• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Beloved leftist icon Mahmoud Khalil says massacre of 1,300 Israeli civilians was unavoidable

T25

Suspended
Joined
Apr 16, 2025
Messages
374
Reaction score
118
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
I'm sure most leftists here wholeheartedly agree with him.

 
I'm sure most leftists here wholeheartedly agree with him.

You are confusing saying something was unavoidable, with approval of the thing.

If you drink a 5th of whisky and then drive a hundred miles an hour down a country road a bad accident is likely unavoidable.

That doesnt mean i approve of such behavior.

As a question of logic do you understand the distinction?
 
Cause he's right.

Oct 7 was the culminating, inevitable result of what happens when you murder, oppress, occupy, blockade, and keep 2.3 million people caged in an open air prison.

Want to know what happens when Palestinians resist "the right way?" When they petition peacefully for their rights, they are ignored by the international community or sniped by the Israeli occupiers. When they resist violently, Israel simply obliterates them with its vast edge in firepower.

And let's not forget that Israel has been routinely mass murdering unarmed Palestinians before Oct 7.

So the moral of the story is, you don't get to ****ing colonize, occupy, steal land, oppress, deny people basic human rights, and then pretend to be the ****ing victim when you suffer the inevitable consequences of your genocidal actions.

The deaths of those on Oct 7 and every Palestinian since then should be laid at the feet of Zionism, because it is impossible for free people to coexist with such an evil and oppressive ideology which distilled to its essence is little more than white supremacy with extra steps. The root cause of Palestinian violence, is Israeli oppression. If your conversation around the issue doesn't involve discussing this as a root cause then you have no intellectual honesty.

This is before I even start discussing the fact that the Israeli intelligence apparatus deliberately funded Hamas to split Palestinian unity from Fatah and then Israelis started ****ing crying about the exact consequences of all the underhanded, nefarious ****ery of their intelligence agencies.

So to recap - unless your discussion of this issue revolves around Palestinian liberation from Israeli oppression and colonization, you aren't interested in an actual end to the conflict. You're just interested in victim blaming.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. Great post.....
 
I'd also add that there isn't a single accusation that Zionists can level at Hamas that the Israelis themselves aren't guilty of a hundred times over.

Mass rape on Oct 7? Unsubstantiated by any serious reporting but Israel has open debates in the Knesset about whether Palestinians in Israeli custody have any human rights at the hands of their rapist captors.


Using civilians as human shields? The IDF literally straps Palestinians to the front of their trucks.


"Hamas hides in tunnels" yes that's exactly what you're supposed to do when the enemy has air supremacy, didn't we see Israeli leadership go underground when the Iranians counterattacked and their ballistic missiles penetrated the iron dome?

"Hamas steals the aid!" Once again, zero evidence of this, but what we DO know is Israel literally pays proxy gangs in Gaza to steal the aid then accuse Hamas of doing it.


There's dozens such examples. Zionism is a fascist, white supremacist ideology and as fascists do routinely, they project everything they are guilty of onto their opposition. And like fascists, they are inveterate liars.
 

Yet we know that Israeli guards have raped and tortured Palestinian prisoners. The abuse was so horrific that the US was alarmed...

 
There's dozens such examples. Zionism is a fascist, white supremacist ideology and as fascists do routinely, they project everything they are guilty of onto their opposition. And like fascists, they are inveterate liars.

Yeah and this is the problem with the third worldist left wing slop posters - they fundamentally misunderstand and improperly frame the conflict as being a tale of European colonialism instead of being about the fundamentally problematic elements of Messianic Judaism and its retarded bastard offspring Evangelical dispensationalism.

Pieces of shit like Smotrich and Ben-Gvir will ramble all day about esoteric Jewish mysticism being the casus belli for ethnically cleansing 2 million people and folks like you will still frame this as being an issue of European colonialism even though it's the Europeans who are the only ones doing anything diplomatically speaking to put an end to this mess.
 
Well said.
 

You guys keep forgetting who did what first.

Rightly or wrongly Western Europe, who didn't want the Jews escaping Germany, Poland, Hungry. etc., who didn't want to live in what had just been a fascist government and who didn't want to return to what was now a Communist satellite nation immigrating to France, England, etc. So they recreated Israel for them.

They got off the boats to what was their new homeland to meet a whole bunch of recently dispossessed Arabs who were intent on driving them into the sea. Except that didn't quite work out for them. It didn't change their minds though. To this day its drive the Jews into the sea or nothing.

Given that state of mind, what do you expect from the Jews who don't quite want to be driven into the sea?

Before you climb all over Israel for their being to harsh with their "Palestinien" neighbors have those gents drop their desire to see Israel eradicated.

If they drop the "From the river to the sea" shite, I bet we could even get Netanyahu to chill with the, 'If it's them or us its going to be them", shite.
 
There's dozens such examples. Zionism is a fascist, white supremacist ideology and as fascists do routinely, they project everything they are guilty of onto their opposition. And like fascists, they are inveterate liars.

Fascism is anti-democratic. Israel today is a liberal democracy with regular elections and multiple parties, including arab parties.
 
I'm sure most leftists here wholeheartedly agree with him.

Well, Israel could have avoided it by not blatantly violating international law, trying to steal Palestinian land, and murdering Palestinian civilians, but they’ve shown themselves utterly unwilling to do so.

So…. Yeah. By that standard it very much was unavoidable.
 
Gee, if we’re using Israel’s standards the Arab states would have been entirely justified in doing so

After all, Israel was formed via terrorism, carried out numerous attacks on Palestinian civilians at peaceful villages such as Deir Yassin, and outright murdered the UN mediator Count Bernadotte.

Israeli immigration had little to do with “communism”— Israel had a fairly strong left wing for roughly the first decade of its existence— and more to do with people simply no longer feeling like they could live in Europe at all.

Israel’s constant attacks on Palestinian civilians in the West Bank pretty clearly show otherwise.
 
Go read the history of the Israel/Palestinian conflict since 1948. The violence has been initiated by the Palestinians.
 
Go read the history of the Israel/Palestinian conflict since 1948. The violence has been initiated by the Palestinians.
False.

The Nakba (Arabic: النَّكْبَة, romanized: an-Nakba, lit. 'the catastrophe') is the ethnic cleansing of Palestinian Arabs through their violent displacement and dispossession of land, property, and belongings, along with the destruction of their society and the suppression of their culture, identity, political rights, and national aspirations.The term is used to describe the events of the 1948 Palestine war in Mandatory Palestine as well as the ongoing persecution and displacement of Palestinians by Israel.
As a whole, it covers the fracturing of Palestinian society and the long-running rejection of the right of return for Palestinian refugees and their descendants.
 
Cause he's right.

Oct 7 was the culminating, inevitable result of what happens when you murder, oppress, occupy, blockade, and keep 2.3 million people caged in an open air prison.
Israel pulled out of Gaza 2 decades ago. All it did was make the Gazans more violent, not less violent. Gazans don't want peace. They want to murder and loot their neighbor.
 

and then almost immediately.....

Cause he's right.

@StillBallin75, I find your position on this topic absolutely atrocious and horrifically immoral, but, I do appreciate that you are unabashed in it.


Reminds me of back when the moderate leftist folks were trying to explain that "Defund The Police" actually meant "Better Funding For Social Programs", and the protest leaders would break in with "NO WE MEAN DE-FUND THE POLICE"
 
Go read the history of the Israel/Palestinian conflict since 1948. The violence has been initiated by the Palestinians.
Um, no. It's been a mixed bag, especially in the formation of Israel. Lest we forget Lehi, Irgun et.al.
 
Israel pulled out of Gaza 2 decades ago. All it did was make the Gazans more violent, not less violent. Gazans don't want peace. They want to murder and loot their neighbor.
They think that Israel not put trade constraints on Gaza (like we do with Russia, Iran, North Korea, etc.) means Gaza was actually a Prison.
 

"We attacked them and lost, therefore we are the victims."

 
Israel pulled out of Gaza 2 decades ago. All it did was make the Gazans more violent, not less violent. Gazans don't want peace. They want to murder and loot their neighbor.
Israel’s endless attacks on Palestinian civilians show that to be completely and utterly false.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…