- Joined
- Apr 22, 2019
- Messages
- 59,656
- Reaction score
- 30,462
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Progressive
There's no sitting down with the dictator of North Korea, the leader of Saudi Arabia, the dictators of Philippines, Turkey, or other countries, and finding much common ground for, say, moving toward justice and western democracy.
All that CAN be done is a sort of corruption based on the corruption of where they are - some deals on some issues that are in their interest, whether based on threats of military force, bribes, etc.
And there are people around us like that. Imagine if one of your neighbors is a member of a street gang that regularly commits crimes. There's not a lot of chance of your talking to them and getting big changes - more just basic agreements, possibly, on minor issues.
We'd like to think Republicans, like Democrats, are fellow Americans who just have some different opinions, where there is mutual respect, mutual goals of things good for the country, room for debate, etc. The thins we see that's basically a lie.
For whatever reason, the Republican part of the country is basically radicalized. We've said it's like a cult, but that's literally the case. There is programming just like with any cult. And it's left them in a condition that is alien to the idea of our democracy pretty much.
About the only thing left in common it seems is some respect for election outcomes, IF Democrats can win by overcoming all the cheating Republicans do, and even that seems less and less accepted by them, with many supporting things like 'trump president for life'.
We need to accept this. To stop expecting that pointing out lie #14,322 by trump will get them to oppose him, that pointing out the harm of policy #521 will get them to see the harm, and just understand how they are in another world, unreachable.
We can recognize why to a point, the 24/7 media bubble they are kept in, distorting many things every day to fit a false narrative. A little like the views the North Koreans might have of the US, when they are fed a narrative constantly.
There's an old saying, usually wrong but right in this case, that 'the only thing they understand is force', referring to trying to say an adversary can't be reasoned with, only defeated. That describes Republicans also. The only 'win' that counts is not in talking, with all due respect to the purpose of this forum, not winning arguments, but in defeating them in elections (while we still have elections).
It reminds me a little of Nancy Pelosi's statement - which was, of course, lied about and distorted by them - about the ACA, when Republicans were lying about what it would do, so loudly that she recognized there was just no way to correct the lies, and she said, 'the only way many people will actually understand what's in the bill is after it's passed, and they see what it really does'.
There was no ability to talk to Republican American and informed them of the truth, and correct the lies they were being told. Of course, the liars distorted her statement to imply the bill had sinister things being hid from the public that they'd only find out about when it was passed, the opposite of what she was saying.
All we can do is hope enough Americans do not fall into the right-wing bubble, so that elections can be won, as the House was won in 2018 (and the Senate would have been, if not almost all the Republican seats were not in the election).
Luckily, so much of the Republican views are based on harming others, on favoring some at the expense of others, that there is a likely cap on their support.
It is still important that we speak out for the truth against the lies, but not so much for the benefit of the Republicans, who are blind, but for those who are less informed, who are vulnerable to being pulled into the bubble if they only hear the lies.
We need to recognize there is a problem: a threat to our theory of democracy, when millions of people can be so brainwashed, it defeats the premise of democracy - if you have the money, you can fool those millions almost no matter how outrageous the lie. We don't have any answer for it that's practical, unfortunately, but we should recognize the problem, instead of pretending just 'talking to them' will fix things.
And it reinforces what's most important practically, getting out the largest group of voters, those who don't vote. All that can likely be done now is to win elections.
All that CAN be done is a sort of corruption based on the corruption of where they are - some deals on some issues that are in their interest, whether based on threats of military force, bribes, etc.
And there are people around us like that. Imagine if one of your neighbors is a member of a street gang that regularly commits crimes. There's not a lot of chance of your talking to them and getting big changes - more just basic agreements, possibly, on minor issues.
We'd like to think Republicans, like Democrats, are fellow Americans who just have some different opinions, where there is mutual respect, mutual goals of things good for the country, room for debate, etc. The thins we see that's basically a lie.
For whatever reason, the Republican part of the country is basically radicalized. We've said it's like a cult, but that's literally the case. There is programming just like with any cult. And it's left them in a condition that is alien to the idea of our democracy pretty much.
About the only thing left in common it seems is some respect for election outcomes, IF Democrats can win by overcoming all the cheating Republicans do, and even that seems less and less accepted by them, with many supporting things like 'trump president for life'.
We need to accept this. To stop expecting that pointing out lie #14,322 by trump will get them to oppose him, that pointing out the harm of policy #521 will get them to see the harm, and just understand how they are in another world, unreachable.
We can recognize why to a point, the 24/7 media bubble they are kept in, distorting many things every day to fit a false narrative. A little like the views the North Koreans might have of the US, when they are fed a narrative constantly.
There's an old saying, usually wrong but right in this case, that 'the only thing they understand is force', referring to trying to say an adversary can't be reasoned with, only defeated. That describes Republicans also. The only 'win' that counts is not in talking, with all due respect to the purpose of this forum, not winning arguments, but in defeating them in elections (while we still have elections).
It reminds me a little of Nancy Pelosi's statement - which was, of course, lied about and distorted by them - about the ACA, when Republicans were lying about what it would do, so loudly that she recognized there was just no way to correct the lies, and she said, 'the only way many people will actually understand what's in the bill is after it's passed, and they see what it really does'.
There was no ability to talk to Republican American and informed them of the truth, and correct the lies they were being told. Of course, the liars distorted her statement to imply the bill had sinister things being hid from the public that they'd only find out about when it was passed, the opposite of what she was saying.
All we can do is hope enough Americans do not fall into the right-wing bubble, so that elections can be won, as the House was won in 2018 (and the Senate would have been, if not almost all the Republican seats were not in the election).
Luckily, so much of the Republican views are based on harming others, on favoring some at the expense of others, that there is a likely cap on their support.
It is still important that we speak out for the truth against the lies, but not so much for the benefit of the Republicans, who are blind, but for those who are less informed, who are vulnerable to being pulled into the bubble if they only hear the lies.
We need to recognize there is a problem: a threat to our theory of democracy, when millions of people can be so brainwashed, it defeats the premise of democracy - if you have the money, you can fool those millions almost no matter how outrageous the lie. We don't have any answer for it that's practical, unfortunately, but we should recognize the problem, instead of pretending just 'talking to them' will fix things.
And it reinforces what's most important practically, getting out the largest group of voters, those who don't vote. All that can likely be done now is to win elections.