• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Should children be allowed to use smartphones?

Bodi

Just waiting for my set...
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 29, 2007
Messages
133,396
Reaction score
31,180
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Independent
Under 18.

Should they? From an educational standpoint grades are dropping, attention spans are faltering, kids are obsessed with tic tok, instagram and following Influencers. Kids are more detached than ever, obsessed with games so much that some schools offer EA Sports as a class, and it is not about programming or something... it is about playing video games while at school.

Thoughts
?
 
I may be a bit too old to effectively comment on this, but if I was the parent of a young child right now, I would say, only with major supervision and monitoring of apps. Someone like @BirdinHand and other DPers with young children would be much better to weigh in on this issue. It is something that deserves serious thought though....
 
Under 18, yes. Under 12, generally no. From 12-18, with limits and supervision. My daughter is setting a line in the sand with her daughter, probably from lessons she herself learned that we were unaware needed to be taught due to the novelty of the smartphone when she was young. Go outside. Make meatspace friends. You'll be better for it.
 

Cell phones and their over usage is an addiction, imo. Look at the adults, dang near everyone with a damn cell phone in their hands, most can't drive without it. Seen people walking around in circles looking at their phone until they walk into a pole, lol. If it's this addictive to adults, bet your bottom dollar it's not healthy for young people. Just my two cents.

Personally, I go out of my way to prevent being tethered to a cell phone.....don't care if I miss a call/text.....so what, I'll get back to them. Human beings are very habitual creatures and this phenomenon has taken over, not a little, but big time.
 
Ohio has enacted legislation to mostly cut out cell use in schools. I'm for it.
They have enough distractions. Throw a cell in there and students aren't paying attention for shit.
https://governor.ohio.gov/media/new...ng-ohio-schools-to-create-cell-phone-policies
And as far as I'm concerned, some adults shouldn't have cell phones either.

Just because it's a text, doesn't mean you contact me about work on a weekend at 9pm Saturday or 9am Sunday.
Happened last weekend. And of course happened yesterday as well.

It's Saturday and a holiday weekend at that. Should have just waited until Tuesday, because I won't be getting back to you until then anyway.
Piss off...
 
The problem is that if your kid doesn't have one they are still going to be exposed to content via their friend's phones. If you go the no phone route you can't pat yourself on the back and think the problem is solved. You will still have to be vigilant about educating them about content and be aware of what they might be exposed to.
It's not just a phone concern, all screens have the potential to be a harmful influence.
 
Probably unwise for the government to get into the business of who is "allowed" to use smartphones, but I can see added regulatory efforts to increase parental access to smartphones used by those under 18 including smartphone use, common function monitoring, and various social media app monitoring.
 
I am amazed when I see 8 year olds toting around $1,200 iPhones which are so big they can barely even hold them.
I was at dinner with my son the other day and the family of four, two parent and to young kids, sitting at the table next to us all spent the entire time with their faces buried in their phones. We never heard any of them saying a single word to each other,
Now to answer your question.
Should children be allowed to use smartphones?
If I still had young kids I may let them have a smartphone but I would certain use one of the newer ones that can limit internet and social media access.
 

We passed a law here making cell phones in school illegal. Many schools just ignore it because they don't want to the hastle.



d
 

Cell phones yes, possibly whenever they are old enough to know how to use them and not lose them. There are controls parents can set for safe usage. Useful for emergencies, contacting, even tracking.

Re: smart phones, IMO 14 and even then with strict parental oversite and controls (yes, I realize that's sadly unrealistic) and not used in school.

And schools should be able to regulate their access any way they choose. IMO, no phones during class time.
 
It should be up to the parents.
 
Sure.
 
Lethargic Aptitude said:
It should be up to the parents.
Click to expand...

Nope. It creates huge distractions as kids without a phone are drawn to the kid showing tik toc videos or Spotify playlists... it is like a drug.

One has to see it to understand.
 
OrphanSlug said:
Probably unwise for the government to get into the business of who is "allowed" to use smartphones,
Click to expand...

At school. There are already limits to what kids can do or say at school.
 

That is something that some schools do...
 
Bodi said:
Nope. It creates huge distractions as kids without a phone are drawn to the kid showing tik toc videos or Spotify playlists... it is like a drug.

One has to see it to understand.
Click to expand...
Children are the responsibility of their parents. If you believe electronic devices are a problem for a child, consult with their parent(s).
Also, I have kids and have seen plenty of kids with their heads bent down staring into a screen. But I am also observant enough to know that not all kids stare at screens for hours since parents like myself are astute enough to out distract them.
 
Lethargic Aptitude said:
Children are the responsibility of their parents.
Click to expand...

Schools have a duty of care for minors in the care

Lethargic Aptitude said:
If you believe electronic devices are a problem for a child, consult with their parent(s).
Click to expand...

That happens. Schools can also just ban certain things. Skateboards in class, weapons, drugs, porno, distracting, radios, movies, etc.

Lethargic Aptitude said:
Also, I have kids and have seen plenty of kids with their heads bent down staring into a screen. But I am also observant enough to know that not all kids stare at screens for hours since parents like myself are astute enough to out distract them.
Click to expand...

Not every parent is the superstar that you are... meaning, the issue is bigger than you.

.
 
Whether a parent is good at parenting or not, does change the legality of responsibility.

Schools can legally ban distractions, so what is your problem then? Your responsibility towards children is limited, while a parents is endless. You are worried about annoying distractions, while the parent might have other reasons their child has the phone. The school's power to decide that is limited to school functions and property.

You seem to want to make it illegal for a child between the ages you mentioned to own a phone. That is an overreach for any school.
 

Phones are banned in schools here.

Lethargic Aptitude said:
You seem to want to make it illegal for a child between the ages you mentioned to own a phone. That is an overreach for any school.
Click to expand...

Incorrect. Just at school.
 
Bodi said:
Phones are banned in schools here.



Incorrect. Just at school.
Click to expand...

Where were you seeing these kids then, obviously not at the school where you work? Why would you raise this concern if it has already been fixed?
 
Lethargic Aptitude said:
Where were you seeing these kids then, obviously not at the school where you work? Why would you raise this concern if it has already been fixed?
Click to expand...

I am not saying it is a problem or not at any one school. I asked a question in the OP. You are free to answer if you like.,


It is obviously a massive problem and no one parent has the right to say their kid can have and use a phone at school if it causes distractions.

That is what I think. What is it that you think?

.
 
Bodi said:
...some schools offer EA Sports as a class....
Click to expand...

What elementary and or secondary schools are offering "EA Sports" (assuming you mean Esports) as a credit bearing class?

I my school system we have Esports as an after school competative team through VHSL (Virginia High School League), similar to Speech Forensics and Debate Teams.

WW
 
WorldWatcher said:
What elementary and or secondary schools are offering "EA Sports" (assuming you mean Esports) as a credit bearing class?
Click to expand...

Lots of them... secondary and colleges...

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…