• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Why one evangelical pastor left a radicalized, post-Jan. 6 America behind

Phys251

Purge evil with Justice
DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 24, 2011
Messages
59,527
Reaction score
51,471
Location
Georgia
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Liberal

Stacy, 31, is one of a small but growing number of younger evangelical Christians who have left what they see as a religious community led astray from its faith by a fervent strain of Trump-based politics. He and other former evangelicals warn that in a post-Jan. 6 world, the movement faces a challenge in attracting and keeping young, progressive Christians alienated by its relationship with conservative politics.

The most effective messengers at pushing young people to the left are not leftists, but rightists, who have become more and more extreme in recent years. Drip, drip, drip, the exodus of young people from conservatism-turned-fanaticism probably accelerated during the trump years.
 
Yup, it can be hard to find a church that is more interested in God then American Conservatism.

I suggest people who are in this situation look for "millennial friendly" or "modern" churches. In this sense modern means applying the lessons of Christianity in a way that makes sense for what people experience today and avoids "churchy" language. If your church engages in a culture that cuts you off from daily life, by and large, you are not going to attract young people who want churches to meet them and not the other way around. Also, millennials tend to shy away from churches that have any sort of political message (liberal or conservative).

 
Last edited:
IMO the two fairly sensible approaches to Christianity would be either viewing it as being a follower of Christ and therefore applying his teachings and example to one's life, or viewing it as a set of cultural traditions and community to be adapted as needed rather than treated dogmatically or religiously.

Most of Christianity to greater or less extents, but American Evangelicalism in particular, have gone almost as far in the opposite direction to Jesus' actual example as it is possible to go: Whereas Jesus commanded his followers to give up all their possessions to help the poor, stop working for money to work for God instead, and have faith in him for their daily bread as well as for 'eternal life,' Christians have frequently insisted that you don't have to actually do a damn thing to be 'saved' and these days on top of that it's pretty common for preachers to declare that God wants you to be filthy rich! So when these guys are trying to pretend that these are legitimate doctrinal beliefs, obviously there's a fundamental contradiction there that's going to cause major problems.

It's really quite scary when you look at how many Christian preachers and 'prophets' declared that Trump was God's chosen one, right up to January 2021 and beyond. Even over here in Australia I've got some religious relatives and a pastor friend who've apparently been dragged into that whole bubble, and it's a constant struggle to understand how and why - some of them have been generally pretty sensible people in the past. Obviously there's various factors which play into it from a political angle (nativism/unease of declining demographic dominance), from the Qanon/conspiracy theory angle (desire to be 'in the know' and algorithms recommending increasingly fringe content; to which Christians who believe the world is under the implicit and soon to be explicit control of the devil are particularly susceptible): But also, from the religious angle specifically, I suspect that the tension between the 'religious truth' vs. 'cultural tradition' ways of viewing Christianity are coming to a head now moreso than ever before for several reasons, but one surprising one being that if Jesus were ever going to return (as many of these folks believe), it would have been pretty much now, 2021-22ish. For several fairly obscure reasons - some of them obviously absurd, such as 1 Cor. 15:52 saying that the end would happen at "the last trump" in the KJV - there's literally never been a time since the 1st century and never will be again when the 'signs' of the end seem so good as they had over the past decade. I think on some level most evangelicals know that, even the ones who preach against date setting, and so there's a real desperation to see the kind of chaos and conflict which they're expecting to happen beforehand. It's difficult to think of a leader who might be better expected to unleash chaos than Trump.
 
Back
Top Bottom