No it doesn't a man that identifies as a woman is still a man. That doesn't change because you have a gender identity.
1.)You're not a Dr or a psychologist and you have zero proof that a child is being pushed by parents or their treatment team to transition because of medical privacy.
Yeah let’s just make up some bs excuse rather then admit that it is a scientific fact that males have a rather large biological advantage over females when it comes to most athletic categories.Nah, IMO, I think it's just like many men being so much more freaked out by gay men but less often have issues with lesbians.
Many are terrified of ambiguity of any kind. "It might move"
Like the fundie Muslim males who believe it's the responsibility of the women to cover up and remove all temptation or ambiguity (like being rejected). So in the US, it's the responsibility of the gay males and trans to make it very very clear so no men ever feel the slightest interest or attraction.Heaven forbid! Why should they have to manage "their" feelings? More male entitlement.
I don't have to be a doctor or a psychiatrist to know that if a four-year-old says they're transgender it's because their parents are telling them that they are.
Don't believe you. They may feel something is wrong but unless they've been introduced to the idea there's no way they know about it.
But if you're 4 the confusion is caused by your parents
You should support this too. The entire medical industry is about gatekeeping. Have you ever wondered why you need a prescription to get certain drugs?
Gatekeeping effective treatment until 18 is very dangerous. These kids are going to Drs and psychologists for the diagnosis and treatment. They arent getting hormones at the playground.
Even if it is true, that instead of winning a championship, she came in second and we were to grant your premise that the determinative factor was trans status as opposed to a myriad of others contributing as much or more, There are other championships to be had. its not as though trans athletes are populating the sports world, or that those few who do, are truly talented gifted top level dedicated athletes squeezing out everyone else. Professional athletes have competitions every week that they travel around for , every other week, every month, multiple times a years, multiple years.
Yes that is what I am talking about. You are inventing this idea about what the right thinks based on nothing more than your feelings.
Why?
This isn't organic in a 4 year old. A 14 year old maybe.
No they don't have you ever been around a 4 year old they know squat.
No. It's a social construct that a child that age must be coached in in order to identify that way.
Nobody's ever died from not being able to get plastic surgery.
I'd question the ethics of doctors prescribing this to a child that young.
Anyone can say "na huh", it doesnt take any thought.
It's funny how 'get a clue and recognize some people, including children, have a brain/body mismatch' so they stop being ignorant about it turns into 'encouragement of children to deny their biological sex' as if 'encouragement is the issue, in order to discriminate against transgender people. It's the same gabage as 'conversion therapy' fo]r gay people.
Or make them heterosexual.
It's simple, but not very good. Transgender women seem to fit in the middle between competing with women and competing with men, with some possible advantages with women and possible disadvantages with men. But they are so few in number as to make 'their own sporting events' impractical. It's not a "simple" topic, which helps make it exploited for bigotry by oligarch interests.
And I am telling you your opinion is nonsense and comes from your sexist views.OK
I said it was my opinion. I dont care if you like it or not, that's not what discussions are about. Do you have a counterargument or would you rather just get bent out of shape?
I gave a legitimate example of fundamantalist Muslim males. I explained a viewpoint. All I see is you typing "na huh". That's not debate and since you cant even articulate why you disagree with me, I disregard it
I asked you to tell me where I was dishonest. You did not do so and now say I lied. Quote my lie(s). It certainly was civil and what was demeaning? I didnt say all men. Does it apply to you, is that why you're trying to make this about me instead of the subject?
More "na huh"
It is there for anyone to consider.Yes I did. You not liking my reasoning does not mean I didn’t tell it to you.More "na huh"
You did not, you are lying not me. Calling it "crap" is merely more "na huh." So...again you cannot debate.
I cant debate if you only post "na huh" so what else would you like?
Quote my lies? How many times do I need to ask? You know you'd prove me wrong if you could. So...you seem to be the one needing to lie instead of just debating.
Off you go then if you cant directly address what I wrote in my original post 149.
Because it is unfair to girls and you'll never be rid of TRUMP with these extremist views.
How is unfair for girls to compete against girls?
Just because someone can verbally claim they are a different sex or a cat or a dog or a gorilla or a plant doesn't make it so.
