• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

I Had to Respond to an EMail

Do you think what they're doing is in line with anything remotely related to project management?

I have, and am certified in Agile. Please lay out for me how sending a list of five things people accomplished during the week is either effective project/productivity management when it is a random list of things being sent to someone who these people do not report to nor has a clue of the value of what they're likely to report on. I'd like to know how this action is more effective than getting productivity reports and department project overviews from management as well as an explanation of their methodologies in tracking productivity.

Here's where it gets interesting, and I'm glad you mentioned "punishment", because it will be a perfect segue in a second. I do want to address this "accountability" thing though. I'll assume you've worked in the private sector, and if so, hopefully at a large corporation. This way you can explain to those who haven't, the value of a company CEO receiving a list of 5 accomplishments from people in departments the CEO has little insight into their daily operations. Do you think he can glean the value of said work and their productivity using this method?

I eagerly await your explanation.


Now, back to the "punishment" piece. I'm sure you know who Russel Vought is and his current role. How is he relevant? Well, he's the architect of Project 2025 and has a real bone to pick with government agencies, who he largely wants to dismantle. What Musk's request is doing is carrying out this strategy Vought laid out for how to deal with government workers:

That's what this "5 things you accomplished" is really about.
 
Last edited:
I've mostly worked at medium/small-sized firms. As for the benefit of sending someone a list of tasks you performed, I think you're missing the point. If I had to, I would just copy and paste tasks I performed yesterday. In fact, I'd have more than 5 in just one day, never mind a week.
 
I'm actually trying to get you to explain the point of this exercise and its viability. This, of course, in the intended purpose Musk described.
 
If you had to report your activities by the minute it was either because your boss was a micromanager or they felt you needed to be micromanaged.
Nah, it's not uncommon if you work contracts, especially government contracts. How else to know who's paying you?
 
If you had to report your activities by the minute it was either because your boss was a micromanager or they felt you needed to be micromanaged.
Well, technically, he could have worked as a consultant. (For example, a tax auditor bills for every minute they spend on a client. At least in Sweden.)
 
I'm actually trying to get you to explain the point of this exercise and its viability. This, of course, in the intended purpose Musk described.
Looks like the point is to expose useless, arrogant pricks on the government payroll.
 
You obviously don't know why he sent out that email...even though he has told everyone why.

shrug...

Regarding your bullet comments...if you get fired, you'll know why.
 
Yeah, there are only two desk jobs that require that level of documentation:
When you say "that level of documentation" does that include the five bullet points?
1. The work done is billable to a client so documentation is needed.
Well no, there are not only two reasons. If you seriously believe this then you really don't know what you are talking about.
2. The employee in question is a very low performer, on a performance improvement plan.
Sounds like you speak of this with first hand knowledge.
 
Ha! Let us know if they respond.
 
I had to do that when managing a parts supply room for a textile mill in my early 20s. Then I got a professional job and never had to do that sort of thing again.

However I did work as a consultant for a while and had to do something similar to total up billing hours.
 
Why do so many people apparently find it "demeaning" to report on what they did?
They already report what they did - to their bosses. Not to some un-elected foreigner who, by his own power-mad public performances, is using a chainsaw instead of a scalpel.
Pretty much every desk job I've ever had I've had to report on every minute I was at work. 30 minutes doing this, 1.5 hours doing that, etc... I've only ever worked in the private sector.
It's no different. These people all have supervisors who already account for what they did. Just like in the private sector, their performance is already monitored and evaluated.
 

I think that was an excellent reply. First you responded so they know you read their email. Second, you gave it the degree of respect due.

In the future, however, you might think about signing off with "Respectfully Yours".
 
Last edited:

You must have worked in a screwed-up office environment. I worked 10 years for private employers and 20 years for public and the only time we were treated with such disrespect was when our bosses didn't have a clue as to what they were supposed to be doing. Insecure managers and immature bosses who are unqualified to be supervisors often think this is 'management'.

The most annoying part is having to take time to answer such crap when you are already swamped with work - anyone with an extra half hour or more to seriously answer that crap are probably the ones doing the least work.
 
Makes you wonder.....


.....how long before maga leader requires all citizens to prove they're worth keeping.

 
Last edited:
Why didn't you quit rather than putting up with being demanded like that? Where is your self respect?
 
Do you think the gov should employ goldbricks?
 
That was before Trump/Elon decided to shit on people (including Trump voters) and ruin the economy.

So good luck.
So far they appear to be strengthening the economy. They are expanding the private sector workforce and shrinking the public sector simultaneously. That is economically healthy.
 
MAGA thinks government workers are accountable to Musk. MAGA and accountability in the same sentence require metric tonnes of cognitive dissonance. I'm a little short, sorry.

This has nothing to do with accountability. It's about Musk.
This is right on target. Musk has no business asking anybody anything. He has no status legally and could never obtain any because he has huge government contracts and having any governmental power would be an enormous conflict of interest. These are questions from Musk-the-South-African-Nazi-Ingrate-Abusing-The US-Government.
 
MAGA thinks government workers are accountable to Musk. MAGA and accountability in the same sentence require metric tonnes of cognitive dissonance. I'm a little short, sorry.

This has nothing to do with accountability. It's about Musk.
To be honestly I think a lot of it is about reorganizing the gov to run more efficently. Musk is tasked with looking at ways to get the gov to do more with less.
 
So far they appear to be strengthening the economy. They are expanding the private sector workforce and shrinking the public sector simultaneously. That is economically healthy.
Biden left the economy in great shape. Now jobs are becoming more scarce and prices are rising.
 
To be honestly I think a lot of it is about reorganizing the gov to run more efficently. Musk is tasked with looking at ways to get the gov to do more with less.
Nobody gave Musk any power. Trump needs him to pay off his debts so he is giving him power he has no right to.
 
Last edited: