• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Working moms look to Michelle Obama for change

Harry Guerrilla

DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 18, 2008
Messages
28,951
Reaction score
12,422
Location
Not affiliated with other libertarians.
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian
Working moms look to Michelle Obama for change | U.S. | Reuters






These people want companies to pay them for chosing to have a baby and want the government to pay for their childcare.

Personal responsibility, out the window.
 
Yeah what's wrong with them, how could they possibly give into their biological instincts at a time like this!

Well, I mean it is a choice after all. Why not plan ahead and pay your own way. No, that is way to much to ask.

Make your employer and the government do the planning for you. That makes much more sense.
 
Working moms look to Michelle Obama for change | U.S. | Reuters

These people want companies to pay them for chosing to have a baby and want the government to pay for their childcare.

Personal responsibility, out the window.

I think paid maternity leave should be mandated for employees who've worked for companies for a certain period of time under the condition that on their return they are not eligible for any pay raise the company might have had DURING the time they left. It's reasonable. And makes everybody happy.
 

That is an excellent idea. I would not mandate it but would support that more than just a blanket "you must pay them."

I think people are sometimes under the impression that having a baby is an involuntary medical condition like a heart attack.
 
That is an excellent idea. I would not mandate it but would support that more than just a blanket "you must pay them."

I think people are sometimes under the impression that having a baby is an involuntary medical condition like a heart attack.

Well it's been my experience that very few companies/employers offer paid maternity/paternity leave without any kind of condition. However I do think that IF companies are going to be obligated to offer maternity/paternity leave that they get something in return when the employees come back to rejoin the work force.
 

I could seriously support that.
Work mans compensation only pays 2/3rds of your regular pay if I'm not mistaken.

Why would an employer be forced to pay full compensation for a voluntary medical condition.
 
Europeans, on average, have a great maternity leave program.

I still think we have to adopt some of those. You're fighting with human nature whenever you force someone to chose baby or no baby, or work or no work.
 
Europeans, on average, have a great maternity leave program.

I still think we have to adopt some of those. You're fighting with human nature whenever you force someone to chose baby or no baby, or work or no work.

How is that? I'm asking for people to think about what happens when you have children, before they have the children.

If you want to have children save enough money for those weeks you will be absent and the problem is solved.
 
How is that? I'm asking for people to think about what happens when you have children, before they have the children.

If you want to have children save enough money for those weeks you will be absent and the problem is solved.

Human nature is not this whole fictional concept of time, working for money, or planning.
The body is not rational. It is based on instincts and the more you refuse the instincts the more, in most cases, it will push toward it.
 
Human nature is not this whole fictional concept of time, working for money, or planning.
The body is not rational. It is based on instincts and the more you refuse the instincts the more, in most cases, it will push toward it.

I certainly realize this.
I know to that the other side of that in human instinct is that when someone else sees a person living off of their dime, they tend to get pissed.
Should that person follow their instinct and take it back by force?

So do you suggest we try to embrace all instincts whether or not they be inferior?

If companies are forced to pay for maternity leave they will simply hire less women.
Staffing companies are going to be popular in the near future i foresee.
 
While the US doesn't have mandatory paid maternity leave, we do have FMLA. Further, a majority of women are offered paid maternity leave by their employers.

I'm inclined to say it should be more, but I think using the European model as an example is a pretty horrible idea.


That's just insane.
 

That is what I'm afraid of.

Something like that and the extension of the statute of limitations on pay discrimination that was signed into law, could make women less desirable employees.
 
Holy crap. It's welfare, only they're calling it something else. Wonderful.
 
Well, I mean it is a choice after all. Why not plan ahead and pay your own way. No, that is way to much to ask.

Make your employer and the government do the planning for you. That makes much more sense.
Arch Enemy is probably unemployed or has never paid any taxes. He seems to wallow in govt benefits to everyone regardless of the insanity of it. People like this have no idea what America is about and why people want to come here.
 
Arch Enemy is probably unemployed or has never paid any taxes. He seems to wallow in govt benefits to everyone regardless of the insanity of it. People like this have no idea what America is about and why people want to come here.

I'm not going to speculate about Arch's employment history but I do understand why he feels the way he does.

It comes from his heart, which I can sympathize with that even though I disagree.

At times I know I come off as a real ass about being upset about programs like this.
I'm trying spread the message, that its time for us to evolve past people who don't want to take care of themselves.

With every choice in life comes the consequences and responsibilities.
If you want to have children you must also bear the burden of completely providing for them and yourself.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…