• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Americans calling for the Genocide of Americans

Do you tolerate Americans calling for the genocide of Americans

  • Americans should tolerate politicians calling for genocide of Americans—but no real genocide

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I am unable to tell if calls for genocide are tolerable

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    15
There are apparently 53 million people in the U.S. who are not native born citizens, plus millions more (I don't have an exact figure, but millions) who hold dual citizenship. It is conceivable her "65 million" referred to all of them, rather than the Latinos. I'm not saying I like that either, but when somebody slips and lets their real plans loose, please read carefully before drawing conclusions.
 
There are apparently 53 million people in the U.S. who are not native born citizens, plus millions more (I don't have an exact figure, but millions) who hold dual citizenship. It is conceivable her "65 million" referred to all of them, rather than the Latinos. I'm not saying I like that either, but when somebody slips and lets their real plans loose, please read carefully before drawing conclusions.

No, it isn't conceivable that she was talking about feeing Melania Trump to alligators. She was referring to the 65 million Latinos in the US.
 
How normal should promoting American genocide be in American politics?
Is this something you want to be an everyday thing?
Or is this something which is intolerable?

A gotcha thread, one of 2,130,928,905,239,821,984,719,248,716,398,546,726,438,953,460,594,385,609,458,704,985,679,458,769,348,523,894,768,237,412,873,465,172,346,188,472,046,953 others.

YAWN.
 
.
the number of people who are treating this as a gotcha question
is darkly hilarious but deeply disheartening​

What is truly "disheartening" is your OP assumption that everyone knows what you are talking about.

This is not just you BTW, there are a number of members who post threads simply assuming that absent specific details people just automatically know what the subject is all about.

As of this point I still don't know what your OP refers to for certain, despite suggestions from other Forum members.

But let's assume for discussion it is Ms. Loomer's comment?


Well, a couple of points:

1. Ms. Loomer is a "right wing influencer," and not a member of the Trump Administration. I don't follow her and know very little about her.

2. She is one person making a personal statement which has nothing to do with the Trump Administration's actions.

3. She has a right to "free speech" however foolish, and she then has to face the various forms of free expression in response.
 
Last edited:
.



the number of people who are treating this as a gotcha question​
is darkly hilarious but deeply disheartening​



.

It should be the easiest No vote ever, but some people just can't stand the idea of not being able to support genocide.

That speaks volumes about their moral character.
 
What is truly "disheartening" is your OP assumption that everyone knows what you are talking about.

This is not just you BTW, there are a number of members who post threads simply assuming that absent specific details people just automatically know what the subject is all about.

As of this point I still don't know what your OP refers to for certain, despite suggestions from other Forum members.

But let's assume for discussion it is Ms. Loomer's comment?


Well, a couple of points:

1. Ms. Loomer is a "right wing influencer," and not a member of the Trump Administration. I don't follow her and know very little about her.

2. She is one person making a personal statement which has nothing to do with the Trump Administration's actions.

3. She has a right to "free speech" however foolish, and she then has to face the various forms of free expression in response.
I agree with most of this but would add that Ms Loomer feeds off of the Trump admin.
 
What is truly "disheartening" is your OP assumption that everyone knows what you are talking about.

I was asked Americans, politicians, and genocide.

Seems like these are well-known topics.

🤷


But let's assume for discussion it is Ms. Loomer's comment?

Why?

Feel free to debate whether or not Loomer's comments qualify as advocating genocide.

But that not my question.

Well, a couple of points:
1. Ms. Loomer is a "right wing influencer," and not a member of the Trump Administration. I don't follow her and know very little about her.
2. She is one person making a personal statement which has nothing to do with the Trump Administration's actions.
3. She has a right to "free speech" however foolish, and she then has to face the various forms of free expression in response.
okay, but...
That's all immaterial to my question


The questions remain

How normal should promoting American genocide be in American politics?
Is this something you want to be an everyday thing?
Or is this something which is intolerable?


These are simple straight forward questions

WHEN DID ADVOCATING GENOCIDE BECOME A GRAY AREA?
 
I agree with most of this but would add that Ms Loomer feeds off of the Trump admin.

afaIct,
whether or not Loomer's comments qualify as advocating genocide is a separate question.


Do you feel that it is acceptable for politicians to advocate for the genocide of Americans?

Or should those politicans be driven from public life?
 
Back
Top Bottom