• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Getting Freaky with the Talmud

N

Navy Seal Patriot

Banned
Joined
Aug 17, 2006
Messages
269
Reaction score
1
Location
Waupun Wis
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Very Conservative
I was inspired by the Thread Getting Freaky with Islam. Isn't strange you don't see this shown on Fox, CNN, learning institutions; but they will talk about Islam and Christianity with forked tongues. This will be an excellent litmus test for DP as I have plenty more of these quotes to come. I'm sure most of you won't be shocked or even act like you saw it at all--denial. A sign your a closet Zionist. :mrgreen:


 
Yes but thats what happens when people believe in bullshit written hundreds and hundreds of years ago.
 
Ionism In Context

"Ionism In Context"

The peculiar translation of the quran contained an associated web-link to a host that is seriously dedicated to the quran. The citation was found, along with multiple interpretations, during investigation of how women are treated under that authority. Any quote, with verifyable citation, found in the torah would make more assoiciative sense. Perhaps one might add how the torah is distinct from islam.

Now, paranoia might indicate that the jews are taking over the world, especially since the binladen family flew out of the US without question immediately after 9/11, authorized by the highest levels of government when everyone else was grounded, and arab oil holds approximately 15% of US assets. However, the jews are not pervasively pursuing the institution of socially intolerant, theocratic governments under the meniacle authority of torah law.

Christianity has undergone extensive social inspection, whereas islam has only just begun. In that christianity absolved itself to the responsibilities of the torah law in option to deciding tradition by faith, islam is culturally mired within the immutable edicts of sharia law which does not fit with free society. It must be challenged before the light of day and against the intelligence of modern construction. Phenomenologically, it was written from within in a cave for the sustenance of primitive peoples.
 
Last edited:

Foolish post. As I have posted on another thread, sacred scriptures of all major religions are littered with statements claiming superiority, professing xenophobia, and justifying or encouraging violence. Your post proves two things: 1) that my statement is correct, and 2) that you have a rather obvious agenda which is actually the purpose of this and most of your posts...to attack Judaism.
 

He may be anti-Jew, I don't know. But it is fair to expose the flaws in all the religious texts if we're exposing any of the books. Also fair to expose any flaws in what the non-religious don't believe (if that makes sense), and treat them equally.
 
Foolish post. As I have posted on another thread, sacred scriptures of all major religions are littered with statements claiming superiority, professing xenophobia,
Click to expand...
Strange, you didn't even post that in the Getting Freaky with Islam thread? What's your agenda? Foolish Post.

Yes but thats what happens when people believe in bullshit written hundreds and hundreds of years ago.
Click to expand...
Yea, the Bible and Koran and Talmud were just written in the last 100 years. And that's why people believe in them. BS

He may be anti-Jew,
Click to expand...
So when someone criticizes the Quran then he might be anti-Muslim? And it's not a war on terror but guised that way for his homophope and racist and bigoted views? Agreed.

I realize many closet and open Zionists exist on DP and so here is some more Talmud quotes to see what your protecting and what is your agenda for protecting them? You claim to be Christian--I don't believe you.

 
Last edited:
mikhail said:
Yes but thats what happens when people believe in bullshit written hundreds and hundreds of years ago.
Click to expand...

Yep . . . nail on the head, there.

But of course you can inteprate these books in a hundreds, or thousands, of different ways . . . however some of of the stuff doesn't translate into something "peaceful". "It's a metaphore" they say, but with some of the stuff written in these texts, I can't see it myself.
 
Most religious texts of any length has enough contradictory passages to justify anything. The Desert religions certainly has plenty of situations in which god can either be vengeful or nice. Depending on the leaders desire, they can quote the correct passage to support war or peace. The lack of internal consistency in them makes it very easy to claim religious support for anything you want. Religion can easily be melded into a weapon of war or peace. Buddhism gets a small pass for it being hard justify violent action with it. Many Buddhists have certainly been violent, but rarely can they use religion to bind others to their cause. Furthermore, when followers have already been taught to suspend rational thought when dealing with religion, it makes bending them to a leaders will even easier.
 
Navy Seal Patriot said:
Strange, you didn't even post that in the Getting Freaky with Islam thread? What's your agenda? Foolish Post.
Click to expand...

I've posted the same thing on a couple of threads...don't need to post it everywhere. Nice dodge though...or attempt at a dodge. My position stands. Every ancient religious text has violent, contradictory, xenophobic statements. Your presenting the Talmud, here is agenda-driven. No different then one who is anti-Muslim posting quotes form the Quran.

Furthermore, you offer nothing to debate and no point to your post. What do you want to discuss, here? The fact that you don't say, but just post these quotes, with little commentary and no direction, exposes your purpose. If that's what you want to discuss there is no need to hide. I'm sure there are many who would gladly debate you.
 
tryreading said:
He may be anti-Jew, I don't know. But it is fair to expose the flaws in all the religious texts if we're exposing any of the books. Also fair to expose any flaws in what the non-religious don't believe (if that makes sense), and treat them equally.
Click to expand...

I would agree that a scholarly discussion about the inconsistencies and contradictions of ancient religious texts and their impact on modern society and morals is an excellent discussion/debate. The OP does not do that. All it does is aim the discussion towards a 'my religion is better than yours' debate, a pointless discussion, usually filled with prejudice and bigotry. It also is aimed towards attacking a particular religion.
 

This same type of thread is started pretty regularly to ridicule Christianity and Islam, and Mormonism. I don't know much about the Jewish religion, but it probably deserves equal time.
 
The funny part about this thread is that he chose the Talmud, not the Torah, to use in his criticizm. The Talmud is NOT the Jewish equivalent to the Quran, and it is NOT the Jewish equivalent to the Bible. That would be the Torah, in a sense.

The Talmud would be the jewish equivalent to a Pat Robertson commentary on the bible.
 
tryreading said:
This same type of thread is started pretty regularly to ridicule Christianity and Islam, and Mormonism. I don't know much about the Jewish religion, but it probably deserves equal time.
Click to expand...

I don't disagree with you. I haven't gotten involved in them, too often, lately. In the past I've said the same thing about several different religions, not just Judaism. There is a difference between an intelligent thread and a troll/flame thread. The former are interesting and fun to be involved in, to me. When I see the latter, I'm going to expose them.
 
What a miserable and ignoramous post from someone who said that he learns Judaism and will consider to be a Jew in the future!

You don't have a clue about the things you are talking about!

There is no essence for the Torah without the Talmud which is the Orally Torah that Moses recieved from G-d. You can't understand the Torah without the Talmud at all.

The Talmud is important thing as much as the Torah and the Talmud explains many things regarding the commandments and how to do things and also give explanations to the Torah:

For example, the sentence: Eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth, the Talmud explains that it's about money compencation and not about revenge.

Another example, there is the hospitality of Abraham to the 3 messengers when he welcomed them in warm and he and his wife gave them food and there is also the "warm" hospitality of Laban to Jacob when he kissed him on the mouth.

The difference is that the Talmud explains that Laban kissed Jacob on the mouth because he thought that Jacob hides diamonds in his mouth so he wanted to steal them from him.

Without the Talmud we wouldn't know that at all

And there are many other examples.

So, Caine, you have got to go a long long way before you can say these nonsence of yours in here.

The problem is that some hotile gentiles to Jews are trying to understand the Talmud without Jewish guidnes and they twist it completely.
 

Firstly, it is unnecessary to insult Caine. Secondly, I agree with you. The Talmud, the Oral Law is as important, in different ways, as the Torah. It is, however, more interpretable, and often information is reinterpretted to reflect modern issues. Thirdly, deep Talmudic study is a fairly intense process and probably isn't appropriate for laymen; one must have a significant understanding of the Torah, Jewish history, traditions, etc... in order to do it.
 
 

You're right, its a flame thread. Its just more of the same, not a tool for learning anything.
 

LOL..... I figured I would get this response.
I understand the Talmud is important.
I just had a hard time finding something in the christian world to compare it to.
 
Its just more of the same, not a tool for learning anything.
Click to expand...

But I thought the road to enlightenment was learning everything--be that Christian or some atheist intellectual bard--let's continue the education for those interested in what was hidden from them. Let's see the Christian Harmony in these:

Strange, why no big-wig Zionist supporting Christian tele-evanglist talks about this--unless, they're false prophets.
 

Moderator's Warning:
OK, I asked one before, now I ask again. Either post something debatable, like commentary or questions, or this thread will end.
 
I find it very alarming that the vast majority of Christianity doesn't understand or want to understand the Talmud, as:
You can't understand the Torah without the Talmud at all.
Click to expand...

What is mainstream Christians trying to hide? Why are the Christians and certain media outlets that are Zionist lackeys--want to talk about certain Koran verses and yet nothing of the Talmud? What Judeo Christian Church can talk about the Talmud openly without being labeled racial slurs? I don't know any. I don't know any media outlet neither. I find it very suspicious I cannot find one condemnation of these sick verses. :2wave:
 
People are aligned against you because the vast majority (of the ones that I have seen, at least) of your posts thus far have been for the sole purpose of attacking Jews. You may say that you are just pointing things out, or whatever, but your anti-semitic agenda is pretty clear.

I wouldn't be surprised if you have a Stormfront membership.
 

Sure, learn everything, the good and bad. But recognize that there is both in all religions.

I am not religious. All I want from religious people is for them to understand that there can be no enforcement of their religion through American law. Other than that, they should live long and prosper.
 



People aligned against me? Sure. And quite possibly no one dares to condemn it because then they will be labeled anti-Jewish. A programmed no-response and don't care attitude people have been conditioned with from mainstream religion, Media, and learning institutions. As your term "anti-semitic" shows your lack of understanding due to the conditioning you received via the latter mentioned institutions. Semitic people include Arabs and most of the Muslim world--hence using the word Anti-Semitic just to specifically describe those who call themselves Jews--is a lie the ignorant only believe. Do I hate Jews? Well let's get a few things straight about it:

1. Jews have none or little racial connection to the Biblical Israelites the Judeo-Christians believe to be the Chosen People. 2. The Jews don't just believe in the OT as in a Christian Bible; they believe in the Talmud in which you can see the verses given. 3. The holocaust was very murdersome, but the other genocides have killed way more than just 6 million; the Red Stalin purges and the Red Chinese commie religion have taken out seperately way more than just 6 million--why the constant attention to just the WW2 Jewish genocide and not other genocides? Sympathy = Power + Money + Arms = _____________ you fill in the line to this formula.


I wouldn't be surprised if you have a Stormfront membership.
Click to expand...
Sorry, not a member of Stormfront; are you a member of the JDL or ADL? It wouldn't surprise me at all. People, you can claim all along you don't or won't condemn this because of my supposed agenda--I don't buy it--it's in your agenda to hide it, cover it up and act like it's no big deal; everyone has an agenda; mine based on the factual--show me your facts.
 
Navy Seal Patriot said:
People aligned against me? Sure. And quite possibly no one dares to condemn it because then they will be labeled anti-Jewish.
Click to expand...

OK, let's clear this up, right now. Perhaps the reasons that people don't condemn it are twofold. Firstly, people are aware of your agenda and don't want to feed into it. Secondly, the Talmud, like all other ancient texts, has quotes in it that can be construed as violent and xenophobic. However, as I've stated before, and you consistently overlook (hence, showing your agenda) is that the Talmud is constantly being reinnterpretted in order to reflect modern times. This is an important reason why these quotes are not seen as horrific or xenophobic, currently. With rabinical study and reevaluation, these are not things that Jews follow, andy longer. I hope this helps you to understand why it is obvious that all you are doing is blowing smoke and trying to incite or futher your anti-Jewish agenda.


Now you are being either intentionally obtuse or intellectually disintegritious. Of course Semites include Arabs. The term anti-Semite is used to describe anti-Jewish sentiments. It is not ignorant to do this. It is the standard way that the term is used. It may be ignorant to deny this.

Do I hate Jews?
Click to expand...

Well, answer your own question.

1. Jews have none or little racial connection to the Biblical Israelites the Judeo-Christians believe to be the Chosen People.
Click to expand...

Don't have time to address this one, right now.

2. The Jews don't just believe in the OT as in a Christian Bible; they believe in the Talmud in which you can see the verses given.
Click to expand...

Completely false. The OT is the Torah. Jews absolutely believe in it. Show evidence of your claim, or retract.


Yes, there have been other horrific holocausts. Comparing one attrocity to another is ridiculous...they're all horrific. I will ignore the bold. Standard anti-Semetic rhetoric.


Your facts are an attempt to take facts and spin them towards your agenda. I have shown your facts, when placed in the appropriate context, show a different outcome. If your agenda is to question issues with the Talmud, I've already refuted that. If that's your agenda...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…