- Joined
- Sep 6, 2017
- Messages
- 3,576
- Reaction score
- 2,429
- Location
- A Purple State
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Moderate
Just call the kid "hey you"...
I just said so didn't I, please read back.
Because he was.
Yes I did, please read back.
"Wrong" and "right" are opposites are far from "meaningless
Did you not learn that at school ?
Really ?
Which "smart" people ?
And who are you to be able to characterize them as "smart" ?
What is your criteria ?
Wrong" and "right" are opposites are far from "meaningless
Did you not learn that at school ?
Yep, you say a lot and say nothing simultaneously.
You have provided no argument, evidence, or reasoning there was any “wrong” done.
This is your damn, flawed, and tiring approach, you make a claim and think it’s right and you need to do no more.
And time and again you fail to follow the damn dialogue.
You made this mind numbing reply:
Can’t follow along? I didn’t say they were meaningless.
I said, “Your claiming of “wrong” is meaningless, It is no different than someone else claiming they were “right.””
Claiming! Claiming! Claiming! Did not “learn” to follow along “at school?”
You're right, Americans do have the freedom to be assholes. Your freedom to throw a punch ends at the end of my nose. Agree or disagree?Ah, and the beauty of freedom is to refuse to call someone by a specific, requested title. You know, freedom, the very word you have expressed antipathy towards time and again at forum.
What are you so afraid of if people have this freedom?
You're right, Americans do have the freedom to be assholes. Your freedom to throw a punch ends at the end of my nose. Agree or disagree?
actually there is quite a significant population that medically is both sexes and were born that way.The only "medical evidence" to support them is called Gender Dysphoria and it is as I stated, a form of mental derangement.
There are only two genders to the human species, plus mutations, and that gender is determined by the number of the two types of sex chromosomes. Not by the twisted desires of the mentally deranged.
I would suggest an education in basic biology.
That you fail to comprehend is not my problem.
Again, I am not responsible for your limited capacity to comprehend.
You need to damn well improve your reading comprehension skills
Isn't the use of expletives fun - it makes you sound so intelligent
NB: I said "sound".
I'm not interested in the state of your mind.
Just because you deem it "wrong" doesn't make it so
You have singularly failed to demonstrate that this is the case.
Another rambling, incoherent rant, that's not untypical of your posts.
You're right, Americans do have the freedom to be assholes. Your freedom to throw a punch ends at the end of my nose. Agree or disagree?
In a Democracy, you have the right to be wrong.
Odd how you looked up "dysphoria" and not "gender dysphoria," which is the specific we're actually talking about, and which looking up would allow you to get the correct definition.From the innerwebz:
[removed to shorten wordcount]
So tell me how it that a problem for the rest of us to worry about?
We tried therapy, it just made things worse. No medications have been developed yet. That's why I said it's the only treatment, nothing else has been proven to fix gender dysphoria.OR get mental heatlthcare and [snipped to shorten wordcount] feelings of depression.
Discrimination, harassment, hate crime, lack of acceptance, etc.Sex changed transsexuals still have a high degree of suicide. Why is that?
...Because it's the only way for trans people to be able to function normally? Regardless of what you think of gender identity, all that matters is this is how you treat GD.No, the teacher just refuses to play a silly game of LYING to the student and to everyone else about what is clearly a claimed gender. Why force society to
play along with this charade?
Studies don't show that there exists a condition wherein one experiences intense "unicorn dysphoria" to the extent that it interferes with their ability to function normally. Studies don't show that attempts to treat "unicorn dysphorics" with therapy makes the dysphoria worse. Studies don't show that calling a "unicorn dysphoric" a unicorn will alleviate symptoms of "unicorn dysphoria" and allow them to function normally.If a student wanted to be called a unicorn, should we play along?
Reality is:He is teaching REALITY. One aberrant confused student does not get to reinvent natural reality for everyone else.
Non sequitur. Care to respond to my question?In a Democracy, you have the right to be wrong.
Accidental physical contact would certainly fall under this dictum. Think "the election was stolen" and the 1.6 insurrection.Assuming the intentional physical contact above, that of a punch to someone else’s nose, doesn’t fall within rational exceptions to the rule, then yes. Because there are in fact situations where there is freedom to punch another in the nose.
No you don’t get it.
All you’ve done is to claim some conduct us wrong. That’s it. You’ve not provided any evidence the conduct is wrong.
You’ve provided no supportive reasoning demonstrating the conduct is wrong. The conduct isn’t “wrong” because you say so but that is precisely your argument.
Oh wait, that’s right, you think because Vindman said it was “wrong” is evidence the conduct was wrong.
Odd how you looked up "dysphoria" and not "gender dysphoria," which is the specific we're actually talking about, and which looking up would allow you to get the correct definition.
I'm sure you didn't do that on purpose, right?
Anyway, according to the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders), in order to meet the criteria for GD, "the condition must also be associated with clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning."
In other words, the dysphoria must be severe enough that's it's making it hard for you to function normally. And that's why people with GD need treatment: so they can be functioning members of society like everyone else.
While this actually has absolutely nothing to do with you, if you happen to be a teacher with a trans student in your class, it is part of your job to accommodate them, the same way you have to accommodate students with autism and ADHD.
All this teacher had to do to accommodate this student's transition is to call them by their preferred pronouns, and he didn't even do that.
I just read this story about more drama coming from Loudoun County and the constant claim that it is parents who are threatening this out of control woke/liberal progressive school board. A parent was arrested for disorderly conduct at the school board meeting after one of the board members accused him about lying over an attack by a "gender fluid" male in the girls restroom. Police investigation confirm that a rape took place in the restroom but since it involves a juvenile the record is sealed.
This is why we need to call out the crazies for this transsexual push. It does not serve society to not have separate restrooms and locker rooms for males and females. If a restroom is just for one person at a time, then it doesn't matter. But allowing biological MALES inside of restrooms for girls is STUPID. And then beyond that this HORSESHIT that a person can claim to be a male or a female at will, and then change back their identity at will is CRAZY.
His daughter was raped at school by a male claiming to be a transsexual female.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ar...g-says-daughter-raped-boy-girls-bathroom.html
It is wrong, because people agree it is wrong
We agree that people, whose name is Peter, are called Peter.
Because people who're commissioned in the US army and hold the rank of Lt Colonel or Colonel should be addressed as "Colonel"
Similarly, people who hold a PhD, are entitled to be addressed as "Doctor"
There are web pages out there that give the correct form of address for all people with titles, decorations, awards or who hold certain offices/positions
Would you like to be pointed in the direction of one ?
Because people who're commissioned in the US army and hold the rank of Lt Colonel or Colonel should be addressed as "Colonel"
Similarly, people who hold a PhD, are entitled to be addressed as "Doctor"
There are web pages out there that give the correct form of address for all people with titles, decorations, awards or who hold certain offices/positions
Cute how you didn't address any of the studies I linked..Yeah, crazy people are crazy. What did I say that didn't agree with that?
Shall society change everything just to make crazy people feel more comfortable? I think not.
Yep, crazy people find it hard to function normally.
Autism and ADHD presents along a broad spectrum of behaviors. Some are very high functioning, some are not. An autistic child who screams all day long could not be accommodated in a normal classroom setting, and it would be unrealistic to make the school or other students be affected by that.
Why do you folks always seek to bend the rest of society to YOUR demands? Forcing teachers to call people, "it, they," or other silly things which are NOT what a person is, is forcing society to play a game we don't need to play. If the child is boy it is a HE. A girl, it is a she.
Nope
No! No! That cannot be logical.
One person saying “it is wrong” doesn’t make it “wrong”
A chorus of people signing in unison something is “wrong” doesn’t make it “wrong,”...
Your argument is the same as before...
...that is circular logic. That reasoning begs the question. The entire issue is whether there is a “should.” Once again, “should” is language reflective of ethical and/or moral conduct....
Or is this “should” just a moral/ethical rule you think exists...
Entitled? Once again, provide evidence and reasoning for this entitlement that other people are to call them by such a title....
So what? That doesn’t establish a moral or ethical rule they are to be called by those titles...
There could be a web page where someone has the “title” of “king, lord, Sir” and there’s no moral or ethical rule anyone call them by any of those titles.
Hahaha... I don't need to address any of the "studies" you require for affirmation. You can find anyone who will do "a study" that comes up with any answers you like after they get paid for that "study".Cute how you didn't address any of the studies I linked..
Do you have any proof that the method the studies used were flawed, or that the writers had some unprofessed conflict of interest? Have you researched the funding of each study and discovered undeniable proof that the many different researchers were coerced into fabricating results?Hahaha... I don't need to address any of the "studies" you require for affirmation. You can find anyone who will do "a study" that comes up with any answers you like after they get paid for that "study".
I have been specifically avoiding making arguments about gender vs sex identity, so I don't know why you're bringing reproductive organs into this? I never said the student is "actually" male or female.Address this. Study THIS, it's all so simple to figure out. Why do you ignore the obvious?
Students demanding to be referred to by either He or She have medical evidence to support it them, unlike god-king.
"gender dysphoria" is pseudo-scientific garbage(as all of psychiatry is) invented for ideological and political reasons.The only "medical evidence" to support them is called Gender Dysphoria and it is as I stated, a form of mental derangement.
What political reason did Christine Jorgenson have in 1950?"gender dysphoria" is pseudo-scientific garbage(as all of psychiatry is) invented for ideological and political reasons.
After Jorgensen’s military service, she went to photography school in New Haven, Connecticut, and dental assistant school in New York City. Jorgensen was still unhappy with her life, however, and she began to look for answers in books, hoping she might find answers. One book called The Male Hormone piqued her interest and helped explain her problems, which led her to start taking estrogen. Then, she consulted with doctors about surgeons in Europe who had already performed sex reassignment surgery. Jorgensen was determined to be transformed into a woman, and in 1950, she traveled to Denmark to pursue her dreams.
When Jorgensen arrived in Denmark, she met endocrinologist Dr. Christian Hamburger, who agreed to do the experimental procedure for free. He was the first person to diagnose Jorgensen as transsexual and not homosexual. For the next two years, Jorgensen underwent hormone treatment, psychiatric evaluations, and finally surgery to remove her male genitalia. Unfortunately, she did not receive a surgically created vagina until years later when she was back in the United States. Before she returned to the United States, she had one last alteration to make in order to complete her transformation. She changed her name to Christine in honor of Dr. Hamburger’s work of making her dreams come true.
Yes - very good to see!Good to see the court is protecting this guy from the snowflakes.