• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Palestinian Arabs were given the gift of self government, and they've squandered it

Israel has repeatedly elected terrorists to lead it.
 
So you believe the US should be destroyed like Nazi Germany, yes? Another objectively bad nation?

If a country is “objectively bad”, does that mean everything it does is bad?
Germany wasn’t destroyed. The Allies considered that plan and rejected it.
 

No “probably” about it. The majority of Gazans were either not born or were at most toddlers when Hamas was voted in.
 
So Gaza isn’t being destroyed either right? Flattening cities and killing a significant portion of the population doesn’t destroy a nation?
If you’ve got evidence of massive bomber raids on Germany post 1945 let’s see them.
 
With having elected Hama to govern, Palestinians have also enabled, and have chosen, the ideological indoctrination of Palestinian children into Hamas terrorists.

The Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI) documents Hamas’s extensive apparatus for indoctrinating Palestinian children from a young age to embrace jihad, hate Jews, and seek martyrdom. This includes Hamas-run TV programs, schools, and summer camps. Specific examples include:
  • A 2007 Hamas TV clip featuring a child, Saraa Barhoum, singing “We Liberated Gaza by Force,” glorifying violence (No. 1637).
  • A 2022 Hamas TV event honoring mothers of “martyrs,” where a mother expressed willingness to sacrifice all 17 of her children for Palestine and Al-Aqsa (No. 9928).
  • 2023 summer camp reports showing children trained in weapons use and simulating attacks on Israeli military posts (No. 10381).
  • A 2023 dispatch quoting a Hamas terrorist’s mother saying, “The Jews are our enemies, we should fight them, devour them with our teeth” (No. 10598).

Teaching Terror: How Hamas Radicalizes Palestinian Society (Published February 11, 2007, with relevance to ongoing patterns)
  • This report details Hamas’s radicalization efforts through its dawa (social welfare and outreach) network, including schools, mosques, and summer camps. Key points:
  • A 2004 Israel Security Agency report noted a 64% increase in minors involved in terrorism compared to 2003, linked to Hamas’s indoctrination.
  • At a Hamas-run kindergarten graduation, 1,600 preschoolers wore military uniforms and carried mock rifles, with a five-year-old girl mimicking bloodied hands from the 2000 Ramallah lynching of two Israelis.
  • Summer camps feature weapons training and propaganda, with Sheikh Bahar stating they instill “seeds of hate against Israel” in children.
  • Hamas’s Islamic Student Movement distributes “Instruction Cards” with images of suicide bombers, encouraging youth to emulate them.

Evidence of Hamas Indoctrination in Gaza (Published January 3, 2024)

ISGAP: What Hamas Leaders Actually Want – In Their Own Words (Published February 6, 2024)
  • The Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP) cites Hamas’s 1988 charter, which calls for the annihilation of Israel and Jews, framing it as a religious duty. It quotes senior Hamas official Ghazi Hamad (November 8, 2023), who said Hamas is “proud to sacrifice” Palestinians for its mission to exterminate Jews, viewing civilians as “martyrs.” The report references:
    • Hamas’s October 7, 2023, attack, involving massacres, rapes, and abductions, as evidence of its anti-Semitic ideology in action.
    • Videos and statements from Hamas leaders glorifying violence and dehumanizing Jews, aligning with the charter’s call for jihad.

Further:
  • New York Post: Israeli Survivors Explain Hamas Indoctrination (Published October 30, 2023)
  • Wilson Center: Doctrine of Hamas (Published October 19, 2023)

At this point, what do you do with a failed, terrorist state?
Keep funding it? Keep it alive?
History has shown that funding it the money and support is redirected to building terror tunnels, and slaughtering innocent people.
 
Don't forget that the State of Israel occupied Gaza for decades.
Seems like they were better off under that situation.
Don't forget that Netanyahu, in an attempt to weaken the power of the Palestinian Authority, promoted Hamas in that election.
The Palestinian authority is Hamas.
Yes, Hamas is a terrorist organization. But today, the majority of Palestinian adults in Gaza probably didn't vote for Hamas in that one election.
So the Palestinians are being oppressed by Hamas.
Seems like Palestine benefits from being under the control of Israel. Hamas seems to want to get Palestinians killed
It looks as if trying to eradicate Hamas from the Strip by force is not a successful strategy.
Is this because they don't want to kill innocent Palestinians and children that Hamas uses as human Shields I think that's what it is. So again Hamas is the supreme enemy to Palestine. If Israel wanted to they could flip a switch and white Palestine off the map.
 
So Gaza isn’t being destroyed either right? Flattening cities and killing a significant portion of the population doesn’t destroy a nation?
Reducing homes, businesses, schools, roads, bridges to rubble isn't destroying Gaza?

Making Palestinians dispossessed and homeless, severely-restricting access to medical and healthcare, and refusing to allow deliveries of sufficient quantities of food, potable water, and other necessities isn't destroying Gaza?
 
If you’ve got evidence of massive bomber raids on Germany post 1945 let’s see them.

If the Israelis stop bombing Gaza does that mean the destruction of the past conflict magically disappears? Do the dead suddenly come back to life?

How many Americans should be killed and how many cities flattened to stop our “objectively bad” country?
 
Israel has repeatedly elected terrorists to lead it.
This is a lie. If there were terrorists we would be talking about Palestine in the past tense. Terrorists with the power that Israel has and it's region are called terrorists that are called dictators.
 
When was the last election in Gaza?

What are the current age demographics in Gaza?

We both know that the majority of Palestinian adults in Gaza today didn't "elect" Hamas. That Hamas is the default government doesn't mean it's the government Palestinians would prefer. It means Hamas is the government Palestinians in the Strip are stuck with.

And it sure as heck doesn't mean that prior to October 7, 2023, the majority of Palestinians supported Hamas' attacks on Israel.
 
Well, in Vietnam it was a lot.

Provably depends on the war
 
This is a lie. If there were terrorists we would be talking about Palestine in the past tense. Terrorists with the power that Israel has and its region are called terrorists that are called dictators.
Nope, Menachim Begin, for example, was absolutely a terrorist.

The U.S. choosing not to label allied tyrants as dictators is an entirely different issue.
 
A lot of American cities were flattened in the Vietnam war? Source for this claim?
You said: How many Americans should be killed and how many cities flattened to stop our “objectively bad” country”

I replied :in Vietnam, it was a lot.

Trying to deny America KIA rather proves my point.
 
You said: How many Americans should be killed and how many cities flattened to stop our “objectively bad” country”

I replied :in Vietnam, it was a lot.

Trying to deny America KIA rather proves my point.

And I said source for your claim that a lot of American cities were flattened in Vietnam. Can you provide one?
 
You appear to still believe that there is still something redeeming about Hamas. Sorry, but I don't.

It also seems that you believe that your Western value system and decision making applies to the Middle East as well as to Hamas and Palestinians in particular.
Your rude surprise is that they don't.

The grotesque reality is that the cycle we have been repeating decades now is going to continue, Hamas constantly creating and indoctrinating their next set of recruits replenishing their ranks.

This indoctrination has been going on for so long that Hamas and Palestinians are one and the same, and that distinction no longer has any difference.
 
You appear to still believe that there is still something redeeming about Hamas. Sorry, but I don't.
Nothing I've said on this thread or on other threads supports your opinion.
It also seems that you believe that your Western value system and decision making applies to the Middle East as well as to Hamas and Palestinians in particular.
Your rude surprise is that they don't.
Nothing I've said on this thread or on other threads supports your opinion.
No, it's not at all valid to claim that today "Hamas and Palestinians are one and the same, and that distinction no longer has any difference."

As I've noted, and you have not refuted, it's highly unlikely that the majority of today's adult Palestinians in the Gaza Strip voted nearly 2 decades ago to empower Hamas.
 
And I said source for your claim that a lot of American cities were flattened in Vietnam. Can you provide one?
Oh, so you are admitting your talk about KIA was worthless? Good to know.
 
When was the last election in Gaza?
2006. So, would you say that Hamas is a dictatorial government since they haven’t allowed election in 17 years?
Well, they sure as **** supported them after Hamas murdered 1200 Israeli civilians.


Despite the devastation, 57% of respondents in Gaza and 82% in the West Bank believe Hamas was correct in launching the October attack, the poll indicated.
 
You don't know much about it, I agree. Hamas is an outgrowth of the Muslim Brotherhood, both had been supported by Israel to undermine the the Palestinian Authority. Why? Because the PA was effective, popular and was gaining Western sentiment in the efforts towards a 2 state solution. Israel did not want a 2 state solution. The MB and Hamas did their job, gained power and became the foil for Israel.

Israel had just given a large sum of Qatar funding to Hamas before Oct 7th. Israel security had all sorts of red lights flashing and Bibi ignored them. The viper they created and fed bit them, it gave Israel the excuse to wipe out Gaza.
 
Israel has murdered more innocent civilians in a single year than Hamas has in its entire existence.

It shows the empathy Palestinians possess that the number is not 100 percent in both cases.
 
Despite the devastation, 57% of respondents in Gaza and 82% in the West Bank believe Hamas was correct in launching the October attack, the poll indicated.
When a prison population keeps being degraded for decades, they will become radicalized. When you allow radical groups to enter into the prison, and you support them, they often will gain the support of the population as you degrade them. Israel is not innocent in this matter.
 
Israel has murdered more innocent civilians in a single year than Hamas has in its entire existence.

It shows the empathy Palestinians possess that the number is not 100 percent in both cases.
Well, we know where you stand on the issue, right? “From the river to the sea”?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…