• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

GOP States Sending Troops to DC: How Their Cities' Crime Rates Compare

I agree. But Trump is rapidly approaching ignoring many constitutional norms and laws. When we reach that point, why would we expect the government to obey the constitution? If they really want to stop the violent crime, get the guns away from the criminals and stop the sale of them.
But we both know the country is too divided on gun regulation for that to be a viable solution any time soon. To call for that now is, IMO, an empty gesture.

I would prefer we massively increase the size of urban police forces rather than use the NG, but I don't think that's going to happen, either. The same people running our cities today were the same folks who just a few years ago openly declared the police as being the problem and called for their defunding.

There's also the other harsh reality that will come from significantly increasing law enforcement in US cities: a disproportionate increase in the number of young, black men arrested, tried, and sent to prison. The political left will inevitably see that outcome not as a consequence of who's committing crime but as the result of an institutionally racist justice system. This will be their argument against more law enforcement.

Meanwhile, our cities keep stacking murder victims like cord wood.
 
Why not just go the whole hog and turn the capital into a full-on police state and have a curfew and shoot anyone out after that time?
Surely, any extreme action is justified in this time of terror where people can't walk the streets without being mugged and murdered and that's on a good day.
But, there's a new armed gang terrorizing the residents of DC. They even wear paramilitary gear and go by the acronym "ICE". They are known for accosting the public in masks, armed violent assaults, kidnapping and other thuggish behavior. Despite numerous videos documenting this behavior, the regime has refused to take any action to address it.
 
Yes, that happens so often here its a wonder any tradespeople get any work done.
I see that you actually don’t address the issue. But hey, at least you are a semi-safe serf.
 
I see that you actually don’t address the issue. But hey, at least you are a semi-safe serf.

Yes, one person got arrested its a shame but hardly a commentary on the state of Britain.
 



Tennessee:
At least two Tennessee cities had higher rates of violent and property crime than Washington, D.C., last year. Memphis reported 15,338 violent crimes last year, including 249 cases of murder and non-negligent manslaughter, according to the FBI's Crime Data Explorer. The city also recorded 42,305 property crimes. The Metropolitan Nashville Police Department reported 7,857 violent crimes in 2024, more than Washington, D.C., but recorded fewer murders, with 102. Nashville also logged 31,521 property crimes, a higher total than the nation's capital.

Louisiana:
New Orleans recorded 2,543 crimes against people last year, including 124 murders as well as hundreds of assaults, rapes and robberies. Police also logged 14,079 property crimes, such as burglaries and thefts, for a total of 16,622 crimes in 2024 compared with 22,376 in 2023. In Shreveport, one of Louisiana's northern cities with higher crime rates, police recorded 2,151 violent crimes in 2024, including 47 murders, according to the FBI's Crime Data Explorer. The city also reported nearly 7,000 property crimes.

South Carolina:
Columbia, South Carolina's capital, has the largest reported violent crime in the state, with 1,113 reported last year, 14 of which were murders. The city saw 4,673 property crimes, according to the FBI's Crime Explorer Data.

Mississippi:
While the FBI Crime Explorer Data did not have information on Jackson, in 2024, the local police reported 111 homicides.

Seems to me these Republican Governors should concentrate on reducing violent crime within their own state jurisdictions.

A novel idea..... Trump should take the federal money he is wasting on having the military patrol Washington D.C. and use those taxpayer funds to hire more D.C. Metropolitan police officers. Military troops do not receive training in policing.
How many of those cities are governed by democrats? The color of the state doesn't matter much, it's the leadership and the policing done in the city that matters. Memphis and Nashville are run by democrats, New Oleans is run by democrats. Jackson MS is run by democrats. Jackson, Memphis, Shreveport,New Orleans, also have a majority black population which tends to voted democrats for city leadership positions. It's the makeup of the city more than the state when it comes to individual cities and crime and how the city government react.
 
It is 100% a commentary on Britain. Folks there are so scared, that they want to ban pointed kitchen knives.


Yes, it's being considered.
Many things are being considered that doesn't mean they are certain to change the law.
I have no objection to points on knives being banned or not.

If they do ban it how could it possibly be detrimental to me?
 
I posted this in another, related thread, but I think it's worth posting here, too. There's a problem with comparing city murder rates as not all cities have the same economic demographics. Chicago has more higher income neighborhoods than, say, Memphis, and since violent crime is lower in such areas, it lowers Chicago's overall murder rate.

From an AI search on the highest murder rates by city neighborhood, there's this:

1755959979019.webp



IMO, I think extreme action in any of these neighborhoods should be considered, provided, of course, that action is itself legal. But for the life of me I can't understand why anyone is satisfied with the status quo.
There's no excuse for not being in favor of cleaning up our American cities, whether red or blue. The left has a bad habit of denying they have a crime problem in blue cites. They are always claiming the crime rate is falling. So why hasn't it gone away after all the years of declining crime? We all know why, they fudge the numbers in a variety of ways. Plea bargains, liberal prosecutors who either don't charge some crime or charge more violent crimes as lesser offenses. The cities in America with the most crime are mostly blue. Doesn't matter the state they are in because it is the city government that determines the law and order in the city. The other problem is economic opportunity and cities where the demographics show a high percentage of black citizens tend to have a higher poverty, higher crime and significant gang violence. Those things are not good for business. Not for the ones already there and not for attracting new businesses that provide more opportunities. These are the factors that blue cities don't seem able to rectify. Making the cities safe for the law abiding people that live there, black, white, brown of whatever should be job one for city leaders. The current presence in D.C. of national guard troops has allowed more city law enforcement to concentrate on crime, serious crime and the results have been dramatically lower crime as more arrest have been made over the last week of so. Instead of embracing the lower crime, the democrats are making ridiculous accusations of their favorite claims, fascism, threats to democracy, taking away people rights.
At some point the troops will leave and the city cops will be left to continue the work. Will the city officials continue to give them the support they have been getting lately? Or will D.C. return to the soft on crime stance that allowed things to get so out of control? Remember, keeping the people of the city safe is the most important job officials have. Democrats promises seem to fall short on delivery. Give them your vote they say and they'll fix the rest, but, they don't get it done.
 
Back
Top Bottom