• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

In your opinion: How do indigenous people of North America re-act when they hear that they are very popular in Germany

How do indigenous people of America re-act when they hear that they are very popular in Germany?

  • they are absolutely furious

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • they are very sad and weep bitterly

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • they are deeply offended

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • they are very much insulted

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • they are pleased to hear it

    Votes: 2 18.2%
  • they like to hear it

    Votes: 3 27.3%
  • they couldn't care less

    Votes: 9 81.8%
  • they do not know about it

    Votes: 5 45.5%
  • they think: another proof that all those German children are all racist and Nazis

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    11

Rumpelstil

DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 10, 2019
Messages
43,294
Reaction score
9,385
Location
Schwarzwald = Black Forest
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Other
In your opinion: How do indigenous people of North America re-act when they hear that they are very popular in Germany and that young German children like to dress up as "Indians and Cowboys" - as those children still usually say?
 
Last edited:
A word of warning!:
This poll is partly ironic!


they are absolutely furious
they are very sad and weep bitterly
they are deeply offended
they are very much insulted

These are the words of woke and politically correct German adults when they talk to still un-woke and politically in-correct German children about this topic.
 
It is all the fault of a certain Karl May - not to be confused with Karl Marx.
Karl May is from Saxony - Karl Marx is from Trier on the River Mosel.

The northern German town of Bad Segeberg is renowned for two things: a vast cave visited each winter by twenty-two thousand bats, and an annual Karl May Festival visited each summer by three hundred thousand people. Karl May (pronounced “my”) is an adventure writer from the late nineteenth century whom most Americans have never heard of but whose stories of the American West are to this day better known to Germans than the works of Thomas Mann. His books have sold more than a hundred million copies. Though May never visited the American West, he told everyone that he had, and he wore a necklace of bear teeth, as if in proof. All his life, he was a confabulator, even when it was of no benefit to him.

May’s most beloved characters are a noble Apache leader named Winnetou and his blood brother, Old Shatterhand, a German immigrant to the United States. The good friends feature in fifteen of May’s eighty-odd works and are central in a series of films from the nineteen-sixties which were so successful that they are said, with only some exaggeration, to have saved the West German film industry. Most Germans can hum the theme music. In 2002, in a copyright case before the German Federal High Court, it was held that Winnetou was no longer a mere character in a novel; he had become “the name for a certain human type, that of the noble Indian chief.”

 
More about Karl May:

Karl Friedrich May (/maɪ/ MY, German: [kaʁl ˈmaɪ] (listen); 25 February 1842 – 30 March 1912) was a German author. He is best known for his 19th century novels of fictitious travels and adventures, set in the American Old West with Winnetou and Old Shatterhand as main protagonists and in the Orient and Middle East with fictional characters Kara Ben Nemsi and Hadschi Halef Omar.

May also wrote novels set in Latin America, China and Germany, poetry, a play, and composed music; he was a proficient player of several musical instruments. Many of his works were adapted for film, theatre, audio dramas and comics. Later in his career, May turned to philosophical and spiritual genres. He is one of the best-selling German writers of all time, with about 200,000,000 copies sold worldwide.

 
I really wonder how indigenous people of North America would re-act if they ever heard that they are very popular in Germany and that young German children like to dress up as "Indians and Cowboys".

Woke Germans tell us un-woke Germans that all this is deeply racist - once gain.
For them nearly everything on Earth and everybody on Earth is deeply racist - with the exception of those noble woke Germans. :cool:
 
I really wonder how indigenous people of North America would re-act if they ever heard that they are very popular in Germany and that young German children like to dress up as "Indians and Cowboys".

Woke Germans tell us un-woke Germans that all this is deeply racist - once gain.
For them nearly everything on Earth and everybody on Earth is deeply racist - with the exception of those noble woke Germans. :cool:
You clearly do not wonder strongly enough to reach out to the numerous special interest organizations that could provide you with an answer.
 
What kind of firewater do they have interest in?

German kids are engaging in cultural appropriation!
 
In your opinion: How do indigenous people of North America re-act when they hear that they are very popular in Germany and that young German children like to dress up as "Indians and Cowboys" - as those children still usually say?
Fasching? I guess native Americans react the same way as real cowboys or real princesses. When I was over there even some little princesses were armed.
 
Last edited:
What do you mean by Flasching?

Flashing?

Or is it a typo for Fasching = Fasnacht, Karneval, Carnival etc etc?
Yeah. I just saw it and edited. Fasching, like Halloween when the kids get dressed up
 
Fasching, like Halloween when the kids get dressed up
That's right!
"Indianer und Cowboy" is a very popular disguise for children in Germany - during Fasching and also during the rest of the year.
But over-woke and over-stupid and over-fanatical Germans think in their very small and very narrow brains that this is very racist und very wrong.
 
Fasching? I guess native Americans react the same way as real cowboys or real princesses. When I was over there even some little princesses were armed.
And how were they armed? Little recolvers with blank cartriges I guess - just for the fun of the noise, I think? :)
 
And how were they armed? Little recolvers with blank cartriges I guess - just for the fun of the noise, I think? :)
The one I remember was armed to the teeth. She had a pink princess dress and a gun belt with two pistols and a rifle. And of course a crown.
 
Btw: This year the Carnival high season in Germany will start on Thursday, 16th of February 2023.
Then one can probably see many little children dressed up as "Indianer & Cowboy" again - and read politically correct comments in newspapers from adult and woke Germans, who are horrified because of it.
 
The one I remember was armed to the teeth. She had a pink princess dress and a gun belt with two pistols and a rifle. And of course a crown.
Yes, that's Carnival in Cologne - or Fasching in Munich - or Fasnacht in the Black Forest - and elsewhere. :)
 
Here is just one example:
For hundreds of years, the streets of Erfurt have been filled with children in elaborate costume as the city celebrates its annual carnival. But for some, the party is now over.

The Campus Kinderland kindergarten has banned its charges from wearing fancy dress over concerns they could be “insulting” to minorities or cause “fear” among other children

Its decision means that on Rose Monday and Shrove Tuesday, the high point of Germany’s one-week carnival season next month when millions of children dress up as cowboys and Indians, pirates or princesses, there will be no festivities in the kindergarten.

Campus Kinderland said its teaching concept was aimed at avoiding stereotypes. “We attach importance to not insulting population groups or giving children false images,” it said in

 
I think you'd get a whole range of reactions.
 
In your opinion: How do indigenous people of North America re-act when they hear that they are very popular in Germany and that young German children like to dress up as "Indians and Cowboys" - as those children still usually say?
They should take a lesson from the maori when someone trespasses on their taonga.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/kahu/mao...and-is-selling-it/XLAJOK6IJG6ZENL56677O2TPZA/
Well-known Māori advocate Rangi McLean is taking legal action against a German artist over the unauthorised use of his tā moko image.
 
I'm guessing most native Americans aren't aware they're very popular with German children. I wasn't until this poll. I'm guessing most who are aware of it probably couldn't care less.
 
Back
Top Bottom