- Joined
- Oct 12, 2005
- Messages
- 281,619
- Reaction score
- 100,389
- Location
- Ohio
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Libertarian - Right
How do you prove that gun does not cross state lines once you sell it?
So if 90% of the people wanted Christianity and only Christianity to be taught in all public schools then we can just ignore the Constitution? God you spout a ton of idiocy.
For those that know the law, that is where the Supreme court decides whether a law is constitutional or not. They are in fact the only body specified under the Constitution to with judicial power.
uh that is already illegal. I can only sell to people in my own state. that destroys any interstate commerce which deprives the federal government of any power to regulate.
Despite whether it is already illegal or not, if it can be shown that guns being purchased at gun shows in one state are being used in crimes in another state, there is a good argument that the gun show sales are complicit in the interstate commerce of guns.
Obviously, the great majority of Americans, including 85% of gun owners, are not buying your far right wing talking points.
Show me the 85% of Californians that don't support gay marriage?
that's a non answer and demonstrates a rather shocking ignorance of constitutional law.
its already against the law
and how can gun show sales are complicit? that's just stupid
Both times that the issue came up on the ballot here, Californians voted overwhelmingly against recognizing the proposed sick, vulgar mockery of marriage as anything comparable to genuine marriage. It is only through the actions of corrupt judges that the issue is still in question.
No matter how often you repeat this lie, it will remain every bit as much a lie as it was the first time you said it.
No matter how often you repeat this lie, it will remain every bit as much a lie as it was the first time you said it.
lie 2 (l)
n.
1. A false statement deliberately presented as being true; a falsehood.
2. Something meant to deceive or give a wrong impression.
Lie - definition of Lie by the Free Online Dictionary, Thesaurus and Encyclopedia.
For someone to lie, they must have intended to deceive.
And since you cannot know what his intentions were, then you cannot know whether he lied or not.
So your statement is totally meaningless.
I disagree.
It is plausible that when he first made that 90% claim, he thought it was true.
I think that claim has been solidly enough disproven, that I find it highly implausible that he still believes it to be true.
I cannot say for certain what goes on in his head, but it is clearly much more plausible that he is willfully repeating something that he now knows to be untrue than that he still believes it to be true.
How do you prove that gun does not cross state lines once you sell it?
For those that know the law, that is where the Supreme court decides whether a law is constitutional or not. They are in fact the only body specified under the Constitution with judicial power.
Its not against the law in 40 states for guns to be sold privately that may be carried across state lines.
Well, may as well do nothing than, right? Just keep selling guns to criminals and the mentally deranged in 40 states...............
Perhaps you don't know what the term "interstate commerce" means? Interstate commerce is taking something from one state into another state with the express purpose of selling it in that different state. Interstate commerce does not mean selling it in one state to another person in that state...that is called "intrastate commerce". Something that the federal government has no power over. Once the gun is sold intrastate it does not matter if the person that bought that item for personal use moves across state lines.
How does the universal background check prevent law abiding citizens that pass the background check from taking their gun purchase across state lines?
Since when have I cared about slanted polls and low wattage respondents. Your only argument is one based on an appeal to mediocrity
tell us Catawba-given your expansive understanding of constitutional law-how is this proposed law going to get past LOPEZ and what exactly is the connection to INTERSTATE COMMERCE given that I can only sell a personal weapon to someone who lives in my own state?
How do you prove that gun does not cross state lines once you sell it?
Roughly ninety percent of Americans support universal background checks. Do you?
I never said that it did.
Then do you know anyone that can explain how background checks are an infringement of interstate commerce laws?
Diversion much? Moving the goal posts much? You were asked a specific question and then when you tried to link interstate commerce with intrastate commerce you were called out on it. You can try and continue this line of "reasoning" but it will continue to fail because you either do not understand the difference between interstate commerce and intrastate commerce or since it has been explained to you the more likely scenario...are willfully ignoring it in order to push your anti-gun agenda. In which case your arguements are nothing more than partisan hackery at best.
The premise of the argument was that background checks are incompatible with interstate commerce laws. I want to know how?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?