• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

New Zealand woman and six-year-old son detained for three weeks by Ice in US enduring ‘terrifying’ ordeal

W_Heisenberg

Trade Representative of Heard and McDonald Islands
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 6, 2019
Messages
26,440
Reaction score
28,527
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
Woman with partial visa approval and a son who is a legal resident sent from Washington State to Texas and detained for 3 weeks by ICE.


Ice confiscated Shaw’s phone and transported the mother and son to the Dilley immigration processing center in south Texas, many states away from her home, Besancon said. Foreign nationals caught up in the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown have similarly been transported to centres far from their homes, support networks and legal representation.

“It has been absolutely horrible,” Besancon said, adding that aside from the staff, Shaw and her son are the only English speakers, are locked in their shared bedroom from 8pm to 8am and are not allowed to wear their own clothes.

“It really is kind of like being in jail ... it has been absolutely devastating and it’s kind of barbaric.”

Shaw is on what is known as a “combo card” visa – an employment visa, which she obtained through her employment at a maximum security juvenile facility, and an I-360 visa, which can grant immigration status to domestic violence survivors.

Shaw had recently received a letter confirming her visa renewal, not realising that the I-360 element of her visa was still pending approval.

“It wasn’t until she tried to come back across the border that she realised only half of the combination card – because it’s only one physical card – had been fully approved,” said Besancon.

Border officials did not need to detain Shaw and could have filed for humanitarian parole, Besancon said. Meanwhile, all three of Shaw’s children have had their I-360 visas approved, and Besancon alleged her youngest son was therefore being detained “illegally”.



Shaw’s case is the latest in a growing list of foreigners facing interrogation, detainment and deportations at the US border, including a British tourist, three Germans Lucas Sielaff, Fabian Schmidt and Jessica Brösche, and a Canadian and an Australian who were each held and then deported, despite having valid work visas.
 
In related news:

U.S. Tourism Will Lose Up To $29 Billion As Visitors Plummet Amid Trump Policies​



Probably just a bunch of woke lib tourists lol maga, they can stay out! Tourism is woke lib stuff. LOL MaGa MAGA! Woke lib tourists can take their tourist dollars elsewhere! Hahahaha!
 
It erodes our world reputation when we make such a farce of the rights outlined in our Constitution.

Trump and his supporters are mean, ignorant, belligerent assholes and they are successfully transforming our government into a government operated by mean, ignorant, belligerent assholes. Who wants to come to the U.S. if there is a risk they’re going to be imprisoned for weeks for a minor error? If I were a foreigner I wouldn’t come here.
 
Courts really, really need to put an end to this shit. It's within reason to detain someone who is out of status or if there's a question about their status, but there's no need to ship them to the other side of the country and detain them without access to a lawyer. It's a violation of their civil liberties, and contrary to what people think - at least prior to this Court - foreign nationals still have mostly the same civil liberties we do, with some exceptions. Access to counsel is a fundamental civil right for all.
 
Shit! I'm as white as they come. I better start carrying my passport. I recommend everyone do as well. We'll except for the maggots/conservatives
As long as white people stay put, they are safe. It's only when you leave and try to re-enter the country that they are forced to look at more than your skin tone.
 
At least Lefties cant cry racism with this one
I don't think that post is going to work out how you think it is. Thanks for giving everyone the opportunity to point out that Republicans aren't just racist but they're also just plain angry hateful people. Is that the look you were going for?
 
I don't think that post is going to work out how you think it is. Thanks for giving everyone the opportunity to point out that Republicans aren't just racist but they're also just plain angry hateful people. Is that the look you were going for?
I dont need a seal of approval from you, or anyone else
 
She violated the terms of her visa and she’s paying the price for that. There’s no story here.
 
Courts really, really need to put an end to this shit. It's within reason to detain someone who is out of status or if there's a question about their status, but there's no need to ship them to the other side of the country and detain them without access to a lawyer. It's a violation of their civil liberties, and contrary to what people think - at least prior to this Court - foreign nationals still have mostly the same civil liberties we do, with some exceptions. Access to counsel is a fundamental civil right for all.
Yup, as the article stated, she didn't need to have been arrested and jailed. She should have done due diligence in ensuring that both portions of her combo card were renewed properly, but it does also seem like there can be confusion as it's contained all on one physical card and her processing was pending.

I think there's a lot that could have been done in order to have avoided throwing her in prison for 3 weeks. But that takes a degree of reason and intelligence MAGA doesn't possess.
 
Did you know that around 5% of convicted criminals are estimated to be innocent.
Do we therefore throw out the entire justice system because of that 5%??

Our criminal legal system, as inherited from the English legal system, is based on the idea that it’s better for the government to occasionally let a guilty person free than to imprison an innocent person.

You and your fascist allies, because of your cultish support of a convicted felon who shits in a diaper, are abandoning centuries of tradition. None of you are conservatives. Most of you are fascists.
 
Back
Top Bottom