• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

New York Times: "Read the Full "Make America Healthy Again" Report"

substantialmajestic

DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 23, 2022
Messages
186
Reaction score
167
New York Times
May 22, 2025
"Read the full "Make America Healthy Again" Report."


Discussion: In light of the pharmacy industry funding billions into medical schools (funds 80%), legislatures (funds 4.7 billion), and media (funds 5 billion), what have been some non-drug solutions that have helped your own health in life? For me, I have been able to stop buying cough medicine by switching to gargling salt water and taking vitamin D. Thank you.



Purpose and Scope
- Objective: The report aims to provide a transparent, evidence-based foundation to address the childhood chronic disease crisis by identifying its root causes and informing policy interventions.

- Commission: The Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Commission, chaired by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., is tasked with studying the crisis, informing the public, and recommending government-wide strategies within 180 days.

The Chronic Disease Crisis
- Scale: Over 40% of U.S. children (approximately 73 million) have at least one chronic condition, such as obesity, diabetes, asthma, allergies, or behavioral disorders.

- Impact: Over 75% of youth aged 17-24 are ineligible for military service due to obesity, poor fitness, or mental health issues, threatening national health, economy, and security.

Trends:
Obesity: Over 20% of children over 6 are obese, a 270% increase since the 1970s, with severe obesity up 500%. About 80% of obese teens become obese adults.

Diabetes: Over 350,000 children have diabetes, with type 2 diabetes cases rising over 600% projected by 2060. Pre-diabetes in teens exceeds 25%.

Other Conditions: Rising rates of neurodevelopmental disorders, cancer, mental health issues, autoimmune diseases, and allergies.

Key Drivers of the Crisis

Poor Diet:
- Nearly 70% of children’s calories come from ultra-processed foods (UPFs), linked to obesity, diabetes, and nutrient depletion.
- Government programs, like school lunch initiatives, often exacerbate the issue by promoting UPFs.

Environmental Chemical Exposure:
- Children face increasing exposure to synthetic chemicals, linked to developmental and chronic health issues.
- Regulatory frameworks need evaluation to address cumulative chemical impacts.

Lack of Physical Activity and Chronic Stress:
- Increased screen time, sedentary lifestyles, sleep deprivation, and psychosocial stress contribute to physical and mental health declines.

Overmedicalization:
- Over prescription of medications, driven by corporate influence, leads to unnecessary treatments and long-term risks.

- The childhood vaccine schedule has expanded, with concerns about safety monitoring and conflicts of interest in regulatory oversight.

Corporate Capture and Systemic Issues

Mechanisms:

- Distorted Science: Pharmaceutical industry funds 97% of highly cited clinical trials, often exaggerating benefits and underreporting harms. Medical journals rely on industry revenue, and peer review is often biased or ineffective.

- Influence on Policy: The industry spent $4.7 billion on lobbying (1999-2018) and funds patient advocacy groups, influencing legislation and regulations.

- Clinical Practice: Industry funds 80% of medical school departments and half of continuing medical education, promoting drug use and polypharmacy.

- Media Control: Over $5 billion spent on TV ads in 2023, with direct-to-consumer advertising driving inappropriate prescriptions, especially for ADHD and antidepressants in children.

- Vaccine Concerns: The National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (1986) shields manufacturers from liability, creating disincentives for safety research. The Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) is limited in studying long-term outcomes, and open scientific inquiry is stifled by professional repercussions.

Proposed Next Steps

Research Initiatives:
- Address the replication crisis to improve scientific reliability.
- Enhance post-marketing surveillance for pediatric drugs.
- Build a real-world data platform linking health and environmental data.
- Use AI for early detection of harmful exposures.
- Reform oversight of GRAS food ingredients.
- Fund nutrition trials comparing whole-food and low-UPF diets.
- Launch large-scale lifestyle intervention trials.
- Study long-term effects of pediatric drugs.
- Invest in alternative testing models (e.g., organ-on-a-chip).
- Map gene-environment interactions for precision toxicology.

Strategy Development: The MAHA Commission will develop a comprehensive strategy by August 2025, involving private sector and academic collaboration.

Call to Action
The report emphasizes reversing the crisis through truth, science, and pro-growth policies, prioritizing prevention, and transforming food, health, and scientific systems to ensure healthier future generations.
 
"Corporate Capture and Systemic Issues"

What does that mean?
 
Interesting what it omits:

"Kennedy has made combatting the chronic disease “epidemic” a cornerstone of his vision for the US, even as he has ignored common causes of chronic conditions, such as smoking and alcohol use. ...it ignores the leading causes of death for children – firearms and motor vehicle accidents – and one of the most common chronic conditions: dental cavities.

...The report comes as the administration has taken a raft of actions researchers consider contrary to the health of Americans, such as eliminating world-leading sexually transmitted disease research laboratories and highly effective tobacco-prevention offices and pushing health leaders and researchers to quit or be fired in the face of censorship and politicization.

...While the report compares US life expectancy and healthcare costs to peer-developed democracies, it does not mention how other nations typically finance healthcare for all citizens: often at minimal or no cost.


By contrast, about 26 million Americans lack health insurance coverage, and the Republican-controlled House passed a bill only hours earlier that was expected to kick 13 million low-income people off public health insurance by 2033 and cut federal food support for the poor."

Link
 
- Commission: The Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Commission, chaired by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., is tasked with studying the crisis, informing the public, and recommending government-wide strategies within 180 days.
RFKJr. NOT a doctor or a scientist. Sheesh! :rolleyes:
 
"Kennedy has made combatting the chronic disease “epidemic” a cornerstone of his vision for the US, even as he has ignored common causes of chronic conditions, such as smoking and alcohol use. ...it ignores the leading causes of death for children – firearms and motor vehicle accidents – and one of the most common chronic conditions: dental cavities.
The report clearly states that it's purpose is to evaluate childhood chronic diseases. That's not "leading causes of death." Your comment raises the question as to whether children suffer an epidemic of alcohol or tobacco use, and if a "condition such as dental cavities" is a chronic childhood disease."
...The report comes as the administration has taken a raft of actions researchers consider contrary to the health of Americans, such as eliminating world-leading sexually transmitted disease research laboratories and highly effective tobacco-prevention offices and pushing health leaders and researchers to quit or be fired in the face of censorship and politicization.
Those issues aren't related to chronic childhood diseases, the subject of this report.
...While the report compares US life expectancy and healthcare costs to peer-developed democracies, it does not mention how other nations typically finance healthcare for all citizens: often at minimal or no cost.
That's probably because the report isn't about healthcare financing.
By contrast, about 26 million Americans lack health insurance coverage, and the Republican-controlled House passed a bill only hours earlier that was expected to kick 13 million low-income people off public health insurance by 2033 and cut federal food support for the poor."
That bit of partisan propaganda isn't relevant to this report/
 
U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said, “I don’t think people should be taking medical advice from me.”
And he's right. But the reports was prepared by the commission that included 13 other department heads, with the data undoubtedly compiled by their staffs - not by Kennedy.
 
The report clearly states that it's purpose is to evaluate childhood chronic diseases.
It starts much broader than that;

This report-Make Our Children Healthy Again: Assessment— is a call to action. It presents the stark reality of American children's declining health, backed by compelling data and long-term trends. More importantly, it seeks to unpack the potential dietary, behavioral, medical, and environmental drivers behind this crisis. By examining the root causes of deteriorating child health, this assessment establishes a clear, evidence- based foundation for the policy interventions, institutional reforms, and societal shifts needed to reverse course.

So why then if the concern is "declining child health" does it, as pointed out, ignore the biggest causes of child deaths?
 
And he's right. But the reports was prepared by the commission that included 13 other department heads, with the data undoubtedly compiled by their staffs - not by Kennedy.
He is the Head, it has his name, yet he has said he is not to be relied upon. He shouldn't be in the position to begin with.
 
He is the Head, it has his name, yet he has said he is not to be relied upon.
No, he didn't say that. He said that people shouldn't take medical advice from him. That's obviously correct. But there is no medical advice in the report. It's a study on what are likely causes of some chronic childhood diseases.
He shouldn't be in the position to begin with.
That;s your opinion, and you're entitled to it.
 
with the data undoubtedly compiled
they left out almost all of this:

nihms-1036871-f0001.jpg

 
they left out almost all of this:
Which of those are "chronic childhood diseases," which is the subject if the report? As the introduction states,"The initial mission of the Commission shall be to advise and assist the President on how best to exercise his authority to address the childhood chronic disease crisis."
 
No, he didn't say that. He said that people shouldn't take medical advice from him.
Oh shit, another argument based on semantics, let me help you....there is no difference between my saying "he cannot be relied upon for medical advice" and his entire quote that I already posted, stop creating such pedantic nonsense.
That's obviously correct. But there is no medical advice in the report.
The hell there isn't. It is offering recommendations for the grab-bag of RFK concerns, not the leading causes of child mortality.
It's a study on what are likely causes of some chronic childhood diseases.
You have this habit of insisting on repeating already counter points.
That;s your opinion, and you're entitled to it.
I'm not alone, even he says he should not be relied upon for medical advice. That is one of the main functions of HHS
 
Last edited:
You’re going to confuse the MAGATS.
I don't think so. Most of them are smart enough to understand what the report is about.
RFK is going to kill people
How. By suggesting that it's good for families to have meals together? By suggesting that kids spend too much time staring at screens? By suggesting that children's diets have deteriorated? How is any of that going to kill anyone?
He absolutely should not be in the position he’s in
That's your politics, and has nothing to do with the report. Is there something in the report that your health expertise makes you disagree with?
 
Back
Top Bottom