- Joined
- Oct 22, 2012
- Messages
- 32,516
- Reaction score
- 5,321
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Libertarian - Right
If you wanted to, yes, farming would be accessible to all though, one wouldn't hoard food for themselves, unless their already is a massive surplus. You wouldn't have private ownership of land that can be used to benefit others, but you need to understand you would be able to hunt, fish..
There is nothing to enforce, it is a stateless society with collective ownership of production, things like farms, factories, lakes.. You seem to like guns alot, as do I, have quite a few myself, people would be able to "enforce" the idea of not killing others, stealing other's PROPERTY, apart from the means of production.. Again, communism is when the workers, the people, live in a society without any state leadership.
Horsecrap
socialism is the plaint of failures or the greedy who wish to gain power by pandering to them
prove your point....here!
Socialism is a social and economic system characterised by social ownership of the means of production and co-operative management of the economy, as well as a political theory and movement that aims at the establishment of such a system.
oh?...then what is your enforcement to stop me from hording?....holding land?
Monopoly - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
They would exist without the state, capitalism at it's core relies on everything I've said above, you've already admitted this.
what do capitalist do without regulation?... and when have we ever seen a time of no regulation?
and really... durign this alleged time of no regulation.. .why did we not revert back to feudalism like you say we would?
No, it really wouldn't. Without the ability to control the sale of competing products there is no way to build an empire.
First I don't buy the argument that an industry gets special treatment because they can afford a lobbyist? That's a straw-man.
Again I don't buy the argument that an industry gets special treatment because they can afford a lobbyist? That's a straw-man.
I totally agree, no different than Obama investing in solar and the like. But I have no problem with protest, million man marches, lobbyist etc etc trying to speak out for their special interest. That is their right. I understand from your comments you want to ban these groups from speaking out on their behalf. Further these groups are not the power of government and some are well financed and some are not and they can be on the different side of an issue.
This is no different than you wanting to protect the constitution against others wanting to ignore it. Thus you have two lobbyist groups, one trying to insure it and the other trying to ignore it. We also have a third branch of government called the judicial.
if communism has no state, then how are the people secure?
how does communism "enforce itself" if it has no state.
First of all, why would you want to own a farm for yourself if no profit motive exists, when you can collectively share and work together with others?
Its about achieving a reasonable balance of power.
posting two links about people does not prove anything...........how did socialism build factories?
..and that is where the academic theory of Communism runs headlong into the massive brick wall labeled "reality".
You would control the sale by lowering prices to where competitor's can't compete, many other ways.
he is saying its collective society , but even that kind of society has to have some kind of enforcement
You're right, we need to drastically cut back on military spending. :applaud
Who do you think actually built the factories? The capitalist who sits back and watches laborers work all day? I'm not talking about socialism, I'm giving a reason as to why socialism is justified for the workers.
Yes, the people, I don't think people would like if you tried to take 50 acres of land for yourself and not share the resources with anyone else..
That involves having an advantage from the start that largely exist from that protection that I spoke of.
Yes, the people, I don't think people would like if you tried to take 50 acres of land for yourself and not share the resources with anyone else..
you post socialism built factories, and when i asked for you to prove it, you post two people bio's.
it can clearly be seen you have nothing to back up what you are posting.
then what is you enforcement?
People who don't want you to take all that land for yourself, much like police officers who stop crimes today, just think of other human beings not in uniform.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?