funny.
Because if I stereotype that blacks eat Fried Chicken and Watermelon, that makes me racist.

There is nothing hateful about this stereotype. However, Its WHO im Stereotyping that makes it racist. :roll:
Click to expand...

I don't think that's racist. What's racist about it?

Do you discriminate against people who eat fried chicken? Watermelon?

Or are you just categorizing people based on what they eat? I can tell you right now, that Thai people like thier food spicier than fire itself. Is that racist? No. It's just a stereotype, a category.

The second you discriminate, meaning acting upon your stereotype, then it becomes racism. Restriction based on stereotype is racism. Stereotyping alone is not racism.




He didn't give it the context of age or era.

He said, "SHE IS A TYPICAL WHITE WOMAN."
Click to expand...

He said it was his grandmother. This is a given. I'm sorry you couldn't read between the lines.
 
well, no one seemed to notice or care when Obama was not a "typical black candidate":

Obama is not typical black candidate | USA Today (Society for the Advancement of Education) | Find Articles at BNET.com

or when this excerpt from Obama's book appeared in TIME Magazine:

"...the typical black sermon freely acknowledged that all..."

or about this guy saying stuff about Obama not representing the "typical black as the scapegoat":

The Black Commentator - January 10, 2008 - Issue 259

I wonder if the Clinton camp remembers this:

In a 1995 interview, Clinton's Surgeon General Joycelyn Elders called Sen. Jesse Helms a "typical white, Southern male bigot."

Steven Leavitt spoke about the "typical white child" on p. 165 of "Freakonomics":

Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist ... - Google Book Search

and "typical white person" is mentioned in 65 other (respectacle) books here:

"typical white person" - Google Book Search

how about 62 mentions of "average white households"?

"typical white household" - Google Book Search

did anybody care when Michael Sherradan, Director of the Center for Social Development at Washington University made a testimony before the Senate Finance Committee on April 28, 2005, and spoke about what life for a "typical white person" was like?

oftentimes "typical" can be used when speaking about what is statistical probable, and unfortunately stereotypes are often true. everybody knows what is meant. but no one "piles on" unless we're incited to.

this is another manufactured "scandal". our society is illiterate. something as crucial as our election process is reduced to two-word soundbites used to distract attention from real issues. never mind that the candidates have policy positions on things that matter. it's pathetic -- anything that can be used against the front runner, will be. heaven help us.

I can't answer the poll question, because it entirely depends upon the context. but now you know how I stand on the whole matter, anyhow.
 
Last edited:

This reminds me of the Prison my Dad worked at. The inmates were on a hunger strike for a couple days until they served fried chicken and watermelon. That's not racist. They like that stuff, it's true. Middle Easteners like falafels. Asians like seafood. Mexicans like ....you get the point.

You keep harping on this as if it weren't true. Heck, tell me you have never warned someone white that they shouldn't be in a predominantly black area of town after dark. That doesn't make you racist. It makes you cautious for their safety (once you've determined that they aren't from the neighborhood or drug customers).
 

typical - Definition from the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary

Typical isn't a derogatory term. And for you people feigning outrage over this, are you saying that you can't put adjectives in front of a race or else it's racist? That is rediculous.
 

Sorry you're insulted. Have a crumpet.
 
Was the comment about a typical white women racist? Probably not. Did he negatively steotype a group of people? I think so. I really, honestly do believe that most white people have moved past the point his grandmother(and mine) are at.

Was his comment really stupid to make in light of the rest of the controversy surrounding him right now? Absolutely. It really is time for him to shut up about race before he digs himself a deeper hole than he already is in.
 


I personally believe his Grandma is a long way from being a racist, after all she raised and nurtured a black grandson.........If she was a racist I doubt if she would do that...........
 
Niether is mine Navy Pride, despite the culture she grew up in. On the other hand, I think most people have moved even further past the point where his grandmother is, and mine. One of my big issues with Obama's big speach was his comparing his grandmother to his preacher, when his grandmother, from the sounds of it is not truly racist, while his preacher is preaching hate and racism.
 
independent_thinker2002 said:
Typical isn't a derogatory term. And for you people feigning outrage over this, are you saying that you can't put adjectives in front of a race or else it's racist? That is rediculous.
Click to expand...


Thats the standard that is held to a white person making a "typical" remark about most other races.
 

What is funny is that my grandmother on my mom's side wasn't like this at all. And she never saw a black person until she was 18 and married to my Grandpa and went with him to his first duty station in the Marines. (She was raised in West Virginia). She might have been like that at first because she mostly heard negative things about blacks. Its like when people who have only heard negative things about pitbull dogs actually meet one in person (in a positive environment, not by being chased by one for intruding its owner's private property) they learn that the dog isn't as bad as they thought. At least thats one way to put her initial views of blacks. But she was the first person in my family to accept my best friend from my hometown (a black guy) as one of my friends.

My father and his mother (other grandma), it took them a little more time to get to know my friend HIMSELF (not just his color) before they were able to let their suspicions drop.

However, I wouldn't call them "typical white people" because there isn't anything typical about reserving judgment on someone based upon the color of their skin.
 
There is a way to say it that isnt but when your in the public eye its always shaky ground.

Its pretty much a fact politicians and people in the media dont have the same freedom of speech as everyone else.
 


I agree. To get called a typical whatever can be offensive. Just because you are a certain race doesn't mean you are the typical stereotype of that race.

IT2002 said:
That's not racist. They like that stuff, it's true. Middle Easteners like falafels. Asians like seafood. Mexicans like ....you get the point.
Click to expand...

But that's not always true and to get catergorized by your ethniticy to "like" something is wrong. Not all Asians like seafood and not all black people like fried chicken. To insinuate that they do is stereotyping them and making them into your idea of a typical ------ person, which they may not be. It may not be racist but it's offensive and stereotypical.
 
Caine said:
Is this type of stereotyping acceptable?
Click to expand...

It is just as racist as saying thats a typical jew,white person and etc.
 
independent_thinker2002 said:
typical - Definition from the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary

Typical isn't a derogatory term. And for you people feigning outrage over this, are you saying that you can't put adjectives in front of a race or else it's racist? That is rediculous.
Click to expand...

It's the pointing out race AT ALL in that particular situation that is the SEPERATION of one race from another and generalizing about one of those race's behaviors. THAT'S the problem. THAT, combined with the particularly sticky situation Obama has due to his relationship with a bigoted anti-American pastor--he needs to choose words on this issue carefully since he is under the microscope.

http://www.debatepolitics.com/1057565626-post90.html

In the context in which Obama used the three words "typical White woman"--it was an indelicate reference to the supposed reaction caucasian women have to black men on the street--in other words--his grandma is like any other "typical white woman" who would judge her safety threatened by confronting a black man on the street. HUUUUUUUGGGGGGGEEEEEEE generalization (and frankly, BULLSH!T). In this regard, as a white woman, I am being labeled by the generalization that I fear for my safety when on the street with a black man simply due to the color of his skin--ergo a racist reaction. That is both WRONG and INSULTING.

http://www.debatepolitics.com/1057565622-post89.html
 
Last edited:

Yes, there are exceptions to the rule so to speak. But typically, it is the case. Stereotypes can be offensive, but not always. Stereotypes happen because certain characterisitics fit the type. Be honest, are you surprised when a black person likes fried chicken? Is it a shock to you when an Asian likes seafood? Would you tell them, "I never would have guessed that you would like that."?

Is saying that your "typical black person" votes for Obama offensive? It's backed by empirical data. Are facts offensive?
 



so then you have the "facts" to prove obama's granny is a "typical white woman"?


post em.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…