• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Low crime in El Paso predates 'wall'; smugglers are U.S. citizens

TU Curmudgeon

B.A. (Sarc), LLb. (Lex Sarcasus), PhD (Sarc.)
DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 7, 2018
Messages
68,960
Reaction score
22,530
Location
Lower Mainland of BC
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Centrist
From United Press International

Low crime in El Paso predates 'wall'; smugglers are U.S. citizens
​

EL PASO, Texas, Jan. 17 (UPI) -- The safety of El Paso, Texas, has become a standard talking point for the Trump administration in its quest to spend $5.7 billion for a wall along the border with Mexico.

"El Paso, Texas, went from one of the most unsafe parts or cities in the United States to one of the safest cities in the United States as soon as they put up the wall," Trump said last week. "They built a wall and fencing apparatus that blocked people. So they went from one of the most dangerous cities to one of the safest cities, all within a very short period of time."

El Paso does have comparatively low crime -- as do many border cities, which are prospering economically. But the dip in crime predates the "wall" and much of the drug smuggling across the border is done by U.S. citizens crossing at legal points of entry.

COMMENT:-

Do you want to know something about snapping your fingers to prevent elephant stampedes in Central Park?


You know that it works because there aren't any elephant stampedes in Central Park.
​
Right?
​
 
The mayor of El Paso disagrees... The border wall has been in El Paso since 2008 and according to him it works.

Sounds to me like the problem for El Paso isn't a lack of a border barrier/fencing because they have one.
The problem according to the Mayor of El Paso is there is a lack of holding facilities which then forces illegal aliens to be let go in El Paso. He's calling on congress to fix the broken immigration system.
Article snipped to highlight key parts of the El Paso Mayor's pov...



'We Have a Fence and It Works': El Paso Mayor Calls on Congress to Fix Immigration System
Hundreds of migrants dropped off in city this week.
 

So what problems El Paso are having aren't related to "The Wall" they are related to the other parts of the immigration system that "The Wall" isn't going to do anything to fix.

In that case, the obvious thing to do is to build "The Wall".
 
TU Curmudgeon said:
So what problems El Paso are having aren't related to "The Wall" they are related to the other parts of the immigration system that "The Wall" isn't going to do anything to fix.

In that case, the obvious thing to do is to build "The Wall".
Click to expand...

That is correct, the wall or a barrier should be built where there is none. The mayor of ElPaso stated that the wall is working!!
 
This is true in general. The reason the wall is so easy to be against is because the justifications used for it are complete garbage. Most Americans understand that hence its unpopularity.
 

Democrats do not hesitate to call their own officials liars and racists if they will not chant the party line.
 
TU Curmudgeon said:
So what problems El Paso are having aren't related to "The Wall" they are related to the other parts of the immigration system that "The Wall" isn't going to do anything to fix.

In that case, the obvious thing to do is to build "The Wall".
Click to expand...

Read the article again.
He said the wall is working.
 
MrPeanut said:
This is true in general. The reason the wall is so easy to be against is because the justifications used for it are complete garbage. Most Americans understand that hence its unpopularity.
Click to expand...
Since the government is spending a billion dollars a day on the shutdown, the Democratic Party now has thrown away the entire cost of the extra 300 miles Trump wants to add to the Pelosi-Schumer 700 mile barrier. Democrats in Congress are now burning a billion dollars a day and all the harms of the shut down not to avoid paying for the wall - but spending a billion a day not to have the border barrier after already burning the entire cost of it for absolutely nothing in return.

The shutdown is no different that if Pelosi backed up a drum truck with $1 billion in it and dumped it in a fire - every day, day after day, week after week.

Why? To prove to Latinos that the loyalty of the Democratic Party is to Mexicans, Central Americans and South Americans is so great they will burn billions of dollars and cause any harm to Americans and the USA for that loyalty.

The arguments against a border barrier are ludicrous and anyone can quote Obama, Pelosi and Schumer in the past to prove it.
 
The arguments against the wall are generally so absurd they are like jokes. Here is an analogy to the logic:

"Statistically a far greater percentage of murders and rapes are committed by people not in prison than in prison. Therefore, people in prisons are the safest of all and all should be let into society for how safe they are."

27% of federal prisoners are illegal immigrants - so therefore it is proven they commit less crimes because they aren't in prison.

Here are the actual claims:

1. A person can run across a football field carrying a 30 foot ladder and scaling a 30 foot wall up and down just as fast and sneakily as a person can just run across a football field.

2. Anyone can dig a 100 yard tunnel exactly as fast as a person could run across a football field.

Those literally are the arguments made by the Democratic Party against Trump's 300 miles of barrier they want - but none apply to the 700 miles of Pelosi-Schumer border barrier.
 

The Democrats aren't responsible for the shutdown. McConnell's subservience to Trump is the culprit. I'm not against strategically placed barriers/walls. I'm against the childlike idea of building one long stretch of wall along the border and justifying it by saying it would stop the problems that mostly occur at legal points of entry.
 
Do you have links to back up that statement?
 
Hanky said:
That is correct, the wall or a barrier should be built where there is none. The mayor of ElPaso stated that the wall is working!!
Click to expand...

Mr. Trump now says that there is no need for a wall where "natural barriers" (like the Rio Grande) already exist.
 
MrPeanut said:
Do you have links to back up that statement?
Click to expand...

Um - the analogy is IN FACT an analogy. That disposes of the "Statistically ... in prison." bit.

Whether the analogy is an accurate one is something else again.

However, I have never seen any "Democrat" actually make either of the two numbered claims.

Not only that, but "literally" means "in fact" and I have never seen any "Democrat" ACTUALLY make either of the two numbered claims.

I, too, eagerly await "joko104" providing some ACTUAL evidence that some ACTUAL "Democrat" has ACTUALLY made EITHER of the two numbered claims.

PS - I'm not holding my breath while waiting.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…