• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Low level flight panics NY

kaya'08

DP Veteran
Joined
Nov 25, 2008
Messages
6,363
Reaction score
1,318
Location
British Turk
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Centrist

BBC NEWS | Americas | Low-level flight panics New York (small clip on this link worth watching)

The president was not on board the flight, which was organised to take photographs of Air Force One against the New York skyline.
 
"Just kidding."

-Barack Obama

:mrgreen:
 
I see large, low-flying jets and fighter planes pretty often in California, and I hardly ever evacuate my building. Then again, we haven't had our buildings knocked down since 1906.


Duke
 
Last edited:

Those people in the video are actually on the waterfront in New Jersey, but it's a revealing clip. While residents of the area are a tough bunch and not prone to dwell on the horror of 9/11, this incident shows just how close beneath the surface the fear lies. These are not ******s...if you had lived through 9/11 in lower Manhattan you would understand.
 

You were there?

As one who did. one has to wonder about the idiots who thought this was a good idea.

That said, to me it was clear this plane was being escorted, not "chased", then as i it got closer I could see the pattern of af1.


There was more outrage than fear, and the return of memories painful to all of us who lived through it.



just another example of "transparency"..... :roll:
 
Last edited:
How hard would it have been to just issue a statement advising people in the surrounding area what they were going to do? Not very hard, I would imagine.

I mean damn, how out of touch are those people who arranged that, that they wouldn't even think of how it would effect that area?
 




Not hard at all. They have done it before.
 
Not hard at all. They have done it before.


Is it common for certain airplanes to get clearence to fly so low in that region? Like does this happen every so often and why?

Because to fly a plane like that for no reason other than a photo-op is ridiculous in itself.
 
Is it common for certain airplanes to get clearence to fly so low in that region? Like does this happen every so often and why?

Because to fly a plane like that for no reason other than a photo-op is ridiculous in itself.





Before 911 it was not uncommon to see planes and military aircraft buzzing up the hudson.


After, no private planes, few .mil aircraft, and like this, I think they let some plane or some aircraft do it once, and they annonced it for like a week around here before they did it.
 
I can see why they didn't announce it.

This was pretty stupid though.

They should have put photoshop in the stimulus package for the White House.
 

All the more reason for the WH to have some sensitivity here (and at least half a brain). Do they even think???
 
Exactly why would they need a photo opp like this anyways?
And of all places and style of doing so?
This is some sort of propeganda to sway some emotions....
 
Exactly why would they need a photo opp like this anyways?
And of all places and style of doing so?
This is some sort of propeganda to sway some emotions....

It was said that they were attempting to get a good picture on a clear day of Air Force One (referred to as a White House aircraft since it only becomes Air Force One when the president is on board..duh) with the Statue of Liberty in the background.

The real question to be asked is this. What ****ing idiot thought fueling and flying a 747 with fighter escorts across a very similar flight that United Airlines flight 175 took and also similar to the miraculous landing made in the Hudson last December would be easier than spending 300 bucks and using Photoshop?

A big WTF were they thinking by not just creating this 'photo op' on the computer. I could do it in 2 hours and I barely know how to use Photoshop.
 
I can see why they didn't announce it.

This was pretty stupid though.

They should have put photoshop in the stimulus package for the White House.

I heard on the news last night that the local authorities were notified beforehand but someone didn't spread the word. Mayor Bloomberg didn't even get advance notice.

It's someone in the NYC government who was at fault, not the Feds.

Reminds me of Katrina.

It wasn't FEMA who was responsible for the initial response. Someone on the local front dropped the ball.
 
All the more reason for the WH to have some sensitivity here (and at least half a brain). Do they even think???


When the Obama White House does something stupid, you won't find me defending them. This was stupid, and the moron who scheduled it should lose his job.

It doesn't matter whether it was announced or whatever, a 747 flying low over Manhattan is enough to panic people. It's making a hell of a lot of noise, flying close to stall, and its presence cannot be justified. Everyone knows 747's can't land at LaGuardia, the only airport with an approach over Manhattan.
 
Who are you and what did you do with bhkad? :shock:


.
 

White House Apologizes for Air Force Flyover - City Room Blog - NYTimes.com

All this does is to fuel the Obama Administration's belief that the Feds should have all the power they want and the effort by some to run roughshod over the locals because the states and cities are incompetent.
 
Now we're hearing that the FAA told the locals NOT to notify the public.

:doh
 




They were notified, but told that it was classified information. The feds tied the locals hand.
 
Crying over this incident is like crying over spilled milk.

But any how from my understanding this was a photo op and the image was made over the Hudson. Now why the heck would they decide to do this in morning early afternoon when the light would be better in the early evening to sunset?
 
They were notified, but told that it was classified information. The feds tied the locals hand.

Although someone in the Mayor's office dropped the ball by not notifying him.


IBID
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…