• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Central American migrants are on a word-of-mouth exodus to the U.S.

j-mac

DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 11, 2009
Messages
41,104
Reaction score
12,202
Location
South Carolina
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Conservative

This is a crisis totally of this administrations making....And this is what they are bringing with them...



Reports of TB, and worse have been reported...And also reports of hardcore MS13 gang members, and affiliates have entered...What the hell is this administration doing? And what should we do to stop this insanity?
 
Would it be a violation of the Geneva Convention to consider this mass migration even though it is largely by independant minds, an act of war (Invasion)?? If so could we declare 'War?' on illegal immigrants? We have a big enough military and advanced enough weaponry to shoot down anyone trying to come into our country. Our reason for war? Economic subterfuge by illegals placing a heavy burden on the american system and a technical "invasion" of residents of those country into ours. Thoughts?
 


I think that there could be a case made in that regard, especially since it is fact that the Governments of these countries typically hand out pamphlets describing how to enter the US, and apply for benefits like welfare.
 

Ahhh, kill people trying to find a better life for themselves and their children, great.
 
Ahhh, kill people trying to find a better life for themselves and their children, great.

I'd frame it more as. Kill people who wish to live off of the american welfare state, who wish to leech off of americans and refuse to take proactive steps to IMPROVE THEIR OWN country. If they don't come here legally than they are criminalss, and this qualifies as an act of WAR because in my opinion it is an INVASION.
 
We need to seal the border with a few infantry divisions.
 
We need to seal the border with a few infantry divisions.
No troops are needed, barely a fence, and half the Border patrol agents.

Just requiring Citizenship/ID for ANY Job in the USA.
No job, No immigrants.

Any Business hiring an illegal should face $5000/$10000/JAIL penalties. (Watch em run, and watch Minimum Wage go up withOut legislation)
Individuals hiring illegals the same.
No money, No immigrants.

No one will institute this simple plan. They are ALL Frauds Posturing with troops, fences, etc.
Bush and Obama, bad and worse. Congress the same clowns.
Amnesty-Obama causing this most recent crisis, Amnesty-Vote-for-me-in-Texas Bush caused a few earlier ones.

I'm generally progressive, but Obama is a Failed President. This is a spectacular example.
Biden is in Central America begging for mercy, pleading with them to stop coming. Doing Damage control for the crisis Obama made.

NO Amnesty, NO 'Path to Citizenship', NO Have-your-baby-here/send-your-children, NO Jobs. Nada.
ALL incentives must be removed. Absolutely.
 
Last edited:

How will that stop the minors from crossing to be with their families?
 
How will that stop the minors from crossing to be with their families?
What percent of illegals come in under your scenario?
Why do you Ignore the Meat of the plan for the exception?
Any answer to the Bulk of my proposal? No.

Nonetheless, to be a US Citizen (and have an ID to work), you have to be born here/have a birth certificate, or be a naturalized citizen.
I don't see an Illegal immigrant child having either. Do You?
Illegals shouldn't leave their children behind and wouldn't have to if they Apply Legally to come here as a family.
 
Last edited:

How can you say that is an exception.

This story is about thousands of minors being held that crossed just for that reason.

I am ignoring anything, as I have no control over the immigration policy.

Talk to Obama about it.
 
How can you say that is an exception.
This story is about thousands of minors being held that crossed just for that reason.
I am ignoring anything, as I have no control over the immigration policy.
Talk to Obama about it.
So you have NO answer despite the fact I answered you Completely
These illegal immigrant children would Never get the ID to go to School or Work and would eventually be deported or voluntarily leave. (and ergo just Not come)
My proposal ensures that.

Your BS attempt to bust it Failed because of (to be polite) poor logic.
 
Last edited:

Are you sure about what you bolded?

If states are giving illegals drivers licenses, why do you think they would not let the children to go to school.

You think what might happen without taking into account that Democrats control many áreas and they don't care about the law.
 
DUH No.
Illegals would NOT be able to get licences either without National Citizen IDs.
And even if they got licenses, they still couldn't get JOBS without NATIONAL ID cards..
Anyone without a National Proof-of-citizenship ID is here ILLEGALLY and subject to immediate deportation.

Your replies are emptily argumentative and Inane.


EDIT to the below.
"out-thinking" you was not exactly tough. You clearly couldn't comprehend this simple proposal: National ID.
It answered All your contingencies.
 
Last edited:

Whatever you say. I guess you just outthought me. Congratulations.

No if you could live inthe real world, you would see what is going on.
 
I think that there could be a case made in that regard, especially since it is fact that the Governments of these countries typically hand out pamphlets describing how to enter the US, and apply for benefits like welfare.

Really?in that case, the White House shall denounce them.
 
The federal government would act more quickly and with greater force if the problem involved some rancher in Nevada.
 
All these people invading North America and then end up in the United States. So we could cut down on all these illegal immigrants by helping Mexico block off their southern border?
 
The major fix in the illegal immigration problem is working with Mexico, etc. to improve their economies so people there won't feel they need to come here.

There is no reason on earth why Mexico shouldn't be in the G8 when Japan is. Mexico has the potential for a thriving agriculture industry 12 months out of the year, they have oil, sunny white sand beaches a archeological sites that attract tourism, convenient shipping access to both the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans and on the border with the number one economy in the world. If they get their act together and we iron out some cultural issues I could support inviting Mexico and Canada into the US.
 

Small problem. First you need a people and a culture who on the whole, are capable of achieving such a thing. It should be obvious, Mexico has neither the people, nor the culture to do so.
 



:mrgreen:
 
Small problem. First you need a people and a culture who on the whole, are capable of achieving such a thing. It should be obvious, Mexico has neither the people, nor the culture to do so.

I don't think there's anything innate that keeps the people of Mexico from building a world-class country. They're already so hard working they put most of us to shame. I think the government needs to deal with corruption and we both need to deal with out respective drug problems; us as customers and them as suppliers. I think making English a second language taught every year in schools would be super beneficial considering their success would largely depend upon a strong relationship with America. Plus American acculturation with several English American radio and TV stations simulcast in every Mexican city and North American (US) Civics and History taught throughout school years.
 

I can't agree with very much of what you've written. Here in California, they have entire public schools, including administrators, where English is a second language. There is no incentive to integrate into this country, and there is no reason to want to. We have encouraged a peasant people, who have chosen to remain peasants through countless generations, to come here, and be taken care of.

These attitudes about their own culture go back for generation after generation. Until we wake up to this truth, the US will just represent another group of people they willingly allow themselves to be exploited by.
 

new immigration policy would make it illegal to issue any valid ID to any non-citizen.
 
Ahhh, kill people trying to find a better life for themselves and their children, great.

Nice kneejerk. If they truly wanted a better life for their families they would stay and build one where they are.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…