• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Ashley St. Clair Says Elon Musk Withdrew Child Support Over 'Disobedience'

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
110,884
Reaction score
101,161
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent

iu

3.31.25
Ashley St. Clair, who says she is the mother of one of Elon Musk's children, has accused the billionaire of withdrawing child support payments to punish her for "disobedience." It comes after St. Clair said she sold her Tesla car on Saturday to make up for Musk's alleged 60 percent cut to payments. Musk has never confirmed that he fathered a child with St. Clair, who filed a lawsuit in New York in February seeking sole custody of her son. In a separate petition, she is seeking a court declaration that Musk is the father. The custody application included screen shots of texts St. Clair said Musk had sent, in which he allegedly told her he wanted to "knock her up again" and make a "legion" of new children.

Responding to St. Clair's claims on Monday, Musk wrote on X, formerly Twitter: "I don't know if the child is mine or not, but am not against finding out. No court order is needed. "Despite not knowing for sure, I have given Ashley $2.5M and am sending her $500k/year." St. Clair later responded: "Elon, we asked you to confirm paternity through a test before our child (who you named) was even born. You refused. "And you weren't sending *me* money, you were sending support for your child that you thought was necessary... until you withdrew most of it to maintain control and punish me for 'disobedience.' But you're really only punishing your son."

Disobediance? Seems Musk is also a pud in his personal life.
 
How do our MAGA women here feel about this?

Should Musk be using his money to keep mother of one of his 13 children "obediant"? Seems like extortion. Very similar to what Trump does with Ukraine.

Back in the day, Musk identified as an athiest. But after he hitched his political star to Donald Trump, Musk today is the typical phony MAGA "Christian".

 

iu



Disobediance? Seems Musk is also a pud in his personal life.

From the link..

Responding to St. Clair's claims on Monday, Musk wrote on X, formerly Twitter: "I don't know if the child is mine or not, but am not against finding out. No court order is needed.

"Despite not knowing for sure, I have given Ashley $2.5M and am sending her $500k/year."


So to clarify, she is claiming that $2.5M payment and $500k a year are all just child support.

However now she is making 60% less on that half a million a year or only $200k a year in child support.

Do you think any court in the land is going to find that all that money is being spent exclusively on the child?

People are free to live and do as they want and if someone wants to be a kept woman, stay at home mom or whatever that is their right but you'd best presume that whether you are bad mouthing your spouse or bad mouthing your job and company at some point there is a cost.

Sound like when she was his favorite she got extra spending cash, now less. The man can do what he wants with is money and she was selling the car because there is no court in the world that is going to rule she needs half a million a year in child support.
 
From the link..

Responding to St. Clair's claims on Monday, Musk wrote on X, formerly Twitter: "I don't know if the child is mine or not, but am not against finding out. No court order is needed.

"Despite not knowing for sure, I have given Ashley $2.5M and am sending her $500k/year."


So to clarify, she is claiming that $2.5M payment and $500k a year are all just child support.

However now she is making 60% less on that half a million a year or only $200k a year in child support.

Do you think any court in the land is going to find that all that money is being spent exclusively on the child?

People are free to live and do as they want and if someone wants to be a kept woman, stay at home mom or whatever that is their right but you'd best presume that whether you are bad mouthing your spouse or bad mouthing your job and company at some point there is a cost.

Sound like when she was his favorite she got extra spending cash, now less. The man can do what he wants with is money and she was selling the car because there is no court in the world that is going to rule she needs half a million a year in child support.
He would be a good guest on Jerry Springer.
 
He would be a good guest on Jerry Springer.

Look at this guy with the dated references.

Springer show ended in 2018. We need a 2025 reference for trashy daytime television where people bitch at everyone for a hour.

I nominate The View.
 
Look at this guy with the dated references.

Springer show ended in 2018. We need a 2025 reference for trashy daytime television where people bitch at everyone for a hour.

I nominate The View.
The view doesn’t do trash paternity reality tv.
I suppose he could do it on doctor phil.
 
The view doesn’t do trash paternity reality tv.
I suppose he could do it on doctor phil.

I'm pretty sure I can find several articles where the trashy hosts have had to walk back or apologize for their statements.
 
I'm pretty sure I can find several articles where the trashy hosts have had to walk back or apologize for their statements.
Perhaps. I know they are a news and commentary show but that’s all I really know about it. Another issue is that Elon seems to impregnate random women so who knows how he would act on that show.

Since you know stuff about daytime tv, is the doctor phil still in?
 
From the link..

Responding to St. Clair's claims on Monday, Musk wrote on X, formerly Twitter: "I don't know if the child is mine or not, but am not against finding out. No court order is needed.

"Despite not knowing for sure, I have given Ashley $2.5M and am sending her $500k/year."


So to clarify, she is claiming that $2.5M payment and $500k a year are all just child support.

However now she is making 60% less on that half a million a year or only $200k a year in child support.

Do you think any court in the land is going to find that all that money is being spent exclusively on the child?

People are free to live and do as they want and if someone wants to be a kept woman, stay at home mom or whatever that is their right but you'd best presume that whether you are bad mouthing your spouse or bad mouthing your job and company at some point there is a cost.

Sound like when she was his favorite she got extra spending cash, now less. The man can do what he wants with is money and she was selling the car because there is no court in the world that is going to rule she needs half a million a year in child support.
Musk is a multi-billionaire, so he can certainly afford 3 million a year in child support and alimony for this child and the mother
 
From the link..

Responding to St. Clair's claims on Monday, Musk wrote on X, formerly Twitter: "I don't know if the child is mine or not, but am not against finding out. No court order is needed.

"Despite not knowing for sure, I have given Ashley $2.5M and am sending her $500k/year."


So to clarify, she is claiming that $2.5M payment and $500k a year are all just child support.

However now she is making 60% less on that half a million a year or only $200k a year in child support.

Do you think any court in the land is going to find that all that money is being spent exclusively on the child?

People are free to live and do as they want and if someone wants to be a kept woman, stay at home mom or whatever that is their right but you'd best presume that whether you are bad mouthing your spouse or bad mouthing your job and company at some point there is a cost.

Sound like when she was his favorite she got extra spending cash, now less. The man can do what he wants with is money and she was selling the car because there is no court in the world that is going to rule she needs half a million a year in child support.
I think Musk is a psycho asshole who is abusing that woman.

If paternity is determined, the courts WILL order Musk-scum to pay child support at an amount based on his income. He WILL pay more, and he WILL NOT be able to withhold it without going to jail.
 
I have mixed feelings here. On the one hand, Elon Musk sounds like a horrible father and a control freak. But as for her, this sounds like FAFO. She knew, or should have known, he was a total piece of shit before she agreed to birth his spawn. And if he actually has paid her $2.5M in child support as he claims...well, that's a lot. Not a lot for him, but a lot more than most kids will ever get.

I feel sorry for the kid though, having two train wrecks for parents. Still, I choose to save most of my pity for kids with two train wrecks for parents who don't have millions of dollars.
 
Last edited:
I have mixed feelings here. On the one hand, Elon Musk sounds like a horrible father and a control freak. But as for her, this sounds like FAFO. She knew, or should have known, he was a total piece of shit before she agreed to birth his spawn. And if he actually has paid her $2.5M in child support as he claims...well, that's a lot. Not a lot for him, but a lot more than most kids will ever get.

I feel sorry for the kid though, having two train wrecks for parents. Still, I choose to save most of my pity for kids with two train wrecks for parents who don't have millions of dollars.
I think she out to get a court order and force Musk to give a DNA sample.

When it turns out he is the father, she can then nail his balls to the wall for child support and she would then have the courts to step on his nuts every single time he tries to withhold funds.
 
Back
Top Bottom