• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Front Page Ron Paul Forums: Letter From Rep. Bob Good (R-VA) on Why He Opposes McCarthy for Speaker, Tour-de-Force

munkle

DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 25, 2016
Messages
1,377
Reaction score
446
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed

Bob Good for Congress
Today, I will be working with my Republican colleagues to elect the best conservative Speaker to lead our conference in doing the things voters across America elected us to do back on November 8. That will not be Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA).

During my first race for Congress leading up to the 2020 election, I was urged by hundreds of voters in Virginia's 5th District to oppose Kevin McCarthy for Republican leader. However, after being elected, I was surprised to see the entire Republican Conference vote by acclamation to confirm McCarthy for leader.

During the 2020 new member orientation, my Republican freshmen class members and I were told by Minority Leader McCarthy that we use every procedural tool at our disposal to thwart the radical Democrat agenda. Sadly, that did not happen, as we got rolled by the majority and the American people suffered under the most extreme leftist policies ever enacted by the Democrat majority.

I continued to hear from hundreds of constituents over the past two years, urging me not to support McCarthy for Speaker if we took the majority. I responded in townhall events and media interviews that I would judge him by what he did during my first two years in Congress. I would assess his efforts to truly fight the Democrat agenda, his commitment to true conservative principles, and his willingness to change how Congress operates to empower regular members.

Unfortunately, Kevin McCarthy did nothing to earn my support these past two years as minority leader when he had the near-exclusive opportunity to audition for the Speaker position. He ignored our pleas to make a motion to "vacate the chair", when Nancy Pelosi was at her weakest moments with the Progressive Caucus and the "Squad" threatening her from her most extreme Left flank.

McCarthy did not effectively fight unconstitutional proxy voting, mask requirements, or metal detectors for members to pass thru when going to the House chamber to represent their constituents. He resisted our efforts to require recorded roll-call votes on hundreds of pieces of legislation spending billions of dollars when the Democrats attempted to pass them in an empty chamber by "unanimous consent" voice vote.

McCarthy fought our initial efforts to remove Liz Cheney from her leadership position after she voted to impeach President Trump and began to express public views that were out of step with Republican voters. He did not support removing her from leadership until she later publicly embarrassed him at a press conference.

McCarthy never marshaled Republican members to defeat bills passed by Democrats under "suspension of the rules", and instead helped provide the two-thirds majority needed to pass dozens of these bills "en bloc". He did not support our efforts to use our rare minority leverage to defeat so-called "must pass" National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) bills when Republican votes were needed to pass them. No matter how much they weakened our military with a dangerous woke focus on leftist priorities that diminished military readiness, he personally voted for them four times despite conservatives' pleas to defeat them.

McCarthy falsely promised that Republicans would not provide the votes to pass the $1.2 trillion phony infrastructure bill, and then did nothing to penalize the 13 Republicans who voted for it.

McCarthy's repeated mantra when conservatives urged him to fight the Democrat agenda was "we have a plan". But no plan materialized over the past two years.

McCarthy represents a Republican swamp system that supports and promotes moderates for leadership positions and prime committee assignments, and the exclusion of conservatives. He spent millions of dollars to defeat conservative candidates in the recent 2022 primary races, against the will of the Republican voters in those districts. This is money that should have been utilized to elect more Republicans in the general election.

...

We must elect a Speaker who will utilize the power of the purse as leverage to restore fiscal sanity and defund the government tyranny we campaign against. We must elect a Speaker who will exercise effective oversight against the weaponization of the federal government against its citizens. ...

...

Don't fall for the orchestrated disinformation campaign that falsely asserts that opposing McCarthy is somehow helping Democrats, or that he is the only person capable of leading our conference. Nothing helps the Democrats more than maintaining the status quo and electing a Speaker who will not stand up to their agenda. This is demonstrated by past history when McCarthy was majority leader in 2017 and 2018, and every major spending package he helped pass was done so with a majority of Democrat support, instead of Republicans.... MORE
 
giphy.gif
 

Bob Good for Congress
Today, I will be working with my Republican colleagues to elect the best conservative Speaker to lead our conference in doing the things voters across America elected us to do back on November 8. That will not be Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA).

During my first race for Congress leading up to the 2020 election, I was urged by hundreds of voters in Virginia's 5th District to oppose Kevin McCarthy for Republican leader. However, after being elected, I was surprised to see the entire Republican Conference vote by acclamation to confirm McCarthy for leader.

During the 2020 new member orientation, my Republican freshmen class members and I were told by Minority Leader McCarthy that we use every procedural tool at our disposal to thwart the radical Democrat agenda. Sadly, that did not happen, as we got rolled by the majority and the American people suffered under the most extreme leftist policies ever enacted by the Democrat majority.

I continued to hear from hundreds of constituents over the past two years, urging me not to support McCarthy for Speaker if we took the majority. I responded in townhall events and media interviews that I would judge him by what he did during my first two years in Congress. I would assess his efforts to truly fight the Democrat agenda, his commitment to true conservative principles, and his willingness to change how Congress operates to empower regular members.

Unfortunately, Kevin McCarthy did nothing to earn my support these past two years as minority leader when he had the near-exclusive opportunity to audition for the Speaker position. He ignored our pleas to make a motion to "vacate the chair", when Nancy Pelosi was at her weakest moments with the Progressive Caucus and the "Squad" threatening her from her most extreme Left flank.

McCarthy did not effectively fight unconstitutional proxy voting, mask requirements, or metal detectors for members to pass thru when going to the House chamber to represent their constituents. He resisted our efforts to require recorded roll-call votes on hundreds of pieces of legislation spending billions of dollars when the Democrats attempted to pass them in an empty chamber by "unanimous consent" voice vote.

McCarthy fought our initial efforts to remove Liz Cheney from her leadership position after she voted to impeach President Trump and began to express public views that were out of step with Republican voters. He did not support removing her from leadership until she later publicly embarrassed him at a press conference.

McCarthy never marshaled Republican members to defeat bills passed by Democrats under "suspension of the rules", and instead helped provide the two-thirds majority needed to pass dozens of these bills "en bloc". He did not support our efforts to use our rare minority leverage to defeat so-called "must pass" National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) bills when Republican votes were needed to pass them. No matter how much they weakened our military with a dangerous woke focus on leftist priorities that diminished military readiness, he personally voted for them four times despite conservativ

Good sounds like he must be an even bigger trumptard than McCarthy.
 
Republican politicians (and I use the term derisively) need to wake up and wise up. I'm afraid we've elected a bunch of childish don't give a crap autism spectrum nuts. I don't see any resemblance to the party of Reagan and Newt Gingrich.
 
Republican politicians (and I use the term derisively) need to wake up and wise up. I'm afraid we've elected a bunch of childish don't give a crap autism spectrum nuts. I don't see any resemblance to the party of Reagan and Newt Gingrich.

Yep, it started in 2016.
 
Yep, it started in 2016.

And what was the other side offering up for wielding extreme executive authority in 2016? It was Hillary Clinton that's who. The only candiate in this or any other world I'd rather put my balls in a hydrolic press and just get it over with before voting for her.
 
And what was the other side offering up for wielding extreme executive authority in 2016? It was Hillary Clinton that's who. The only candiate in this or any other world I'd rather put my balls in a hydrolic press and just get it over with before voting for her.

That's just dumb. Hillary was clearly a WAY BETTER candidate than the lying grifter conman who killed 100,000s of Americans... on purpose... when he found out COVID would hit blue states more... guess he did not realize most of the ones he killed would be Rs anyway.

Not to mention he turned out to be a Traitor too.
 
That's just dumb. Hillary was clearly a WAY BETTER candidate than the lying grifter conman who killed 100,000s of Americans... on purpose... when he found out COVID would hit blue states more... guess he did not realize most of the ones he killed would be Rs anyway.

Not to mention he turned out to be a Traitor too.

All of Trump's alleged misbehaviors with Russia, Russia, Russia were pure fiction created the HRH for President 2016 campaign. Fact is fact no matter how embarrassing it may be for your own side.
 
Republican politicians (and I use the term derisively) need to wake up and wise up. I'm afraid we've elected a bunch of childish don't give a crap autism spectrum nuts. I don't see any resemblance to the party of Reagan and Newt Gingrich.
Debasing autistic folks as part of a smack against politicians is unacceptable.

Find a better choice of words to voice your displeasure with Republican politicians.
 
Debasing autistic folks as part of a smack against politicians is unacceptable.

Find a better choice of words to voice your displeasure with Republican politicians.

How about comparing politicians to people with brain syphilis instead. Would that be allowed?
 
And what was the other side offering up for wielding extreme executive authority in 2016? It was Hillary Clinton that's who. The only candiate in this or any other world I'd rather put my balls in a hydrolic press and just get it over with before voting for her.
Maybe she'll run again and give you another go at it.
 
How about comparing politicians to people with brain syphilis instead. Would that be allowed?
Why not just call shit for brains politicians, “shit for brains politicians”?
 
Fact is fact no matter how embarrassing it may be for your own side.
You might want to reexamine THAT statement, it may mean something you didn't intend it to mean.
 
How about comparing politicians to people with brain syphilis instead.
Man oh man, you really don't see how your comments look on you, do you?
 
All of Trump's alleged misbehaviors with Russia, Russia, Russia were pure fiction created the HRH for President 2016 campaign. Fact is fact no matter how embarrassing it may be for your own side.

Wrong. Read Mueller report. Trump asked Russia for help, Trump people shared proprietory data with Kremlin, Russia helped Trump in different ways. (and yes, then Trump became Putin's lackey). And if you noticed, I mentioned a lot of other-than-Russia things in my post but you chose to move it back to Russia.
 
Wrong. Read Mueller report. Trump asked Russia for help, Trump people shared proprietory data with Kremlin, Russia helped Trump in different ways. (and yes, then Trump became Putin's lackey). And if you noticed, I mentioned a lot of other-than-Russia things in my post but you chose to move it back to Russia.

If Trump was in Putin's pocket why did General Milley at the time assure his Russian counterparts behind the scenes that they would never allow Trump to attack Russia? Answer me that and I'll ask you another one.
 
If Trump was in Putin's pocket why did General Milley at the time assure his Russian counterparts behind the scenes that they would never allow Trump to attack Russia? Answer me that and I'll ask you another one.

I don't know what General Milley did. If he did what you said, that does not conflict with the idea of Trump being in Putin's pocket. It also would not tell me whether Trump knew what Milley were doing and/or directing him to do so.
 
That's just dumb. Hillary was clearly a WAY BETTER candidate than the lying grifter conman who killed 100,000s of Americans... on purpose... when he found out COVID would hit blue states more... guess he did not realize most of the ones he killed would be Rs anyway.

Not to mention he turned out to be a Traitor too.
More than a million have died through reckless insane republican policy of do nothing.... regarding COVID 19.
 
More than a million have died through reckless insane republican policy of do nothing.... regarding COVID 19.

More than a million died in US but not all those deaths are due to the do-nothing policy. Many people died in other countries too that DID try to do it right. That's why I said Trump is responsible for killing 100,000s, not a million+.
 
That's just dumb. Hillary was clearly a WAY BETTER candidate than the lying grifter conman who killed 100,000s of Americans... on purpose... when he found out COVID would hit blue states more... guess he did not realize most of the ones he killed would be Rs anyway.

Not to mention he turned out to be a Traitor too.
If she had won the land vote as well as the popular, the way I see it going down is this :

Hillary wins and has a Republican congress to deal with. They allow her to do absolutely nothing and spend most of their time investigating absolutely nothing. The 2018 midterms would have been a wipeout, and there probably would have been a successful impeachment attempt including conviction. The pandemic would still have hit in 2020, and the orange imbecile would have been on tour the whole time running for president again. The Democratic candidate, whether an impeached but not convicted Clinton or new president Kaine would be running against Democratic fatigue, the pandemic, and a cratered economy. Tweety would have won in 2020 and would probably win again in 2024, as the economy is going to improve after medical science gets at least partially on top of the pandemic. He would claim full credit for that, of course. Basically, either way, we would have been stuck with that malignantly narcissistic psychopath. This is a lousy call to have to make, but I think that we are probably better off with land electing him in 2016 instead of in 2020.
 
This is a lousy call to have to make, but I think that we are probably better off with land electing him in 2016 instead of in 2020.

100,000s lot more people would have lived as govt response to covid would have been reasonable.

We also would not have had all the environmental damage during those years.
 
Questions for Representative Bob Good.

- In your letter you state you have heard from "hundreds of" your constituents asking you not to support McCarthy. My question is what percentage of your constituents is the "hundreds"?
- Have you done any outreach to your constituents asking them their opinion on who should be speaker.
- People are more likely to complain that they are to call and praise a nomination. Just look at any forums. Heck if one relied on posts on a vehicle forum noone would buy a vehicle. Most people post to say I don't like rather than I like this vehicle.

- I am not a McCarthy supporter. I was a lifetime Republican till the MAGAts started to make outlandish claims they could not back up. I left to become an independent. You sir, should take a hard look at how Congress has been and is currently operating. We the People are not impressed.
 
100,000s lot more people would have lived as govt response to covid would have been reasonable.

We also would not have had all the environmental damage during those years.
My guess is that more people would have refused to wear masks, refused to take real medicine, and would have avoided the vaccines. I can't imagine the far right accepting a Clinton-linked lockdown, either, and their propaganda would have encouraged large scale unrest. We'd probably have King Tangface right now, and the environmental damage would probably have happened four years later. The upside is that the mango mistake wouldn't have gotten multiple SCOTUS appointments prior to 2020, but I'm not sure that I believe that McTurtle would have allowed Clinton SCOTUS nominations, either. Tweety would have most likely filled the seats in 2021.
 
Back
Top Bottom