• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

28 year old Dutch woman to be euthanized because depression, autism, and borderline personality disorder

Chock Full o Nuts

Dungeon Master
DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 28, 2023
Messages
8,575
Reaction score
9,950
Location
Cincinnati, Ohio
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian - Right

‘I’m 28. And I’m Scheduled to Die in May.’

Some right-to-die activists want everyone to have access to euthanasia—even young people with mental illness. Are they also making suicide contagious?
www.thefp.com

So much for being reserved for the 'terminally ill'.
Has a bit of Soylent Green ring to it.
I'm not dying, but I want to, because I just cant take it anymore!
No problem, we got you...
 

Calgary judge rules woman with autism can seek Medical Assistance In Dying

“What I know of your journey through the health-care system from the evidence in this case suggests that you have struggled to find a doctor who could diagnose your condition and offer appropriate treatment,” he said. “I do not know why you seek MAID. Your reasons remain your own because I have...
debatepolitics.com
 

I prefer this to her parents having to clean up blood from their bathroom after they find her body.
 
So it's not just the Dutch that will put you down, Canadians too!

Let's just start putting people down because the McRib is gone and they can't take it. Don't worry, it will be back. Nasty anyway..
 
The deepest sympathies to her family and friends.

She deserves the right to decide that she wants to leave this VALE OF TEARS.

The mental/physical suffering of some human beings is horrific beyond words.

All American states should allow people to end their lives in a dignified manner.
 
I'd say we should be careful with this. Some people on the spectrum can get hyper obsessed with things later to move on to a new thing. They could get hyper fixated on their own deaths, and I don't see how we shouldn't just treat the issue, instead of letting them go on with it, there's no return.

But, then again, I only stayed at a Holiday Inn psychology unit last night. I have no real idea.

I am very familiar with those of us on the spectrum tho, and I could see the possible problems with this. I personally don't like it.

I could also see people start encouraging death as an option if say, you couldn't afford treatment, or were a burden. That's not a good fix, IMO.
 
I remember a story not long ago about a daughter who wanted to kill herself, but couldn't because she loved her parents too much, but she was in enormous pain every day. Her parents decided to kill themselves with her so she could find peace.

With the stigma today against the mentally ill, there often is no other treatments--or the treatments are far more traumatizing.

For the mentally ill, it's a tough haul just to wake up every day, let alone navigate retaining dignity while seeking treatment and attempting to be accepted by the society you exist in. It can be worse than death.
 
Suicide should not be stigmatized as a shameful, cowardly, or heroic act.
No one should be forced to live.
 
I just hope there's no pressure because they have mental issues.
 
Your headline carries the strong implication that the woman is being forced by the state to have her life terminated.

That is incorrect as anyone who had actually read the article would know.

Did you actually read the article and write the inaccurate headline on purpose or did you simply not actually understand what was in the article?
 
And, of course, you are implying that "autism" and "subnormal intelligence" mean the same thing - right?
 
Allan said:
A number of countries including Canada allow this even for conditions that aren't terminal.

Not sure why this is news.
Click to expand...
It isn't news - BUT it does give the OP a chance to post material where they IMPLY that "the state" is "forcing" the person to have their life ended.
 
Opossum said:
How about treating people instead?
Click to expand...
When psychiatry has a statistically significant better chance of "curing" mental illness than an illiterate tribal healer in a tribe that is cut off from civilization does, you may well have a point.

"Doctor, I want to thank you for helping me realize that it doesn't make sense for me to believe that people are out to _[fill in the blank]_ if I don't know why people are out to _[fill in the blank]_. That, however, doesn't change the fact that people ARE out to _[fill in the blank]_ and I'm going out of my mind trying to figure out WHY people are out to _[fill in the blank]_." is (in paraphrase) a not unlikely "psychiatric treatment outcome".
 
TU Curmudgeon said:
It isn't news - BUT it does give the OP a chance to post material where they IMPLY that "the state" is "forcing" the person to have their life ended.
Click to expand...
I didn't take it that way at all. I guess if you're looking to bitch about something, you'll find it.
 
Allan said:
A number of countries including Canada allow this even for conditions that aren't terminal.

Not sure why this is news.
Click to expand...
Not for nothing, but it was only news when someone else posted about it?
 
TU Curmudgeon said:
Your headline carries the strong implication that the woman is being forced by the state to have her life terminated.
Click to expand...
You know damn well that's not what I meant, but you go with that.
Though euthanasia is 'ending the life of someone through peaceful means at the hands of another', so, technically factual.
TU Curmudgeon said:
That is incorrect as anyone who had actually read the article would know.

Did you actually read the article and write the inaccurate headline on purpose or did you simply not actually understand what was in the article?
Click to expand...
Read every word, I did! She will be euthanized.

Just how much 'help' has she received at 28 before resorting to this? How long has this gone on? Went from wanting to be a psychiatrist herself, to wanting to die.

..but she was never able to muster the will to finish school or start a career.
Click to expand...
Couldn't have been  too long if presently only 28.
Seems like they would try more mental health help before resorting to just ending it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…