• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous? [W:286]

Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

Are you kidding me with this?

There is no question whatsoever that every single pro-abort is bigoted against the unborn. The post you quoted addresses this.

If someone told you that they didn't hate black folks, only they used a ridiculous slur to refer to them and told you that black folks aren't really human beings or people and that it's OK for them to be treated like someone else's property and even be killed at their owner's whim... Would you believe them? Or would you consider the original statement to be deceit, and the following comments to be hateful and bigoted?

It's the same thing here. Pro-aborts hold their fellow human beings in disdain, appropriate of nothing.

No, you didnt answer the question. Are you saying that anyone that does not see the unborn as equal to the born is bigoted against and hates the unborn?

If so, then you claim that before women were recognized as equal to men in this country that all men were bigoted against women and hated them. Is that what you are saying?
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

There is no question whatsoever that every single pro-abort is bigoted against the unborn.
The usual moronic uneducated drivel. Is that why most opponents to morality coercers are parents?
 
I answered your question directly and honestly.

Pro-aborts are bigoted against the unborn. I'm not going to go off on a million off-topic tangents with you.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?


From your article...fresh or frozen.
If it is frozen it needs to frozen right away and kept at a constant temperature.

There is no way that planned Parenthood is making a profit in the tissue donation program if they are only getting the $30 to $100 fees mentioned in the first undercover video

From Fact Check

Jim Vaught, president of the International Society for Biological and Environmental Repositories and formerly the deputy director of the National Cancer Institute’s Office of Biorepositories and Biospecimen Research, told us in an email that “$30 to $100 per sample is a reasonable charge for clinical operations to recover their costs for providing tissue.” In fact, he said, the costs to a clinic are often much higher, but most operations that provide this kind of tissue have “no intention of fully recovering [their] costs, much less making a profit.”

Unspinning the Planned Parenthood Video
 
Last edited:
No, you didnt answer the question. Are you saying that anyone that does not see the unborn as equal to the born is bigoted against and hates the unborn?

If so, then you claim that before women were recognized as equal to men in this country that all men were bigoted against women and hated them. Is that what you are saying?
I answered your question directly and honestly.

Pro-aborts are bigoted against the unborn. I'm not going to go off on a million off-topic tangents with you.

So you have no foundation for the basis of pro-choice people hating the unborn except your own feelings? And you cannot actually answer the tough question that might prove it? That's what I thought.

You really should just preface your statements in the future then with, *IMO I believe* that all pro-choice supporters and the courts and many medical professionals hate the unborn. So that you can post honestly. Just a suggestion.
 
So you have no foundation for the basis of pro-choice people hating the unborn except your own feelings? And you cannot actually answer the tough question that might prove it? That's what I thought.

You really should just preface your statements in the future then with, *IMO I believe* that all pro-choice people hate the unborn. So that you can post honestly. Just a suggestion.

What a nonsensical statement on your part!

This was all just explained to you at length.

It is not my feeling that you use slurs to refer to the unborn.
It is not my feeling that you have denied their humanity and want to continue to deny them personhood.
It is not my feeling that you regard them as property of their mother to be disposed of at their master's whim.

My feelings towards this factual record of your statements are things like disgust and contempt, but the record is what it is, and it is fact that you have confirmed bigotry against the unborn. You are not alone in this, of course.
 
It is not my feeling that you use slurs to refer to the unborn.

Please tell me what slurs I have used against the unborn. A list will be fine.

It is not my feeling that you have denied their humanity and want to continue to deny them personhood.

Please show where I have ever claimed the unborn are not human. Good luck with that!

It is not my feeling that you regard them as property of their mother to be disposed of at their master's whim.

Property might be closer to how the unborn are considered legally, but then it proves you know that I dont hate or place no value on the unborn, since of course no one hates property or doesnt recognize the value of property!

Well done sir!!!

My feelings towards this factual record of your statements are things like disgust and contempt, but the record is what it is, and it is fact that you are bigoted against the unborn.

And yet you were unable to provide any proof of bigotry when questioned appropriately. Oh well. We'll just have to go with you 'expressing your feelings'. And the disgust and contempt you display for women is apparent, not mine towards the unborn. I never use vitriolic, emotional language when referring to the unborn, as you do towards women.
 
And yet it was just proven at length, whereas your nebulous claim of disliking all women - just because I despise all men and all women who kill other human beings in aggression - remains just that... nebulous.

You mocking the notion of treating humans as property tells folks all they need to know.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

So I'm still seeking an answer here, to see if there is some legitimate connection between a pro-choice position and 'hating' the unborn.

Are you going to address this?

Would you deny that those who are pro-choice regard the unborn human as less human (and therefore less valuable) than the born?
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

Would you deny that those who are pro-choice regard the unborn human as less human (and therefore less valuable) than the born?

100% human. Having the attributes of people, human beings, that are more than just DNA? No.

I value born people more. That does not mean I do not value the unborn. However it does not generally benefit my arguments to bring that up...except when extremists then use that 'gap' to assume hate.

Edit: this is my opinion, I cant speak for all pro-choice people but I have never seen one that hates the unborn.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

Do you also need a list of situations throughout history where those who were bigoted against some humans also "valued" them as subhuman property?
 
And yet it was just proven at length, whereas your nebulous claim of disliking all women - just because I despise all men and all women who kill other human beings in aggression - remains just that... nebulous.

You mocking the notion of treating humans as property tells folks all they need to know.

What did you prove? I see you cannot even use my quotes for reference...talk about nebulous!

What did you prove?

And what exactly did my using your reference to humans as property "tell folks"? Please, be clear, not nebulous. I have been very specific in my posts.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

100% human. Having the attributes of people, human beings, that are more than just DNA? No.

I value born people more. That does not mean I do not value the unborn. However it does not generally benefit my arguments to bring that up...except when extremists then use that 'gap' to assume hate.

Edit: this is my opinion, I cant speak for all pro-choice people but I have never seen one that hates the unborn.

I've said nothing about anybody hating the unborn. I specified less human and therefore less valuable. The argument has been made in this forum that either one or the other--the mother or the unborn--must be less; that they cannot be equal.

I disagree. The greater either/or is that either all human life is valuable or it's not. I don't think there should be a sliding scale of "worth."
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

I've said nothing about anybody hating the unborn. I specified less human and therefore less valuable. The argument has been made in this forum that either one or the other--the mother or the unborn--must be less; that they cannot be equal.

I disagree. The greater either/or is that either all human life is valuable or it's not. I don't think there should be a sliding scale of "worth."

I never said there was a sliding scale. And I answered your question completely. Ignore the other part if you choose, that's fine.

Now, what is the point of a belief (in value in this case) if it cannot be carried out practically in society...legally or otherwise?

Please tell me how the born and unborn can be treated equally? If you cannot answer this question, then why would you hold onto the belief or opinion that both are equal if it's not in fact possible? (Of course you can hold that belief AND live it...but it's dishonest to want to see it forced on people that do not believe it, esp. if it is impossible for society.)
 
Last edited:
"How can the unborn and born be treated equally?"

Well let's see here. If a born human being is killed in aggression that act is against the law and its perpetrator goes to prison.

If an unborn human being is killed by his or her own mother prior to birth, no legal consequences whatsoever.


This isn't equal. There are two obvious ways to make it equal.

No legal consequences for anyone ever for anything, aka anarchy.
Ensure the same legal consequences for the same harmful action regardless of the age of the victim.

I prefer the latter, personally.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

I never said there was a sliding scale. And I answered your question completely. Ignore the other part if you choose, that's fine.

Now, what is the point of a belief (in value in this case) if it cannot be carried out practically in society...legally or otherwise?

Please tell me how the born and unborn can be treated equally? If you cannot answer this question, then why would you hold onto the belief or opinion that both are equal if it's not in fact possible? (Of course you can hold that belief AND live it...but it's dishonest to want to see it forced on people that do not believe it, esp. if it is impossible for society.)

How can the born and unborn be treated equally? Allow them both to keep living; that's how.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

How can the born and unborn be treated equally? Allow them both to keep living; that's how.

Sure. And how do you do that without infringing on a woman's rights to life, liberty (The positive enjoyment of social, political, or economic rights and privileges), the pursuit of happiness, plus many of her civil rights as well?

Again, I asked 'how' it could be done, not what you would like.
 
Last edited:
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

How can the born and unborn be treated equally? Allow them both to keep living; that's how.

Apparently what she really means when she asks this question is "how can you ban abortion without violating the right to abortion?"

Which is, of course, nonsensical.

It also goes without saying that those who wish to ban abortion, like ourselves, do not recognize such a "right," as it violates actual human rights.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

Would you deny that those who are pro-choice regard the unborn human as less human (and therefore less valuable) than the born?

I have never, EVER said that the unborn is "less human". BTW, why do I never see you take issue with anti choicers who call pro choicers and/or women who abort "subhuman"?
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

Apparently what she really means when she asks this question is "how can you ban abortion without violating the right to abortion?"

Which is, of course, nonsensical.

It also goes without saying that those who wish to ban abortion, like ourselves, do not recognize such a "right," as it violates actual human rights.


Of course there is no right for or against abortion in the Const. And as such, when examined, the courts determined it is legal.

The violation of inalienable and civil rights for women is unquestionable if abortion were made illegal however.

And there is no violation of human rights for the unborn. They have no rights.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

I have never, EVER said that the unborn is "less human". BTW, why do I never see you take issue with anti choicers who call pro choicers and/or women who abort "subhuman"?

In both sentences, you are lying.

At best, you are hinging on a frivolous and irrelevant technicality. By stating over and over again that they are not "human beings" - which you have done, dozens of times - you are absolutely saying they are less human than those humans you deign to recognize as human beings.

You lie again by labeling us "anti-choicers."

You lie again by suggesting anyone on this site has called pro-aborts "subhuman" merely for their political belief.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

From your article...fresh or frozen.
If it is frozen it needs to frozen right away and kept at a constant temperature.

There is no way that planned Parenthood is making a profit in the tissue donation program if they are only getting the $30 to $100 fees mentioned in the first undercover video

From Fact Check
Unspinning the Planned Parenthood Video

Tell ya what, Minnie, provide a link that details the steps Planned Parenthood takes and what steps the on-site procurement service personnel take after an abortion is performed and the fetus is ready for dissection.
Your link above wasn't it.
I might have missed it but they didn't even mention that the tissue traffickers were actually on site, did they?
Do you understand the point I'm making?
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

From your article...fresh or frozen.
If it is frozen it needs to frozen right away and kept at a constant temperature.

There is no way that planned Parenthood is making a profit in the tissue donation program if they are only getting the $30 to $100 fees mentioned in the first undercover video

From Fact Check



Unspinning the Planned Parenthood Video

Tell ya what, Minnie, provide a link that details the steps Planned Parenthood takes and what steps the on-site procurement service personnel take after an abortion is performed and the fetus is ready for dissection.
Your link above wasn't it.
I might have missed it but they didn't even mention that the tissue traffickers were actually on site, did they?
Do you understand the point I'm making?

Here, Minnie.
This is from someone you're told not to believe but you have to wake up sooner or later.
Pleas read it all.

After the abortion is performed, what happens next?

Once the abortion is complete, the jar or the tube where everything was suctioned would go into the products of conception lab. The product of conception technician, who works for Planned Parenthood, would empty everything that was suctioned out into a dish like what we saw in the fourth and fifth video.

At that point, what did the product of conception technician do with the different body parts?

If it was during a time that we were participating in a research study, they would pick out whatever was requested—whether it was a specific organ, eyeballs, whatever it was—they would take that out and put that in a specimen bag.

Then we would put all of the bags that were going for research in a Styrofoam container inside a freezer, and the ones that were not went into a different bag. With each specimen we had to make a copy of the consent form they signed and put it into the specimen bag.

At the end of the day, we would ship on dry ice the specimens to the company that we were contracted with. Sometimes research labs will actually come and pick up the box, but in our case we shipped it off.

How much did shipping typically cost?

The researchers provided the Styrofoam box and dry ice to Planned Parenthood. Literally the only cost we had was shipping the box. And that was about $20 every time we shipped. So Planned Parenthood is getting $200 per specimen, and we’re taking all the specimens, putting them in one box and shipping it off for $20. The different fetal body parts are not shipped individually.

Does Planned Parenthood have to hire an employee to sort through the body parts and put them in these containers?

It’s not like we hire someone just to separate these parts for research because after every single abortion, a product of conception technician reassembles the parts of the baby to make sure that everything was removed. If they don’t, that can be fatal for a woman. We had several instances where our product of conception technician failed the patient because they would come back in and there would be a leg still in their uterus and that causes very serious infection.

To send the body parts to a research laboratory, it’s just a matter of separating them into different bags.

Do you think Planned Parenthood is doing anything illegal?

The way that the law is written currently, it allows them to charge for these certain items as long as they are coded correctly on a line-item budget. And that’s the problem with the law, is that it’s so subjective as far as the cost. As long as they code it as, we need $100 for extra work in collecting the tissue—well, there is no extra work. And that’s what the videos are showing, with Dr. Mary Gatter, she said, “We don’t have to change anything.” That’s true: they don’t have to do anything.

Former Planned Parenthood Worker Explains Tissue Donation

And that was when the tissue trafficker wasn't on site to do work on the parts.
 
Re: Can someone tell me as a society how we have become so callous?

Can we clarify the "nonsense" you are referring to here? Can you or can you not support these statements with facts? I think it's especially important to clarify what the slurs are, since most pro-choice people posting here arent trying to cast slurs...that sort of thing just muddies arguments, it doesnt move them forward.

What a nonsensical statement on your part!

It is not my feeling that you use slurs to refer to the unborn.
Please tell me what slurs I have used against the unborn. A list will be fine.
It is not my feeling that you have denied their humanity and want to continue to deny them personhood.
Lursa said:
Please show where I have ever claimed the unborn are not human.
 
Back
Top Bottom