• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Bernie calls Trump a 'corporate socialist'

Dans La Lune

Do you read Sutter Cane?
DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 30, 2019
Messages
15,778
Reaction score
10,638
Location
Hobbs End
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Socialist
This is how you fight the socialism attack, successfully. What's Trump's defense?

Here's the time-stamp: YouTube

 
By saying Sanders is no different.
 
Thread title: Bernie calls Trump a 'corporate socialist'

A self avowed Democratic Socialist calling Trump a corporate socialist is not a very smooth move Bernie. Point out the holes in Trump's policies which are many. Trying to paint him with the same brush you have painted yourself with won't get you very far.

Interestingly, I saw one of the News Channel talking heads a couple days ago claim that he purposefully canvased Bernie supporters for months and found that a number of them did not know that Bernie had self-avowed as a Democratic Socialist. Do we actually think that will be the case if Bernie is the nominee and the GOP starts pounding him with attack ads?
 

Except it’s not the same brush. Trump directs wealth towards corporations, Bernie directs wealth towards the people.
 
Wow, Sanders nullified the attack that easily? Democrats have been running for 'socialism!' for no reason?

More or less since democratic versions of "socialism" largely are not.
 
Except it’s not the same brush. Trump directs wealth towards corporations, Bernie directs wealth towards the people.

A socialist is a socialist. Put any adjective in front of that noun you want to and it does not amount to a dimes worth of dif. Bernie called Trump a socialist and that comes off as painting Trump with the same brush Bernie himself has avowed to.

Simply sounds gimmicky.

Socialism is socialism. Democratic Socialism is simply Socialism pinned onto a Democratic political process. I simply do not know what a corporate socialist is. That is an oxymoron though it might play with the Bernie crowd.
 

Corporate socialism is corporate agribusiness getting billions of taxpayer monies to help stay afloat while the trade war kills off the family farms..Yeah, that oxymoron.
 

Bernie is talking about how corporations get away with not paying taxes billion dollar corporations. And 83% of the tax cuts went to the rich

When Democrats view the rich not paying their fair share. That's a freebie. I know the right doesn't look at it way but we do. So do most people!
 
It makes as much sense as trying to call Bernie a "socialist". He's not. Socialists want government to own the means of production.

Sanders just wants more government involvement in provision of things like health care or education. That's not "ownership" of "the means of production"; nationalizing industry is, and no Dems are advocating that.
 
Corporate socialism is corporate agribusiness getting billions of taxpayer monies to help stay afloat while the trade war kills off the family farms..Yeah, that oxymoron.

That is not any sort of socialism. You need to read up on what socialism is. Once you are segregating out a particular class or demographic or type you have already busted out of any definition of socialism. "Democratic" Socialism does not segregate out a class or type which is why "corporate" socialism is simply an oxymoron and nothing more.

One common definition:
a political and economic theory of social organization which advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole.

Another:
any of various economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and administration of the means of production and distribution of goods

There is a dividing line between being a Social Democrat and being a Democratic Socialist though in some dictionary definitions the line is muddled. Liz Warren is a self avowed Social Democrat that is as close to the line as it gets and Bernie is a self avowed Democratic Socialist. The difference is that you can draw borders around how far a Social Democrat will push a Social agenda. Once a politician self avows as a Democratic Socialist he is telling you that for him, there are no boundaries to how far he will push a Social agenda. The Policies could be very similar between the two but the result could be alarmingly different.

I actually have no idea why Bernie self avowed as a Democratic Socialist except that Bernie does many things for the same reason Trump does.....to get his base salivating. Bernie cannot possibly think that the dif between a Democratic Socialist and a Social Democrat will not be exposed at some point in the political process. The Dems won't completely expose him. But should Bernie ever be the actual nominee the GOP will go after that difference with a vengeance.
 

It is fine and it is telling the truth. Some voters will be turned off by the phrase; more will be attracted to support Bernie. Bernie has always only gone up in support the more voters get to know him - the opposite of figures like Hillary and Biden.
 
That is not any sort of socialism. You need to read up on what socialism is.

No, you do.


Oh, the horror - yet trump got elected as a P-grabbing, adulterous pathological lying narcissist who is crooked, sexually assaulting dozens of women, on and on, and is utterly incompetent with no meaningful political ideology or abilities and his only economic policies being 'whatever Republicans want for plutocracy and his wrong-headed tariffs'. Bernie actually supports policies with large majority support.
 

It will be fine until the day the GOP makes it not fine and Bernie is not telling the truth. Corporate Socialist is nothing more than word salad which is not hard to figure out nor even hard to expose.
 

Socialism for the rich and capitalism for the poor - Wikipedia
 
It will be fine until the day the GOP makes it not fine and Bernie is not telling the truth. Corporate Socialist is nothing more than word salad which is not hard to figure out nor even hard to expose.

It's fine. If it's easy to figure out, all the better. If it's easy to expose it's happening, all the better. People support Bernie's policies, not trump's, which is why trump lies about his. Protector of pre-existing conditions... his head should have exploded for saying that, as he's literally fighting against Democrats in court to remove protections.
 

None of which has anything to do with Capitalism or attacking Capitalism which is part of the fabric of this country, like it or not. Socialism is a direct assault on Capitalism which is not the big bogeyman the Bernie Bros make it out to be. Corruptly abusing Capitalism is a pretty big bogeyman, not Capitalism itself. Greed is a pretty big bogeyman.

If anything labor and supporters of labor are as much at fault for defending the wrong aspects of labor or not defending it at all. That glaring weakness is as bad as the worst Corporatists you can think of. That horse has basically left the barn now though there is a road back.
 

All good with that except you will not get a Democratic Socialist to the WH given the EC. NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.

As I have said before, I will hold my nose and vote for Bernie v Trump if Bernie is the nominee. But I am convinced I will be voting for the losing side which of course will doom us to four more years of Trump.
 

You're posting gibberish. The word capitalism is useless in discussing American politics because it's vague.

I could repeat what's been said many times, but you say 'Bernie Bros' and I have a general that anyone who uses that phrase is not worth talking to.
 
Many people think socialism means government handing out "free stuff' and "equality".

That is NOT what socialism is. . . Not even close.

Gallup Poll found that only 17% of Americans could define socialism correctly.

The Meaning of "Socialism" to Americans Today
 

Good for you. Stop talking to me then. "Capitalism is vague." Now there is a great argument.
 

Let's make most of our discussion of economics in the US about tulips. Pro-tulip, anti-tulip, it's all about tulips.

Sound crazy? And yet that's exactly the case about "socialism", which has nothing to do with American economics, as far as what 'socialism' actually is. Less than one percent of the country wants to have the government own all means of production, and so the people who rant about 'socialism' are ignorant, dishonest, or both.

As I've long said, we lack the vocabulary to actually discuss economic systems/issues in the US. Everyone is for some balance of government programs and private systems, but that can't discuss that realistically, all they can do is yell 'socialist' at one side and they don't even have a good word for the other so they use words like 'greed'.

It's gibberish. But Bernie talks about policies that are good policies, and luckily most Americans agree, and that's why he became the most popular politician in the US.
 
Bernie cannot beat Trump, he's just another old white guy that the millennials don't like. Mayor Pete is the guy that can beat Trump, he will bring all the young voters out…
 

Actually there is Social Democracy which you seem to ignore for tulips and weird Wikipedia economic theory nonsense. Social Democracy IS the middle road. Social Democracy does not really require a retooling of Capitalism which like it or not is part of the fabric of this country.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…