• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

2024 Presidential Election

Will the next presidential election be decided by the House?


  • Total voters
    16

gman

DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 19, 2023
Messages
5,344
Reaction score
8,347
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
As it stands right now, there is a possibility that neither major candidate will receive the required electoral votes needed to win. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. could actually be a spoiler affecting both major party's candidate. Should that occur, what are your bets?
 
As it stands right now, there is a possibility that neither major candidate will receive the required electoral votes needed to win. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. could actually be a spoiler affecting both major party's candidate. Should that occur, what are your bets?

Third-party candidates might siphon some votes, but they won't get any electoral votes. So the only way the election goes to the House is via a 269-269 tie, and that's extremely unlikely.
 
Third-party candidates might siphon some votes, but they won't get any electoral votes. So the only way the election goes to the House is via a 269-269 tie, and that's extremely unlikely.
True, but there remains that possibility even tho slim. But who do you think it will affect more? Don’t forget, H. Ross Perot received almost twenty million votes.😵‍💫.
 
True, but there remains that possibility even tho slim. But who do you think it will affect more? Don’t forget, H. Ross Perot received almost twenty million votes.😵‍💫.
When one candidate is an incumbent, spoiler candidates usually hurt the challenger more than the incumbent. Independents tend to vote for incumbents unless they are given a glaring reason not to and, though widely unpopular, Biden hasn't done anything particularly egregious, where Trump has done many egregious things. And given Nikki Haley's (relatively) impressive performance in the primaries, I'd say Republicans are more primed for an alternative to their candidate than Democrats are.
 
When one candidate is an incumbent, spoiler candidates usually hurt the challenger more than the incumbent. Independents tend to vote for incumbents unless they are given a glaring reason not to and, though widely unpopular, Biden hasn't done anything particularly egregious, where Trump has done many egregious things. And given Nikki Haley's (relatively) impressive performance in the primaries, I'd say Republicans are more primed for an alternative to their candidate than Democrats are.
Yeah. I tend to agree with you. Trump’s shtick has definitely turned a lot of independents off and he really needs them more on top of his 30% diehards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lwf
Yeah. I tend to agree with you. Trump’s shtick has definitely turned a lot of independents off and he really needs them more on top of his 30% diehards.

Trump's ceiling is very, very low. The problem for Biden is that he is losing working class and working poor households, particularly among people of color. This is an election in which the winner could end up winning with a lot of plurality results.

That being said, according to 538, Biden's had his strongest polling data since late October. Still not great but better than he's been doing.
 
As it stands right now, there is a possibility that neither major candidate will receive the required electoral votes needed to win. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. could actually be a spoiler affecting both major party's candidate. Should that occur, what are your bets?
RFK will only be the spoiler if he gets on the ballot of all 50 states. I think right now he's on the ballot in like … five states:
 
stg040824dAPC-800x0.jpg


RFK will only be the spoiler if he gets on the ballot of all 50 states. I think right now he's on the ballot in like … five states:
Not so. We already know who's going to win in most states, it's only a handful of states where the issue is in doubt.

And for how much the Biden campaign has to worry about, Karl Rove always has some interesting numbers. In Arizona, if the two candidates get the same percentage of each demographic as in 2020 and turnout for either the Hispanics or the 18-29 age group declines by 0.5%, Trump wins. Likewise in Georgia if Black turnout drops by 0.3% In Nevada, Democrats have a 33k lead in party registrations but that's down from 2020 by 54k, and Biden only won the state by 33k votes. Likewise, in Pennsylvania Democrats have a lead in party registrations of 399k but that's down from 2020 by 286k and he only won the state by 81k votes.
 
stg040824dAPC-800x0.jpg



Not so. We already know who's going to win in most states, it's only a handful of states where the issue is in doubt.

And for how much the Biden campaign has to worry about, Karl Rove always has some interesting numbers. In Arizona, if the two candidates get the same percentage of each demographic as in 2020 and turnout for either the Hispanics or the 18-29 age group declines by 0.5%, Trump wins. Likewise in Georgia if Black turnout drops by 0.3% In Nevada, Democrats have a 33k lead in party registrations but that's down from 2020 by 54k, and Biden only won the state by 33k votes. Likewise, in Pennsylvania Democrats have a lead in party registrations of 399k but that's down from 2020 by 286k and he only won the state by 81k votes.
My point about Kennedy is that if he's not registered in swing states, his presence is basically redundant as far as whether he will be a "spoiler."

Interesting you mention PA -- weird little poll at the end of March shows Biden up +10 if head-to-head with Trump, and only up +2 if all "major" third-party candidates were included. Biden finished March with Wisconsin and Pennsylvania in his column (going by the most recent poll taken in those states, and not the average). That means he needs, Michigan or Georgia first, then the other one or Nevada/Arizona. These are the states in play as of March since Trump is under +5 in those. First time a pathway to victory has opened for him in the polls.
 
My point about Kennedy is that if he's not registered in swing states, his presence is basically redundant as far as whether he will be a "spoiler."
Good point, and now Kennedy's on the ballot in Michigan.

Interesting you mention PA -- weird little poll at the end of March shows ...
I wouldn't take that poll too seriously, you get outliers and that looks like one. One thing I do when checking out RCP's polling is drop the "highest" and "lowest" poll and recalculate the average, precisely to get rid of outliers. For Pennsylvania currently, if you eliminate the Biden +10 and Trump +4 you get an average of Trump +0.75.

Speaking of polling, here's something interesting:

t0kTewx.jpg


Usually, what you get in the run-up to the general election is the Republican running ahead in the total number of states and the Democrat leading in the Electoral College, with the question being if the Republican can win enough of the swing states to make up the difference. I can't remember the last time I saw the Republican leading in both the number of states and the Electoral College.

And here's the current RCP Presidential No Toss-Up map:

FKfOXPr.jpg
 
Good point, and now Kennedy's on the ballot in Michigan.


I wouldn't take that poll too seriously, you get outliers and that looks like one. One thing I do when checking out RCP's polling is drop the "highest" and "lowest" poll and recalculate the average, precisely to get rid of outliers. For Pennsylvania currently, if you eliminate the Biden +10 and Trump +4 you get an average of Trump +0.75.

Speaking of polling, here's something interesting:

t0kTewx.jpg


Usually, what you get in the run-up to the general election is the Republican running ahead in the total number of states and the Democrat leading in the Electoral College, with the question being if the Republican can win enough of the swing states to make up the difference. I can't remember the last time I saw the Republican leading in both the number of states and the Electoral College.

And here's the current RCP Presidential No Toss-Up map:
This map here ( the first one -- and I have no clue if the post is going to show it?) Is how people would have voted in March, with one exception: Wisconsin would have gone blue going by most recent March poll.
 
This map here ( the first one -- and I have no clue if the post is going to show it?) Is how people would have voted in March, with one exception: Wisconsin would have gone blue going by most recent March poll.
The map is based on an average of the last five polls RCP has listed, including two in April. The RCP average currently has Trump +1. Using my "drop the highest and lowest" method, that drops to Trump +0.67.
 
It's been a couple weeks, and while RCP's main Electoral College map hasn't changed from the above post, Trump's lead on the No Toss-Ups map has grown--Pennsylvania has flipped:

bUfDX5O.jpg
 
Most recent Washington poll showed Trump. I spoke to one person already on here and got their theory. What is your theory for why that happened?
 
Most recent Washington poll showed Trump. I spoke to one person already on here and got their theory. What is your theory for why that happened?
The best pollsters will have the occasional poll that makes absolutely no sense, and I suspect that's one of them.
 
Polls in May don't count for much.
 
As it stands right now, there is a possibility that neither major candidate will receive the required electoral votes needed to win. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. could actually be a spoiler affecting both major party's candidate. Should that occur, what are your bets?
I would bet on a Trump Harris Administration.

That's the way the tally lies, each state gets one vote and more states have a Republican Majority.
 
So no change in the Electoral College count since I posted my screen shots on 4/21 & 5/8, here's how the swing states are doing currently:

  • AZ: T+4.1 / T+4.3
  • GA: T+4.0 / T+3.7
  • NV: T+5.3 / T+4.5
  • NC: T+5.0 / T+5.2
  • MI: T+1.1 / T+0.8
  • MN: B+2.3 / ----
  • PA: T+2.3 / +2.3
  • WI: T+0.1 / T+0.8
The first number is the RCP average, the second is the same with the highest and lowest poll results removed to avoid outliers.
 
I'm not convinced Minnesota is a swing state -- yet. Can you make your case to me?
 
I'm not convinced Minnesota is a swing state -- yet. Can you make your case to me?
Technically, I believe a swing state is any state where the leading candidate is within the margin of error. The latest poll (and only one within the past six months) has Biden leading by 2 with a margin of error of 4.3, so it counts.
 
As it stands right now, there is a possibility that neither major candidate will receive the required electoral votes needed to win. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. could actually be a spoiler affecting both major party's candidate. Should that occur, what are your bets?
RFK Jr is not even on the ballot in most states, I think he is up to only 7, He stands almost zero chances of even getting a few EC votes.
 
RFK Jr is not even on the ballot in most states, I think he is up to only 7, He stands almost zero chances of even getting a few EC votes.
We won’t know till the fat lady sings.
 
Technically, I believe a swing state is any state where the leading candidate is within the margin of error. The latest poll (and only one within the past six months) has Biden leading by 2 with a margin of error of 4.3, so it counts.
If that were true, I would agree with you. However, fivethirtyeight has many other polls. See here:

Ignoring the rolling average (too few polls in my opinion to really make a case either way) and looking at the poll results themselves, does your analysis still hold up? If so, why or how?
 
Back
Top Bottom