• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Pro-Trump states most affected by his health care decision

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
111,687
Reaction score
101,936
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Pro-Trump states most affected by his health care decision


By CHRISTINA A. CASSIDY AND MEGHAN HOYER
ASSOCIATED PRESS Oct 14, 2017

President Donald Trump's decision to end a provision of the Affordable Care Act that was benefiting roughly 6 million Americans helps fulfill a campaign promise, but it also risks harming some of the very people who helped him win the presidency. Nearly 70 percent of those benefiting from the so-called cost-sharing subsidies live in states Trump won last November, according to an analysis by The Associated Press. The number underscores the political risk for Trump and his party, which could end up owning the blame for increased costs and chaos in the insurance marketplace. An estimated 4 million people were benefiting from the cost-sharing payments in the 30 states Trump carried, according to an analysis of 2017 enrollment data from the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Of the 10 states with the highest percentage of consumers benefiting from cost-sharing, all but one — Massachusetts — went for Trump. Kentucky embraced former President Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act under its last governor, a Democrat, and posted some of the largest gains in getting its residents insured. Its new governor, a Republican, favors the GOP stance to replace it with something else. Roughly half of the estimated 71,000 Kentuckians buying health insurance on the federal exchange were benefiting from the cost-sharing subsidies Trump just ended. Despite the gains from Obama's law, the state went for Trump last fall even as he vowed to repeal it. Rates already were rising in the immediate aftermath of Trump's decision.

Insurance regulators in Arkansas, another state that went for Trump, approved premium increases on Friday ranging from 14 percent to nearly 25 percent for plans offered through the insurance marketplace. Had federal cost-sharing been retained, the premiums would have risen by no more than 10 percent. In Mississippi, another state Trump won, an estimated 80 percent of consumers who buy coverage on the insurance exchange benefit from the deductible and co-pay discounts, the highest percentage of any state. Premiums there will increase by 47 percent next year, after regulators assumed Trump would end the cost-sharing payments. Trump's move concerned some Republicans, worried the party will be blamed for the effects on consumers and insurance markets. "I think the president is ill-advised to take this course of action, because we, at the end of the day, will own this," Rep. Charlie Dent (R) of Pennsylvania said Friday on CNN. "We, the Republican Party, will own this."

Trumpcare 2018 premium hikes are on the way. With his EO-directed sabotage against the ACA, Trump now owns healthcare costs in the US.
 
Bloomberg has a handy map.

Share of Marketplace Enrollees Receiving CSRs is Highest in the South
10-13-17-csr-enrollment.png


Trump's decision will spike premiums for everyone but the impact will fall more heavily on places that supported him. There may even be some market exits. We've never had a bare county with no sellers, but now Trump may have paved the way for some. And undoubtedly they'll be red, rural counties.
 
Pro-Trump states most affected by his health care decision




Trumpcare 2018 premium hikes are on the way. With his EO-directed sabotage against the ACA, Trump now owns healthcare costs in the US.

I like this thread, thanks for starting it.

One point: It's not the EO that does this.

White House’s decision to stop ACA cost-sharing subsidies triggers strong opposition

The Trump administration’s decision to halt payments to insurers...
...The administration’s move, which officials formalized through a filing in a federal appeals court...
 
Unfortunately, Conservatives and Republicans appear to be the only ones who are not aware that they constantly vote against their own interests. With Trickle Down economics revealed as an illusion, gun control out of control, and Christian values constantly betrayed by their "representatives," they really have little to believe in anymore. Instead of reinventing themselves, which is something political groups and voters should do as history and society advances, Conservatives and Republicans have dug in and doubled down on their senseless ideologies.

They simply go along with the flow of the political current even if it means that their representation worsens their medical care. But how does a billionaire, who lacks family values, morality, demeans military service, and embraces a mean spirit, represent the Christian base that is supposed to be the Republican Party?

When the GOP begs its constituency not to vote for Donald Trump, perhaps it is time to wake the hell up. The American Right is proving dysfunctional. This is what happens when the GOP pushes its voters to extremism for eight years. The Conservative answer to the Democratic lame duck (Clinton), was an absolute buffoon who is going to send their medical premiums through the roof. And the voters applaud for the fools that they are.

Here's to Making America Great...again?
 
Last edited:
It's times like this that I wonder how the people who voted for Trump in part because of his campaign promise to have healthcare for everyone are feeling right now.
 
It's times like this that I wonder how the people who voted for Trump in part because of his campaign promise to have healthcare for everyone are feeling right now.

Hard to tell if they're even aware he's responsible for their 2018 premium hike.
 
It's times like this that I wonder how the people who voted for Trump in part because of his campaign promise to have healthcare for everyone are feeling right now.

I get the feeling that Trump plans to shift the blame for everything onto Republicans in congress and claim that still fighting the good fight, but the swamp is to blame for any problems.
 
I get the feeling that Trump plans to shift the blame for everything onto Republicans in congress and claim that still fighting the good fight, but the swamp is to blame for any problems.

No, Trump and republicans will deny blame for the destruction of Obama care and instead say, "See, Obama care self-destructed, just like we said it would". And most republicans and Trump supporters will believe it. It's a win-win for Trump and republican politicians at the expense of Americans.
 
No, Trump and republicans will deny blame for the destruction of Obama care and instead say, "See, Obama care self-destructed, just like we said it would". And most republicans and Trump supporters will believe it. It's a win-win for Trump and republican politicians at the expense of Americans.

You're right about the "Obamacare self-destructing" lie, but he also promised to replace Obamacare with a plan that would cover more people, be cheaper and better. Since that's impossible and even the most obtuse voter will notice if he/she doesn't have coverage anymore, someone will get blamed. Trump plans for it to be congress.
 
If the right were rational, anyone that wasn't wealthy wouldn't be a Republican.
 
If the right were rational, anyone that wasn't wealthy wouldn't be a Republican.

So are you saying that people become Democrats because they selfishly want to receive benefits?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Pro-Trump states most affected by his health care decision




Trumpcare 2018 premium hikes are on the way. With his EO-directed sabotage against the ACA, Trump now owns healthcare costs in the US.

It's a policy that has no upside -- except that Trump can show that he is tough enough to wreak a lot of harm on Americans without a care. He basically has negative empathy -- that is, enjoys seeing others hurt. Trump has betrayed this supporters, just as he has betrayed everyone else in his life. This action will cost them, and it will hurt people you love. Wait and see.
 
Tell the folks in Arizona who just saw an 106% increase it their healthcare premiums. The dems own this fiasco for passing a very flawed joke on the American people.
Not one republican voted for it!
How will taking away the subsidies reduce their healthcare premiums?

Nobody is saying that the ACA is perfect and the Republicans in Congress had eight years to work with Democrats on viable solutions but they chose to focus on 100 meaningless repeal votes.

Trump's action does no good. John Kasich said on Meet the Press about an hour ago: 'I Just Don't Think There's Any Policy Here... "
https://www.nbcnews.com/widget/video-embed/1073688131550
 
Last edited:
Many old white conservatives might be left with unaffordable health care with trump's latest decree.....................Good
 
Last edited:
So are you saying that people become Democrats because they selfishly want to receive benefits?
Rich Republicans have a personal financial interest to be Republicans -- they vote against programs that cost money but help average Americans.
Most people aren't rich and want those programs, such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and the ACA. There is nothing wrong with average Americans doing what rich Republicans do.
 
Remember why we are in the disaster today.

The lies Obama used to get the bill passed.


Obama said:
"If You Like Your Doctor, You Will Be Able To Keep Your Doctor, Period."

"If You Like Your Health Care Plan, You'll Be Able To Keep Your Health Care Plan, Period"

"Cut the cost of a typical family's premium by up to $2,500 a year."
 
Unfortunately, Conservatives and Republicans appear to be the only ones who are not aware that they constantly vote against their own interests. With Trickle Down economics revealed as an illusion, gun control out of control, and Christian values constantly betrayed by their "representatives," they really have little to believe in anymore. Instead of reinventing themselves, which is something political groups and voters should do as history and society advances, Conservatives and Republicans have dug in and doubled down on their senseless ideologies.

They simply go along with the flow of the political current even if it means that their representation worsens their medical care. But how does a billionaire, who lacks family values, morality, demeans military service, and embraces a mean spirit, represent the Christian base that is supposed to be the Republican Party?

When the GOP begs its constituency not to vote for Donald Trump, perhaps it is time to wake the hell up. The American Right is proving dysfunctional. This is what happens when the GOP pushes its voters to extremism for eight years. The Conservative answer to the Democratic lame duck (Clinton), was an absolute buffoon who is going to send their medical premiums through the roof. And the voters applaud for the fools that they are.

Here's to Making America Great...again?

Post of the month! Excellent.
 
Many old white conservatives might be left with affordable health care with trump's latest decree.....................Good
Just the opposite. The beneficiaries of the ACA are the old and the sick. If you are 50 or older you were very much helped by the ACA's provisions, including subsidies. Just like the GOP alternatives to Obamacare, this action raises the cost to older Americans, who are a worse insurance risk to insurance cos.
 
So are you saying that people become Democrats because they selfishly want to receive benefits?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes, as opposed to working your ass off for the benefit of the wealthy.
 
Pro-Trump states most affected by his health care decision




Trumpcare 2018 premium hikes are on the way. With his EO-directed sabotage against the ACA, Trump now owns healthcare costs in the US.

So you believe those 6 million Americans voted for Trump in the last election? really? Absolutely stunning how everything is anti trump and never pro personal responsibility with the left. Subsidies for ACA came out of the pocket of taxpayers, something the left wants everyone to ignore and in a country of 330 million Americans with 27 million still uninsured and ACA helping so few this is nothing more than anti Trump hate rhetoric to fire up the ignorant leftwing base
 
Rich Republicans have a personal financial interest to be Republicans -- they vote against programs that cost money but help average Americans.
Most people aren't rich and want those programs, such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and the ACA. There is nothing wrong with average Americans doing what rich Republicans do.

So if most people want ACA how did Obama lose the House in 2010-2010 and the Congress in 2014-2016 since ACA was a major campaign issue that even the left ran from?
 
Rich Republicans have a personal financial interest to be Republicans -- they vote against programs that cost money but help average Americans.
Most people aren't rich and want those programs, such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and the ACA. There is nothing wrong with average Americans doing what rich Republicans do.

I've never understood their enthusiasm for subservience.
 
Back
Top Bottom