- Joined
- Jun 23, 2005
- Messages
- 34,601
- Reaction score
- 25,106
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Moderate
I did not know where to put this thread. On the surface it is an economics thread, but its very relative to current events so I put it here. Anyway,we have got to have a tax increase.
Right now the national debt is about 8 trillion dollars. That is about 26,000 dollars for every family in America. Whether you agree with the war in Iraq or not, it still is extremely expensive and will continue to be for the foreseeable future. This coupled with the Katrina disaster, the war on terrorism, prescription drug benefits for Medicare recipients, and congress’s usual appetite for pork is rapidly leading to unsustainable deficit levels.
Don’t get me wrong, there is still plenty of capital out there to float the federal government’s debts. Increasingly, that capital is largely foreign, but just the same, there is plenty of capital out there and we would have to borrow a lot more money that we are now before there would not be enough capital out there to float the T-bills. The problem is, and what the ideologues don’t talk about, is that the cost of servicing this debt is increasing almost exponentially. Right now we are spending about 22 to 23 cents on every dollar of federal revenue to service debt. That means that for every dollar you give the federal government, about a forth of it just pays interest. Therefore, only about 75% of the money you pay in federal taxes actually goes to pay for defense or domestic spending. As we borrow more, the cost of servicing that additional debt increases which only means there is less money to spend on defense or domestic programs….which means we just borrow more and further increase the cost to service debt. It’s a vicious cycle.
There are those who believe that we can grow our way to balanced budgets again. If that were the case, we would be well underway towards doing just that because the economy is growing and has been growing at a healthy pace.
There are those who believe that the answer is in cutting spending and not raising taxes. No doubt about it, the government wastes a chunk of the taxpayer’s dollars. This latest transportation bill is a glaring example of that. However, as much pork that there is in it, even if you were to trim out the bulk of it, you still would have huge budget deficits. Maybe if you pulled out of Iraq and Afghanistan and massively reduced the amount of money earmarked to rebuild after Katrina and seriously cut out all the pork barrel spending and all the corporate welfare and cut defense spending substantially, then you might actually have a chance at a balanced budget at our current level of taxation. However, any reasonable person knows that doing those things is not practical and is only wishful thinking. Moreover, when one considers that this president has yet to veto one spending bill, its just not going to happen.
Instead, what will happen is that we will see massive cuts to small federal expenditures like National Parks and National Forests. It is no secret that there are some radicals out there like Grover Norquist who if they had their way, would sell out our national treasures. It’s not unreasonable to believe that if we continue down the path we are going, we could one day be visiting “Sprint PCS Yellowstone National Park”. Even still, even if we privatized all the national parks and forests, we still would have a huge budget deficit because that’s such a small proportion of federal spending anyway. Even if we completely got rid of Welfare, we would still have a huge budget deficit because even welfare is not one of the largest government expenditures.
The only practical answer is to return to something like the 90s level of taxation again. No one likes a tax increase. I know that our household pays in thousands and thousands of dollars every year to Uncle Sam, but we have to pay for what we spend. That is just the bottom line. If you don’t like the spending, then vote in people who cut it out, but in the mean time, you have to pay for what you spend. If we don’t, we are headed for an economic collapse. It’s just that simple. You can argue about the perceived fairness of a flat tax, but its not practical. You can say its class warfare, but its not, its simply a recognition of the fact that it costs a certain amount of money to run the government and that money has to be raised some how. Don’t get me wrong, I am not talking about going to some paralyzing almost socialist European level of taxation, but rather I am talking about returning to taxation levels of the nineties which as history has shown was a good balance of taxation and economic growth. Either way, something has to be done.
Right now the national debt is about 8 trillion dollars. That is about 26,000 dollars for every family in America. Whether you agree with the war in Iraq or not, it still is extremely expensive and will continue to be for the foreseeable future. This coupled with the Katrina disaster, the war on terrorism, prescription drug benefits for Medicare recipients, and congress’s usual appetite for pork is rapidly leading to unsustainable deficit levels.
Don’t get me wrong, there is still plenty of capital out there to float the federal government’s debts. Increasingly, that capital is largely foreign, but just the same, there is plenty of capital out there and we would have to borrow a lot more money that we are now before there would not be enough capital out there to float the T-bills. The problem is, and what the ideologues don’t talk about, is that the cost of servicing this debt is increasing almost exponentially. Right now we are spending about 22 to 23 cents on every dollar of federal revenue to service debt. That means that for every dollar you give the federal government, about a forth of it just pays interest. Therefore, only about 75% of the money you pay in federal taxes actually goes to pay for defense or domestic spending. As we borrow more, the cost of servicing that additional debt increases which only means there is less money to spend on defense or domestic programs….which means we just borrow more and further increase the cost to service debt. It’s a vicious cycle.
There are those who believe that we can grow our way to balanced budgets again. If that were the case, we would be well underway towards doing just that because the economy is growing and has been growing at a healthy pace.
There are those who believe that the answer is in cutting spending and not raising taxes. No doubt about it, the government wastes a chunk of the taxpayer’s dollars. This latest transportation bill is a glaring example of that. However, as much pork that there is in it, even if you were to trim out the bulk of it, you still would have huge budget deficits. Maybe if you pulled out of Iraq and Afghanistan and massively reduced the amount of money earmarked to rebuild after Katrina and seriously cut out all the pork barrel spending and all the corporate welfare and cut defense spending substantially, then you might actually have a chance at a balanced budget at our current level of taxation. However, any reasonable person knows that doing those things is not practical and is only wishful thinking. Moreover, when one considers that this president has yet to veto one spending bill, its just not going to happen.
Instead, what will happen is that we will see massive cuts to small federal expenditures like National Parks and National Forests. It is no secret that there are some radicals out there like Grover Norquist who if they had their way, would sell out our national treasures. It’s not unreasonable to believe that if we continue down the path we are going, we could one day be visiting “Sprint PCS Yellowstone National Park”. Even still, even if we privatized all the national parks and forests, we still would have a huge budget deficit because that’s such a small proportion of federal spending anyway. Even if we completely got rid of Welfare, we would still have a huge budget deficit because even welfare is not one of the largest government expenditures.
The only practical answer is to return to something like the 90s level of taxation again. No one likes a tax increase. I know that our household pays in thousands and thousands of dollars every year to Uncle Sam, but we have to pay for what we spend. That is just the bottom line. If you don’t like the spending, then vote in people who cut it out, but in the mean time, you have to pay for what you spend. If we don’t, we are headed for an economic collapse. It’s just that simple. You can argue about the perceived fairness of a flat tax, but its not practical. You can say its class warfare, but its not, its simply a recognition of the fact that it costs a certain amount of money to run the government and that money has to be raised some how. Don’t get me wrong, I am not talking about going to some paralyzing almost socialist European level of taxation, but rather I am talking about returning to taxation levels of the nineties which as history has shown was a good balance of taxation and economic growth. Either way, something has to be done.