• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

hold the champagne

Good4Nothin

DP Veteran
Joined
Nov 24, 2018
Messages
13,230
Reaction score
2,912
Gender
Female
Political Leaning
Slightly Conservative
Before you break out the New Year's champagne to celebrate the miracle vaccines and the end of the pandemic -- according to this interview with Pfizer VP, they don't even know if their vaccine will prevent infection or transmission. So it's "highly effective" at what?? How will the vaccine create herd immunity if it doesn't prevent infection or transmission?

Dormitzer: So the answer is we don't yet know if it prevents infection and will prevent spread.

 
Before you break out the New Year's champagne to celebrate the miracle vaccines and the end of the pandemic -- according to this interview with Pfizer VP, they don't even know if their vaccine will prevent infection or transmission. So it's "highly effective" at what?? How will the vaccine create herd immunity if it doesn't prevent infection or transmission?



"So we don't have the direct evidence in people yet". Neither did those who developed the smallpox vaccine at first, and yet that hideous disease has been totally eradicated through vaccination.
 
Last edited:
"So we don't have the direct evidence in people yet". Neither did those who developed the smallpox vaccine at first, and yet that hideous disease has been totally eradicated through vaccination.

The smallpox vaccine will forever make you think any vaccine must be safe and effective.

Even if the vice president of Pfizer says they don't know if it prevents infection or transmission, you won't believe him. No, this vaccine must be exactly like the smallpox vaccine.
 
The smallpox vaccine will forever make you think any vaccine must be safe and effective.

Even if the vice president of Pfizer says they don't know if it prevents infection or transmission, you won't believe him. No, this vaccine must be exactly like the smallpox vaccine.
Unlike you I don't live in fear.
 
Before you break out the New Year's champagne to celebrate the miracle vaccines and the end of the pandemic -- according to this interview with Pfizer VP, they don't even know if their vaccine will prevent infection or transmission. So it's "highly effective" at what?? How will the vaccine create herd immunity if it doesn't prevent infection or transmission?




People in his position (vp of science based pharmaceutical company) must choose their words very carefully. I think its true that they don't yet know, but its looking like this is a game changer. Once data from the population starts flowing in over the course of weeks to months, I'm hoping to hear more confident statements from vaccine manufacturers.
 
Unlike you I don't live in fear.

No I don't "live in fear." But on the other hand, I don't drink poison, or stand in the middle of the highway during rush hour, or jump off bridges.
 
People in his position (vp of science based pharmaceutical company) must choose their words very carefully. I think its true that they don't yet know, but its looking like this is a game changer. Once data from the population starts flowing in over the course of weeks to months, I'm hoping to hear more confident statements from vaccine manufacturers.

It's all about wishful thinking and rising stock prices.

The pandemic will end naturally, but they will have the world convinced they need mRNA covid vaccines twice a year.

When the cancer rate rises from 40% to 60%, no one will blame it on the vaccine.
 
No I don't "live in fear." But on the other hand, I don't drink poison, or stand in the middle of the highway during rush hour, or jump off bridges.
So you're imagining that a vaccine is somehow toxic for you. I wonder how many of the tens of thousands of trial volunteers feel the same way. Has anyone died or fallen seriously ill after Covid vaccination? If so, how many?
 
It's all about wishful thinking and rising stock prices.

The pandemic will end naturally, but they will have the world convinced they need mRNA covid vaccines twice a year.

When the cancer rate rises from 40% to 60%, no one will blame it on the vaccine.
Why do you think people take the seasonal flu vaccine every year? And what's this crap about cancer rates; something you found on some lunatic's conspiracy website?
 
Before you break out the New Year's champagne to celebrate the miracle vaccines and the end of the pandemic -- according to this interview with Pfizer VP, they don't even know if their vaccine will prevent infection or transmission. So it's "highly effective" at what?? How will the vaccine create herd immunity if it doesn't prevent infection or transmission?




If it doesn’t prevent infection then why claim it’s roughly 95% effective?
I understand that it’s not known yet if the vaccines prevent colonization.
I will tell you this: out of about 30000 people enrolled in the vaccine arms of the studies I think only one person developed severe disease. Most people can handle a cough and sore throat for a few days, but no one wants to end up in the hospital.
Also, while there have been several reports of allergic reactions to the vaccines all people who had them recovered quickly. There will be others.
As for long term side effects Dr Fauci said its “unheard of” for vaccines to have unknown side effects that develop months to years later. I think he is a pretty smart guy. Generally I believe him until he gives me a reason not to.
Make no mistake: these vaccines are a game changer. People just have to be convinced to accept them. Vaccines not administered won’t work.
As time goes on the vaccines will improve too.
 
So you're imagining that a vaccine is somehow toxic for you. I wonder how many of the tens of thousands of trial volunteers feel the same way. Has anyone died or fallen seriously ill after Covid vaccination? If so, how many?

There has been no longterm testing. The vaccine makers admit that the longterm effects are NOT KNOWN.
 
Why do you think people take the seasonal flu vaccine every year? And what's this crap about cancer rates; something you found on some lunatic's conspiracy website?

The flu vaccine is not mRNA.
 
If it doesn’t prevent infection then why claim it’s roughly 95% effective?
I understand that it’s not known yet if the vaccines prevent colonization.
I will tell you this: out of about 30000 people enrolled in the vaccine arms of the studies I think only one person developed severe disease. Most people can handle a cough and sore throat for a few days, but no one wants to end up in the hospital.
Also, while there have been several reports of allergic reactions to the vaccines all people who had them recovered quickly. There will be others.
As for long term side effects Dr Fauci said its “unheard of” for vaccines to have unknown side effects that develop months to years later. I think he is a pretty smart guy. Generally I believe him until he gives me a reason not to.
Make no mistake: these vaccines are a game changer. People just have to be convinced to accept them. Vaccines not administered won’t work.
As time goes on the vaccines will improve too.

Fauci has no idea if mRNA vaccines might have longterm side effects. Why are mainstream experts saying the longterm effects of this new experimental vaccine technology are UNKNOWN?

And when they said the vaccine is effective, they meant it lessens symptoms. They do not know if it prevents infection.
 
Ridiculous. Trials have been in progress since March. How long would you prefer trials should be extended for?

Testing on large numbers of human subjects started recently.
 
Fauci has no idea if mRNA vaccines might have longterm side effects. Why are mainstream experts saying the longterm effects of this new experimental vaccine technology are UNKNOWN?

And when they said the vaccine is effective, they meant it lessens symptoms. They do not know if it prevents infection.
They know it prevents infection
 
Testing on large numbers of human subjects started recently.
No, it did not. Volunteers were being tested since April in Britain. Tens of thousand of them. Over 100,000 volunteers, globally, have taken part.
 
I don' t know if there is a chance the vaccine may harm me down the road but what I do know is that Covid would could likely kill me. I have had enough of this , the only way out without blowing up the healthcare system and ending the economic devastation is a vaccine. I' m in..... the risk reward ratio works for me.
 
I don' t know if there is a chance the vaccine may harm me down the road but what I do know is that Covid would could likely kill me. I have had enough of this , the only way out without blowing up the healthcare system and ending the economic devastation is a vaccine. I' m in..... the risk reward ratio works for me.

COVID is NOT likely to kill you! You are caught up in the hysteria.
 
Fauci has no idea if mRNA vaccines might have longterm side effects. Why are mainstream experts saying the longterm effects of this new experimental vaccine technology are UNKNOWN?

And when they said the vaccine is effective, they meant it lessens symptoms. They do not know if it prevents infection.

I see what you are saying. I haven’t reviewed the data in enough detail to see if they did pcr tests regularly to document infection. I will say this though: if I get this vaccine and because of it I don’t get sick from Covid then I really don’t care what my pcr test shows.
The bottom line is that I remain well BECAUSE I was vaccinated. At least it greatly increases my odds of staying well.
The chance of long term side effects is likely tiny according to the country’s top ID doc. He is the expert I would listen to here.
If you choose not to be vaccinated no one will hold you down and make you take it. But there will likely be consequences for making that decision down the road, as we have discussed
 
there’s no evidence currently that mRNA vaccines cause autoimmune disease or make it worse, says Betty Diamond, an immunologist and rheumatologist at the Feinstein Institutes for Medical Research of Northwell Health. “At the moment there’s every reason to suggest that people with autoimmune diseases ought to get either of these vaccines when they get rolled out.”


No evidence "CURRENTLY." Well why worry about the future, all that counts is now. "AT THE MOMENT" you can just go ahead and get the vaccine, because they DO NOT KNOW if it might cause autoimmune diseases in the future.

Don't worry, be happy.
 
COVID is NOT likely to kill you! You are caught up in the hysteria.

Depends on the age and other factors of that poster.
Even if Covid doesn’t kill you it can certainly make your life miserable. Its a multi organ system disease, affecting the heart, the brain etc. You may be sick for weeks or longer. You are wrong to minimize this disease: its very serious.
 
I see what you are saying. I haven’t reviewed the data in enough detail to see if they did pcr tests regularly to document infection. I will say this though: if I get this vaccine and because of it I don’t get sick from Covid then I really don’t care what my pcr test shows.
The bottom line is that I remain well BECAUSE I was vaccinated. At least it greatly increases my odds of staying well.
The chance of long term side effects is likely tiny according to the country’s top ID doc. He is the expert I would listen to here.
If you choose not to be vaccinated no one will hold you down and make you take it. But there will likely be consequences for making that decision down the road, as we have discussed

Fauci wants you to the the chance of long term side effects is tiny. He DOES NOT KNOW. No one knows. But if he pretends to know, millions will believe him.
 
Back
Top Bottom