- Joined
- Aug 27, 2005
- Messages
- 43,602
- Reaction score
- 26,257
- Location
- Houston, TX
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Conservative
danarhea said:Nothing like a few cut and paste jobs to put into your manuscript, except that she is using someone else's ideas and sentences as her own.
Article is here.
In other news, Advertising Age Magazine has asked Ann to kill herself. Good idea. I'll even chip in a few bucks to help out such a good cause.
Article is here.
danarhea said:Nothing like a few cut and paste jobs to put into your manuscript, except that she is using someone else's ideas and sentences as her own.
Article is here.
In other news, Advertising Age Magazine has asked Ann to kill herself. Good idea. I'll even chip in a few bucks to help out such a good cause.
Article is here.
Stinger said:That's not a cut and paste, it's two people speaking of the same factual event. Should she change the facts.
Geez argue substance not style.
As to th second, so much for free speech I guess.
SouthernDemocrat said:She should have put the statement in quotes, and then cited the source in a footnote. However, it's really as much of a mistake on the part of her editors (who really have their work cut out for them with her) than it is on her part.
http://rawstory.com/news/2005/coulter_caught_cribbing_column_720.htmMuch of Coulter's Jun. 29, 2005 column, “Thou Shall Not Commit Religion,” bears a striking resemblance to pieces in magazines dating as far back as 1985—and a column written for the Boston Globe in 1995.
/snip
The piece was first questioned by The Rude Pundit on Jul. 1. His post noted that Coulter appeared to have cribbed from a defunct 1993 magazine called The Flummery Digest.
Coulter : "A photo of a newborn infant with its mouth open titled to suggest the infant was available for oral sex."
The Flummery Digest: "The title of a photo of a newborn infant with its mouth open suggested that the infant was available for oral sex."
Coulter: "A photo of a woman breastfeeding an infant, titled ' Jesus Sucks.'"
The Flummery Digest: "… photograph of a woman breastfeeding an infant was titled 'Jesus Sucks.'"
Coulter: "A show titled 'DEGENERATE WITH A CAPITAL D' featuring a display of the remains of the artist's own aborted baby."
The Flummery Digest: "'Degenerate with a Capital D'...included 'Alchemy Cabinet' by Shawn Eichman, featuring the remains of the artist's own aborted baby."
Coulter: "Performance of giant bloody tampons, satanic bunnies, three-foot feces and vibrators."
The Flummery Digest: "[T]he performance art of Johanna Went...relies upon props such as giant body tampons, satanic bunnies, three-foot turds, and dildos."
The she appears to lift directly from one written by Boston Globe columnist Jeff Jacoby in 1995 for the same column.
Coulter: "...inserting a speculum into her vagina and inviting audience members on stage to view her cervix with a flashlight."
Jacoby: "...inserted a speculum into her vagina and called up audience members to examine her cervix with a flashlight..."
Coulter: "Christ submerged in a jar of urine."
Jacoby: "...photographs of a crucifix submerged in his urine..."
The 1992 MIT-based magazine Counterpoint included similar items.
Coulter: "A photo of a newborn infant with its mouth open titled to suggest the infant was available for oral sex."
Counterpoint: 3. (1984) "The title of a photo of a newborn infant suggested the infant was available for oral sex."
Coulter: "A show titled 'DEGENERATE WITH A CAPITAL D' featuring a display of the remains of the artist's own aborted baby."
/snip
George_Washington said:Asking someone to kill themselves is a cruel thing to do and is quite typical of people on the far left. They often resort to such viscious attacks.
It's really amazing how the mainstream media is picking apart Ann's comments and how they frequently ignore things said from people on the left.
SouthernDemocrat said:There is a big difference though. Both sides have their share of nut jobs. Nut jobs on the far left are for the most part ignored by mainstream liberals and progressives. Nut jobs on the far right though are completely embraced by many Republicans.
SouthernDemocrat said:Nut jobs on the far left are for the most part ignored by mainstream liberals and progressives. Nut jobs on the far right though are completely embraced by many Republicans.
taxedout said:Yeah, whatever.
SouthernDemocrat said:Al Franken and Micheal Moore write books that blast conservative political leaders and many conservative policies. However, they don't call conservatism itself evil, and they both in their books recognize that many conservatives are good people who just have a different viewpoint
.
taxedout said:We're not arguing whether franken or moore or coulter are nut jobs. You asserted that both sides have their fair share of nut jobs. Further you asserted that these nut jobs were ignored by mainstream liberals while republicans were unable to do the same. That is a rediculous assertion and puts your speech in no higher regard than what you accuse her of.
I guess when you do it, you are just asserting truth, but when she does it, she is spewing hate. Is that the new rules of fairness, liberals can insult a whole group's collective intellect, while others cannot ? Spare me with your christian conscience BS.
galenrox said:Alright, I watched the Al Franken election day show on Sundance, so don't try to pretend like Al Franken is all respectful of the opposition, considering that he refered to the red states as "the dumb states".
SouthernDemocrat said:The same is true for the writings of Ann Coulter. If someone wants to sit here and defend her calling Liberals Godless, thats fine, but its shamefull to do so.
SixStringHero said:Randi Rhodes sure has no problem with it.
It goes both ways.
SouthernDemocrat said:I don't think he is respectful of the opposition at all. As to calling the red states the dumb states, that was sarcasm. However, he has never referred to conservatism as an evil ideology. He has never called conservatives evil. He has never called them godless. That is the difference. He has many conservative friends and does not hate people simply because they are conservative. Ann Coulter quite literally hates liberals simply because they are liberal.
taxedout said:I'm not defending her.
I'm calling you out for your rediculous assertion that liberals can ignore the far left nut jobs while the republicans are unable to do the same for the right wing nut jobs. You're not suffering from a little superiority complex are you? This wholesale categorization of a groups collective intellect is exactly the type of behavior you have just been criticizing Coulter for. You are just like her. POT MEET KETTLE
taxedout said:Oh I get it, Coulter's writing is not sarcasm or satire.
SouthernDemocrat said:Name a liberal writer who routinely calls Conservatives evil simply because they are conservative and who calls Conservatism an evil ideology that actually sells books.
.
George_Washington said:Asking someone to kill themselves is a cruel thing to do and is quite typical of people on the far left. They often resort to such viscious attacks.
It's really amazing how the mainstream media is picking apart Ann's comments and how they frequently ignore things said from people on the left.
George_Washington said:Asking someone to kill themselves is a cruel thing to do and is quite typical of people on the far left. They often resort to such viscious attacks.
It's really amazing how the mainstream media is picking apart Ann's comments and how they frequently ignore things said from people on the left.
taxedout said:you are a liberal. You are a writer, of many posts anyway. You just categorized a whole group of people as being of insufficient intelligence to see through far right "nut jobs". You too engage in animated inflamatory speech. Congratulations, you too are now a hatemongerer.
Do you have any other "my **** doesn't stink" arguements ?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?