• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Is assasination ever called for

Is assasination ever the right thing to do

  • In some cases assasination is right

    Votes: 30 83.3%
  • assasination is never right EVER

    Votes: 6 16.7%

  • Total voters
    36
 
Never justified in a democracy, where the ballot box can be used to get rid of a tyrant or despot. It may be utilized in political systems where there's no other way to get rid of a despot.
 
 
Never justified in a democracy, where the ballot box can be used to get rid of a tyrant or despot. It may be utilized in political systems where there's no other way to get rid of a despot.

Hitler was elected in a democracy.
 
 
Hitler was elected in a democracy.

So what? How many elections were held after he took office? He seized absolute power almost immediately. Holding a free election does not make a democracy. It's holding the second, third, and subsequent elections that make a democracy.
 
Hitler was elected in a democracy.

That's actually not true. He was appointed Chancellor by Hindenburg. In 1932 Hitler lost to Hindenburg.
 
By the way, I already know that antisemitic sentiments were already beginning to peak in Germany in the beginning of the 20th century, I'm just wondering how much Hitler was required to take those sentiments to the next level.
Anti-Jewish emotions are on the rise again in this country. How much will our Hitler require to begin rounding up any Jew who does not support him? Granted that will not be very many American Jews. Many appear to be self-loathing Israel haters.
 
Anti-Jewish emotions are on the rise again in this country. How much will our Hitler require to begin rounding up any Jew who does not support him? Granted that will not be very many American Jews. Many appear to be self-loathing Israel haters.

"Our Hitler?"
 
Anti-Jewish emotions are on the rise again in this country. How much will our Hitler require to begin rounding up any Jew who does not support him? Granted that will not be very many American Jews. Many appear to be self-loathing Israel haters.

People who have any criticism of the far-right-wing, anti-peace policies of the current Israeli government are not necessarily Jew haters. Netanyahu is from a political party that effectively removes peace from the table. Why should he be supported or endorsed by anyone who wants peace?
 
To do what hitler did you needed to have someone who the German people nearly worshiped as a savior. Hitler had that very rare ability to mesmerize a crowd and ultimately a country. People like that are few and far between
And he did it all without a teleprompter.
 
So what? How many elections were held after he took office? He seized absolute power almost immediately. Holding a free election does not make a democracy. It's holding the second, third, and subsequent elections that make a democracy.

Exactly my point, a tyrant worth assassinating can rise to power through a democracy
 
Exactly my point, a tyrant worth assassinating can rise to power through a democracy

Neither the Nazis nor Hitler were elected democratically. That they were is a myth.
 
That's actually not true. He was appointed Chancellor by Hindenburg. In 1932 Hitler lost to Hindenburg.
Right, but whether he elected (as many think) or appointed, that aspect is so misunderstood and so overplayed. Hitler gaining power through legitimate avenues was not his first choice, it was merely a calculated means to an end.
 
I will research that.

Good, you'll find that they lost the initial election in 1932, but "won" after the Reichstag fire when most of the opposition were outlawed and barred from the elections. It would be like if a Republican won the Presidency after successfully outlawing all left-leaning parties. Nobody would argue that the result was the outcome of a democratic election.
 
Right, but whether he elected (as many think) or appointed, that aspect is so misunderstood and so overplayed. Hitler gaining power through legitimate avenues was not his first choice, it was merely a calculated means to an end.

There was nothing kosher about Hitler's rise to power.
 
First impeachment. Then conviction and removal from office. Then arrest him for treason, for waging war openly and brazenly against the American citizen, the nation and the Constitution. Once convicted seek the death penalty in the punishment phase.

He will still be a martyr to the left even if he spends the rest of his life in prison. When a leader voids the Constitution that leader must be dealt with, legally, not by murdering him.

JFK was not a very good president. Being murdered in office was the best thing for his legacy that could have ever happened to him. At least two generations believed the Camelot myths. Imagine the Hope and Change myths that would grow around our first really Red president were he to be murdered in office. No thanks.
 
First impeachment. Then conviction and removal from office. Then arrest him for treason, for waging war openly and brazenly against the American citizen, the nation and the Constitution. Once convicted seek the death penalty in the punishment phase.

Hoooooookay. [backs away slowly and carefully]
 
I meant that there were no "legitimate avenues" to his rise to power.
He used the electoral process to gain seats/power in the Reichstag, and eventually to set himself in a position to be appointed. His underlying tactics in gaining popularity to secure votes were often criminal, but using the electoral process in and of itself was legit.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…