• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

CHILDREN TO “TRANSITION” GENDER IDENTITY AND DECEIVING PARENTS

Renae

Banned
Suspended
DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 26, 2007
Messages
50,241
Reaction score
19,244
Location
San Antonio Texas
Gender
Female
Political Leaning
Conservative
Eau-Claire2.webp
We understand and acknowledge that teachers are often put in terrible positions caught between parents and their students. But much like we wouldn’t act as stand-ins for abuse in other circumstances, we cannot let parents’ rejection of their children guide teachers’ reactions and actions and advocacy for our students.” In one classroom at North High School, a teacher followed ECASD’s instructions, displaying a poster in class stating: “If Your Parents Aren’t Accepting of Your Identity, I’m Your Mom Now #freemomhugs.”

Agenda driven evil.
 
"Agenda driven evil", said by someone whose political posts have uniformly lain somewhere between vile and dishonest on the one hand, evil and dishonest on the other. Right.


EDIT: I mean...seriously... a child with parents who reject them (emotional abuse at the least) turns to the only person they can turn to - her teacher - and Renae's like omg that's evil, the teacher should mimic the parents' emotional abuse of the child!

Eau-Claire-3.jpg


That's the kind of thing she's calling evil. Telling children that religion is not the problem, but someone using religion to crush them spiritually and emotionally is. What's she want? Teachers to tell these kids that God hates them, if that happens to be what the parents want?

Guess what. Some parents are shit-awful and never should have had a child.
 
Last edited:
Parents already decided their child's sex. They shouldn't be tasked to do it yet again.
 
First four names that pop up when looking for who’s behind America First Legal.

1662665174784.webp

Where do you find this tripe?
 
View attachment 67411629


Agenda driven evil.
The article is about a lawsuit seeking to forcibly prevent teachers from encouraging children to transition, and forcing them to reveal a child's reported gender identity to their parents.

Is this lawsuit what you are saying is the agenda driven evil, or is the teacher's freedom to discuss gender identity with children and their freedom to not mention a child's gender identity to their parents what you consider evil?
 
First four names that pop up when looking for who’s behind America First Legal.

View attachment 67411630

Where do you find this tripe?
The usual "I cannot defend this so let me try to destroy the messenger" approach. IF you can show they are lying about the schools actions, please provide that, that would be useful. What you have done is show you're intellectually lacking the ability to debate the matter.
 
The article is about a lawsuit seeking to forcibly prevent teachers from encouraging children to transition, and forcing them to reveal a child's reported gender identity to their parents.

Is this lawsuit what you are saying is the agenda driven evil, or is the teacher's freedom to discuss gender identity with children and their freedom to not mention a child's gender identity to their parents what you consider evil?
USING TEACHERS AND SCHOOLS TO HIDE LIFE CHANGING DECISIONS FROM PARENTS IS ****ING EVIL. Had someone tried that with my kid? There would have been violence.
 
USING TEACHERS AND SCHOOLS TO HIDE LIFE CHANGING DECISIONS FROM PARENTS IS ****ING EVIL. Had someone tried that with my kid? There would have been violence.

I don't agree with using violence but I do agree with your point and don't like the idea of teachers (adults) and students (minors) keeping secrets from parents, no matter what it's about.
 
The usual "I cannot defend this so let me try to destroy the messenger" approach. IF you can show they are lying about the schools actions, please provide that, that would be useful. What you have done is show you're intellectually lacking the ability to debate the matter.
No, Renae, all I have done is called out more of your manufactured outrage, I guess you have been getting good service from the carhops, lately?
 
I don't agree with using violence but I do agree with your point and don't like the idea of teachers (adults) and students (minors) keeping secrets from parents, no matter what it's about.
Just saying, someone trying to set my childs life path and hiding it from me... no. NO.
 
No, Renae, all I have done is called out more of your manufactured outrage, I guess you have been getting good service from the carhops, lately?
Blah blah blah I cannot defend what this school district is doing, so "look shiney penny everyone the source!"
 
The article is about a lawsuit seeking to forcibly prevent teachers from encouraging children to transition,
A teacher should never encourage any student to undergo such a life altering procedure. That's not their job and quite frankly, it's none of their damned business.



forcing them to reveal a child's reported gender identity to their parents.
A parent needs to know if their children are identifying with a gender they weren't born with. That's a serious psychological issue that needs to be out in the open and addressed.

.
 
View attachment 67411629


Agenda driven evil.
Try putting the thread title in all capital letters as a pathetic way to make it sound even more shrill!

Oh, wait, you already have.
 
View attachment 67411629


Agenda driven evil.
Do you dream of Joe McCarthey and the John Birth Society? These people are nuts. They hate peopple like you.

The radical left is using its power inside and outside of the government to destroy our country. It is opening America’s borders, shutting down American energy, trying to take over American elections, and violating the fundamental civil rights of the American People.
At America First Legal, we are building a team of some of the nation’s best legal, political, and strategic thinkers to challenge this lawlessness at every turn. We will use every legal tool at our disposal to defend our citizens from unconstitutional executive overreach. We will also stand up against corporations that restrict free speech and violate our citizens’ civil rights.
We are committed to fighting for all Americans–regardless of race, color, religion, or creed. We will defend the rights of all Americans from attacks by anyone, in any party, who would seek to attack their freedom, their dignity, and their equal rights under the law.
For years, progressives have used the court system to attack our founding documents, undermine the rule of law, and erode our nation’s most cherished principles and traditions.

With America First Legal, we are turning the legal tables on the radical activist left.
We will wage a forceful defense of our rights, our country, and our cherished American way of life.



AFLEGAL.com/about
 
Do you dream of Joe McCarthey and the John Birth Society? These people are nuts. They hate peopple like you.
I support parents and treating children with respect not as agenda movers
 
I sure never discussed my gender identity nor sexuality with a teacher. I didn’t and still don’t find that appropriate.
Then you don't have to. Teachers are often the only adult some children have a positive relationship with. Do you think their peers would give them better info?
 
This is the extreme, fighting the extreme, impacting very few, who may be considering transgender and maybe with parents entirely against the idea, and maybe involving a school.

We have no real evidence this "woke agenda" (from the article) matches some sort of observed result.

So the far right is going to sue the potential outcome arguably driven by the far left with just about everyone else watching this mess play out.
 
A teacher should never encourage any student to undergo such a life altering procedure. That's not their job and quite frankly, it's none of their damned business.




A parent needs to know if their children are identifying with a gender they weren't born with. That's a serious psychological issue that needs to be out in the open and addressed.

.
People are either borns trans or they are not. It's not a choice to be transgender.

Who is telling you that it's a choice to be transgender, that CIS teens are choosing to be transgender? We do not choose our gender identity or sexual orientation. The vast majority of people, (+90%) are both heterosexual and cisgender. CIS and hetero people don't become gay or trans just because they watched too many Streisand movies or spectated at a Pride parade to see what it was like.



I support parents and treating children with respect not as agenda movers
Please explain this process of agenda moving, because you seem to believe in it. Do you blame this same agenda for you being trans or were you groomed by someone else, such as Mr. Rodgers and Sesame Street?

What are the steps and what is the ultimate goal?
1.)

2.)

3.)

4.)

5.)
 
Last edited:
People are either borns trans or they are not. It's not a choice to be transgender.

Who is telling you that it's a choice to be transgender, that CIS teens are choosing to be transgender? We do not choose our gender identity or sexual orientation. The vast majority of people, (+90%) are both heterosexual and cisgender. CIS and hetero people don't become gay or trans just because they watched too many Styreisand movies or went to a Pride weekend.


Please explain this process of agenda moving, because you seem to believe in it. Do you blame this same agenda for you being trans or were you groomed by someone else, such as Mr. Rodgers and Sesame Street?

What are the steps and what is the ultimate goal?
1.)

2.)

3.)

4.)

5.)
You are dishonest.
 
You are dishonest.
The entire idea of this claim is laughably absurd. The best that I can do in response is satire because there are no facts to discuss.

This is no different than it would be if it were written by Fred Phelps or Anita Bryant 40 years ago. How are trans people a threat to the county, society school, or even your church? What will society look like 50 or even 100 years from now just because trans teens are permitted to live openly and be happy as they are? Is your transition a threat to others being CISgender? How many adults or teens have you groomed to be trans if you are going to make the specious argument that grooming to change a person's gender identity is possible?

99.99% of the people who are around trans children/teens are CIS, so if grooming were possible to change a person's gender identity they would be CIS and not trans but we both know that it is not possible and it doesn't happen. The fact that some teen comes out as trans doesn't mean that they were ever CIS to begin with. They might have been assumed to be CIS, but they never were. You were never CIS, even before your transition. Are there points awarded for grooming people to be trans that can be redeemed for discounts at Sephora, Zappos, Macy's, and Neiman Marcus?


(And to think my college composition prof' said that I was a failure at creative writing. It seems that I just needed the proper inspiration) 👩
 
Last edited:
The entire idea of this claim is laughably absurd. The best that I can do in response is satire because there are no facts to discuss.

This is no different than it would be if it were written by Fred Phelps or Anita Bryant 40 years ago. How are trans people a threat to the county, society school, or even your church? What will society look like 50 or even 100 years from now just because trans teens are permitted to live openly and be happy as they are? Is your transition a threat to others being CISgender? How many adults or teens have you groomed to be trans if you are going to make the specious argument that grooming to change a person's gender identity is possible?

99.99% of the people who are around trans child/teens are CIS, so if grooming were possible to change a person's gender identity they would be CIS and not trans but we both know that it is not possible and it doesn't happen. The fact that some teen comes out as trans doesnt mean that they were ever CIS to begin with. They might have been assumed to be CIS, but they never were. You were never CIS, even before your transition.
You are dishonest. No one is staying ppl aren't trans, or suggesting to deny help to people.
 
Back
Top Bottom