• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

I am kind of Muslim and kind of Southern Baptist

I grew up going to Church and Mosque. I am reverted and saved. Should I go Jew just to cover all my bases, or is this impossible to do and still go to heaven?

If I believed you I would be very intrigued. Do you care to convince us that you were immersed in Baptist culture? Do you care to convince us that you were immersed in Islamic culture? At present I believe neither but that could be because it seems so unlikely. If you elaborated with details then it might be more convincing thus more intriguing.
 
Except for the Jesus part, there really is not all that much difference between a Muslim and a Southern Baptist.

I think it might depend on the sect.

Sunni Islam is very close to Southern Baptist concept wise : Priesthood of all believers, no hierarchy, highest authority is the leader of the local church or mosque, one can learn the faith simply by reading the Bible or Koran etc.

Meanwhile Shia Islam might be closer to Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy (Ecclesiastical hierarchy, not all believers are priests, Bible or Koran must taught and transmitted through recognized teaching authorities and tradition).
 
Last edited:
Except for the Jesus part, there really is not all that much difference between a Muslim and a Southern Baptist.

I'd actually have to disagree. The theological differences are pretty extraordinary, especially when it comes to the exaltation of a set of biblical laws.
 
I think it might depend on the sect.

Sunni Islam is very close to Southern Baptist concept wise : Priesthood of all believers, no hierarchy, highest authority is the leader of the local church or mosque, one can learn the faith simply by reading the Bible or Koran etc.

Meanwhile Shia Islam might be closer to Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy (Ecclesiastical hierarchy, not all believers are priests, Bible or Koran must taught and transmitted through recognized teaching authorities and tradition).

But I think that's only looking at it organizationally. Fundamentally, I think Sunni Islam looks more like Orthodox Judaism than it does Southern Baptism, with many of the same differences.
 
I'd actually have to disagree. The theological differences are pretty extraordinary, especially when it comes to the exaltation of a set of biblical laws.

Not when viewed from the secular seat where I'm sitting.
 
But I think that's only looking at it organizationally. Fundamentally, I think Sunni Islam looks more like Orthodox Judaism than it does Southern Baptism, with many of the same differences.

The organizational matters reflect much deeper spiritual similarities. Please consider the following simplified discussion:

Me: I want to become a believer.

Sunni Islam: Pick up a Koran read it, and do what it says. Classes are preferred, but they are really optional.
Southern Baptist: Great, get a bible, read it, and do what it says. Of course, we have classes for new believers. But... they are optional in the end.
Orthodox Judaism: Real Judaism must, absolutely must, be taught through a teacher.

Me: Ok, I have done that. Do I need to study anything while being a believer?

Sunni Islam: No, not really, the other things such as the Hadith are optional. Koran is all you really need.
Southern Baptist: Just the Bible. Some may read the writings of the early church fathers, but you don't need to
Orthodox Judaism: Judaism must be practiced using both scripture and the collective wisdom of the Jewish teachers.

Me: If I have questions, what should I do?

Sunni: If you want , you can talk to an Imam- but you don't need to. Just read the Koran. Its self explanatory to a genuine believer.
Baptist: Well, I am a pastor. I can answer questions. But, using me is optional. Read the Bible. God will reveal it ti you. Its all you really need.
Orthodox Judaism: You will have questions. And no, you cannot just read the Torah and figure it out. You must be taught by a Rabbi or other authorized teacher.
 
Last edited:
I grew up going to Church and Mosque. I am reverted and saved. Should I go Jew just to cover all my bases, or is this impossible to do and still go to heaven?
You'd need to go long ways beyond just those three to cover ALL bases.

The only group you needn't bother paying attention to is that of atheism. If offers no rewards for joining up whatsoever.;)
 
I have met several Jews who were very nice people. I can't say the same about Southern Baptists.

My 2nd ex was one....quite a shock after my 1st, who was atheist. So much so that I made damned sure to go back to finding me an atheist for the 3rd.
 
Back
Top Bottom