• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Johnson, Martinez, Smoltz, Biggio voted into Hall of Fame

Johnson, Matinez, Smoltz...wow, what a set of pitchers!
 
Seems to be the right choices this round.
 
Seems to be the right choices this round.

Yeah, there's really no room to complain about any of these guys. Of the four I'd say that Johnson was the strongest and Biggio the weakest but if Biggio had played in a bigger market he'd have been in 2 years ago.
 
Yeah, there's really no room to complain about any of these guys. Of the four I'd say that Johnson was the strongest and Biggio the weakest but if Biggio had played in a bigger market he'd have been in 2 years ago.

Edgar needs to go in...
 
Yeah, there's really no room to complain about any of these guys. Of the four I'd say that Johnson was the strongest and Biggio the weakest but if Biggio had played in a bigger market he'd have been in 2 years ago.

I had to look up his numbers when I saw he made it in. 3k hits, 291 HR, 414 SB, .796 OPS over 20 years, that is pretty solid consistency. I think the 3k hits clinched it, though I would have voted Trammel over him...but I am biased there, he was my childhood hero.
 
What do you think of Curt Schilling saying he didn't make the HoF because he was a conservative.
And that John Smoltz made it because he was a liberal ?

Schilling was a good pitcher. Smoltz has similar numbers but but spent several years in the bullpen too.

Personally, I think Schilling will get in within the next couple of years.
 
Schilling was a good pitcher. Smoltz has similar numbers but but spent several years in the bullpen too.

Personally, I think Schilling will get in within the next couple of years.

Smoltz is in because he is the only pitcher in history with over 200 wins and 150 saves (A 1996 NL Cy Young winner with 213 wins with 154 saves I think is the actual stat.)
 
What do you think of Curt Schilling saying he didn't make the HoF because he was a conservative
Sour grapes?
BTW Smoltz donated to Romney's campaign.:shrug:


And that John Smoltz made it because he was a liberal ?
Similar records.
Smoltz saved 150 games in addition to his accomplishments as a starter.
 
Good to see you this year.
Did you see my College wrestling post to you ?

Sour grapes?
BTW Smoltz donated to Romney's campaign.:shrug:



Similar records.
Smoltz saved 150 games in addition to his accomplishments as a starter.
 
Edgar needs to go in...

As a hitter with power and average it's hard to imagine he wouldn't be in.
Over .300 career BA and 300 HR's, 2000+ hits......
Maybe his career just wasn't long enough.
400 HR's or 3000 hits and he'd be in.
 
Good to see you this year.
Did you see my College wrestling post to you ?

Yes, I did.
I've got a Hawaii trip planned for late Feb., so I'm a little iffy.
Flights to St Louis seem reasonable and event ticket prices are manageable.
Accommodations seem ridiculously pricey.
I'll continue looking.
At this time, I'm 50/50.
 
As a hitter with power and average it's hard to imagine he wouldn't be in.
Over .300 career BA and 300 HR's, 2000+ hits......
Maybe his career just wasn't long enough.
400 HR's or 3000 hits and he'd be in.


He's in quite some company
Edgar encouraged by boost in HOF vote total | MLB.com
 
Hope for the best.....if that fat %$#@**&!! Manny Ramirez gets in and Edgar doesn't...I swear to gawd....I'll snap....



Randy Johnson endorses former Seattle Mariners teammate Edgar Martinez for Baseball Hall of Fame - ESPN

4 Mariano Rivera says Edgar Martinez was the toughest batter he ever faced
 
I think Mike Mussina should be in. But, he signed with the Yankees after the 2000 season, so **** him.

It seems like, for starting pitchers, winning at least one Cy Young Award is a prerequisite for hall of fame induction.
 
Last edited:
Now Smoltz, Glavine and Maddux are all Hall of Famers. With them the Braves had 14 consecutive playoff appearances. I still don't know why they only won one world series.

I loved watching them all pitch. And at that time the Braves also had the best announcers in the game, IMO.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…